5. A snapshot of wine education through 5 different
countries (public educational system. Vocational diplomas)
|
Australia
|
France
|
Spain
|
UK
|
US
|
Wine consumption
|
22.3 (increasing)
|
53.8 (decreasing)
|
30.8 (decreasing)
|
20.9 (increasing)
|
9 (increasing). Source :
|
per capita (2006 source OIV)
|
|
|
|
|
Trade data and analysis
|
Vocational
|
Wine courses are electives in
|
Wine courses are
|
Wine courses are
|
No specific courses in the
|
|
syllabus (state)
|
all levels of education.
|
mandatory and included in all levels of the
syllabus.
|
included in syllabus and are mandatory
|
mainstream education
|
No specific, common programs, but some college
|
Accredited
|
- Certificate II in hospitality
|
|
|
- Diploma in food and
|
or university offer whether
|
programs
|
- Certificate III in hospitality
|
- CAP (Certificat
|
- Grado medio servicios
|
beverage operations :
|
elective units through
|
|
- Certificate IV in hospitality
|
d'aptitude professionnel) (2 years program) (1800
|
en restauracion
120 hours through the
|
table drink service
|
hospitality programs or sometimes a full wine
|
|
- Diploma in hospitality
|
hours + training period)
|
2 years studies. (2000
|
- BTEC levels 4 and 5
|
program including wine
|
|
|
- Baccalauréat
|
hours including
|
higher national
|
service (e.g. Santa Rosa
|
|
- Advanced diploma of
|
professionnel and Brevet
|
training period)
|
certificate: beverage
|
Junior college). Emphasis
|
|
hospitality
|
de technicien (3 years
|
|
preparation and service
|
is also done on wine
|
|
|
programme)
|
- Grado superior
|
(unit 5: food and
|
foreign countries
|
|
Hospitality students can
|
- BTS (brevet de
|
restauracion
|
beverage operations
|
|
|
graduate without studying
|
technicien supérieur) (2
|
A complete unit of 5
|
management.
|
Hospitality programs are
|
|
wine
|
or 3 years programme)
|
hours per week on the
|
Elective). Apply
|
mainly undertaken at
|
|
Students often come back to
|
|
second year
|
sensory evaluation
|
university
|
|
study wine while in the
|
An average of 1 hour per
|
(sommellerie). Wine
|
techniques to assess
|
|
|
workforce (e.g. : WSET)
|
week devoted to wine (apart
|
service is done on the
|
beverage acceptability
|
Degrees or non-degrees
|
|
Special unit on international wines (only in Sydney
for the moment)
|
wine service in restaurant) Minimal courses on
international wines
|
first year
|
(unit 27. Elective) (source : edexcel)
|
courses
|
Specific
Sommelier courses
|
Only in Sydney (TAFE) : Certificate III in hospitality
specialised in the role of sommelier
|
- Mention complémentaire
sommellerie (certificate)
- Brevet professionnel sommelier (advanced diploma)
|
- University degree in
sommellerie (Pablo Olavide university. Seville). Great
emphasis is done on foreign vineyards.
(fees around 2000 €). It is not compulsory to have an
hospitality background
- Sommelier and wine
culture courses (Logrono)
|
Only through private programs
|
Private schools.
Wine evaluation and
service certificate (not only dedicated to the sommelier job)
(Santa Rosa Junior College)
|
Waiting culture
|
No waiting culture. Waiters are usually university students.
Waiting as a career is not officially recognised
|
Waiting is strongly linked to the food culture (e.g. :
Vatel). But the job is now less attractive and no longer seen as
enhancive as before
|
|
Not seen as an attractive job. Perceived as a servile job
|
No waiting culture
|
Sommelier
|
Sommelier Australia (ASI
|
Union De la Sommellerie
|
Unión de Asociaciones
|
The Academy of Food and
|
Sommelier society of
|
association
|
observer)
|
Française (UDSF) (ASI member)
|
Españolas de Sumilleres (UAES) (ASI observer)
|
wine service (ASI member)
|
america
United States sommelier association
American sommelier association
|
Legal drinking age
|
18
|
16 (changing)
|
18
|
18 (16, 17 with a meal)
|
21
|
Number of WSET centres (source :
west.com)
|
18
|
15
|
2
|
87
|
29
|
private schools, programs
|
Court of Master sommelier, WSET
|
Few private sommelier courses.
WSET. The Macon Davayé School is the only public school in
France which authorized to prepare 3 different levels of the WSET exam
(included diploma)
|
WSET
The Wine Academy of Spain (TWAS) is a private organisation
devoted to the promotion of the Spanish wines
|
WSET (accredited by the QCA)
Importance of the Master of wine
|
Society of wine educators (non-profit organization) International
sommelier guild (Master sommeliers similar title as master of wine in UK and
Sommelier diploma program, 6 month International program)
|
5.1. Australia
«In Australia education is delivered through a network of
Training Packages designed for each industry. The package is the Tourism
Hospitality and Events Training Package and has a number of qualifications
leading to job outcomes.» (Clive Hartley Senior Head Teacher, Food &
Beverage/Event Management TAFE, Sydney).
- Waiting as a career is not officially recognised as an
apprenticeship by the government - Only few restaurants can afford to employ a
sommelier. The role is usually taken by the owner or the restaurant manager
- Wine lists in many suburbia and country towns are very small
and offer only local wines
- Wine consumption per capita : 22.3 (2006)
- The hospitality industry has never officially recognised the
job (sommelier). - Many Australians tend to find the sommelier intimidating.
- Things are changing and the Sommelier Association is becoming
more important - Hospitality students can graduate without studying wine
- Each qualification is devised and discussed by bodies with
representatives in the hospitality industry. The number of wine units are
increasing
- Students leaving the courses do not have the skills and
knowledge to be able to talk confidently about wine
- Customers in Australia are becoming more knowledgeable and that
can be a disadvantage for the students
- Students come back to college to pick up specialist knowledge
on wine and enrol in short courses
Advanced diploma of hospitality:
28 core units must be completed
15 elective units must be completed
Career opportunities: food and beverage manager, executive
chef...
Wine courses are electives:
- Serve food and beverage to customers 110 hours
- Provide food and beverage service 80 hours
- Provide table service of alcoholic beverages 50 hours
- Conduct a product tasting for alcoholic beverages 40 hours -
Provide specialised advice on imported wines 40 hours
- Provide specialised advice on Australian wines 40 hours -
Manage the sale of service of wine 80 hours
Table 2. Source: Assessment guide diploma Tafe
|