IMPACT OF THETYPE OF THE CROSS SECTIONAL PROFILE ON
URBAN ZONES ROAD
OBOUNOU ASSOUMOU Moise Edgard
July 2015
A dissertation presented in partial fulfillment of
the requirements for the award of a postgraduate diploma in technical education
option publics works (DIPETII)
Department of Civil Engineering and Forestry
Techniques University of Bamenda
CERTIFICATION
I hereby certify that this thesis entitled
«IMPACT OF THE CROSS SECTIONAL PROFILE ON URBAN ZONES ROAD»
has been carried out by OBOUNOU ASSOUMOU
MoiseEdgard with registration number
13T0753 in the Department of Civil
Engineering and Forestry Techniques and of the option
Publics Works of the Higher Technical Teacher Training
College (H.T.T.T.C.) Bambili, University of Bamenda.
Date:.......................................
Main Examiner: .........................
Signature...................................
Date:.......................................
Main Examiner: .........................
Signature...................................
Date __________________________Date
__________________________
______________________________
______________________________
SUPERVISOR:
HEAD OF DEPARTMENT:
Dr. KAMDJO Grégoire
Pr. YAMB Emmanuel
Signature:.............................
Signature:.........................
DECLARATION
I hereby declare that I am the sole author of this thesis. I
authorize the Higher Technical Teacher Training College (H.T.T.T.C.) Bambili to
lend this thesis to other institutions or individuals for the purpose of
scholarly research.
I understand the nature of plagiarism, and I am aware of the
University's policy on this.
I certify that this dissertation reports original work by me
during my University project.
Signature Date
...........................
............................
DEDICATION
v To The lord
v To My beloved Father ASSOUMOU OBOUNOU Jacob
v To My beloved Mother EKOMESSE Sylvie Francoise
v To my whole family
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
This work wasperformedat the University
ofBamendaandparticularlyat the Higher Technical Teachers Training College
(H.T.T.T.C) of Bambili. In a challenging environmentanda limited time,the
outcomeof thisstudy wasmade ??possible by thecontribution of many peoplewho
have supportedmethroughoutthis ordealby theirmoralcapital,financial,
andscientificequipment.
I extendmy sincere thanks:
Ø To Pr. AKUME Daniel AKUME, Director of the H.T.T.T.C
Bambili
Ø To Pr.YAMB Emmanuel Head of Civil Engineering and
Forestry Technics department, for his constant availability and his endless
encouragement, confidence in ourplace, patience, and interest and vigor brought
to this work. He guided me and advice throughout the course and writing it. It
is her expression of my profound gratitude.
Ø To Dr. KAMDJO Grégoire, my Supervisor, for
having offered me help and advice for this dissertation.
Ø All those which from near or from far contribute to
the realization of this work.
ABSTRACT
Basing itself on the concepts of hierarchisations of the
roadway network system in urban environment, this work presents the impact, the
consequences that a bad structuring of urban space by road transportation
systems can convey.
This thesis thus presents the dimensioning of the roads, at
least the cross sectional profile, in urban environment under an aspect often
neglected especially in our country Cameroun.
In order to support this work on a strong foundation, an
observation was made on the town of Yaoundé the capital of Cameroun; a
city which knows multiple problems in its daily functioning. These observations
were based on the figures on the linear of roadway system of the city, the
hierarchisation of the various ways components of the roadway network system of
the city, as well as analyzes of the functionality of the plan of the city,
system of transport of the city and road safety.
In order to be beneficial, by bringing something new, we
completed this work withsome proposals of standard cross sectional profile for
the various categories of ways constituting the framework of an urban space.
KEY WORDS
URBAN ROADWAY SYSTEM, HIERARCHISATION, FUNCTION, FORM, CLASS
OF WAYS, NETWORK
RESUME
Se basant sur les notions de hiérarchisations du
réseau viaire en milieu urbain, ce travail présente l'impact, les
conséquences que peut apporter une mauvaise structuration de l'espace
urbain par des voies de communications routières.
Cette thèse présente donc le dimensionnement des
routes, du moins le profil en travers, en milieu urbain sous un aspect souvent
négligés surtout dans notre pays le Cameroun.
Afin d'appuyer ce travail sur une base solide, une observation
a été faite sur la ville de Yaoundé la capitale du
Cameroun ; une ville qui connait de multiples problèmes dans son
fonctionnement quotidien. Ces observations ont été basées
sur les chiffres du linéaire de voirie de la ville, sur la
hiérarchisation des différentes voies constituants le
réseau viaire de la ville, ainsi que sur des analyses de la
fonctionnalité du plan de la ville, du système des transports de
la ville et de la sécurité routière.
Afin d'être bénéfiques, en apportant
quelque chose de nouveau, nous terminons ce travail par des propositions de
profil en travers types pour les différentes catégories de voies
constituant l'armature viaire d'un espace urbain.
MOTS CLES
VOIRIE URBAINE, HIERARCHISATION, FONCTION, FORME, CLASSE DE
VOIES, RESEAU
TABLES OF CONTENT
CERTIFICATION
iii
DECLARATION
iii
DEDICATION
iv
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
v
ABSTRACT
vi
RESUME
vii
TABLES OF CONTENT
viii
LIST OF FIGURES
x
LIST OF TABLES
x
ABBREVIATIONS
xi
GENERAL INTRODUCTION
1
BACKGROUND OF THE STUDY
2
PROBLEM STATEMENT
3
JUSTIFICATION OF THE CHOICE OF THE
TOPIC
4
PURPOSE OF THE TOPIC
5
RESEARCH QUESTIONS
5
FORMULATIONS OF HYPOTHESIS
6
FORMULATION OF RESEARCH OBJECTIVES
6
HYPOTHESIS TESTING APPROACH
6
GENERAL AUDIT APPROACH
7
CHAPTER I:THEURBAN HIGHWAY NETWORK: DESIGN,
FUNCTION AND ORGANIZATION.
8
1.1. The urban roadway system: what
is it
9
1.2. Parameters to be considered
during the dimensioning of the width and the appendices of a road in urban
environment
11
1.3. Functions of a roadway system
in urban environment
14
1.4. Various categories of ways in
urban environment
17
1.5. Hierarchisation of roadways in
urban environment
19
CHAPTER II: METHODOLOGICAL
CONSIDERATION
22
2.1. Description of the course of
the data-gathering
23
2.2. Description of the environment
targets of study
24
2.3. Description of the instruments
of research
25
2.3.1. Pneumatic sensors
25
2.3.2. Electromagnetic loops
26
2.3.3. Acoustic detectors
26
2.3.4. Radars with Doppler-Fizeau
effect
26
2.4. Description of the model of
study
27
2.4.1. The legibility and
functionality of the plan of the city
28
2.4.2. Requirements of temporal
delimitation: rush hours.
28
2.4.3. The functioning of the
transport system
28
2.4.4. The road safety
34
CHAPTER III: PRESENTATION OF THE RESULTS
AND DISCUSSION.
35
3.1. The legibility and
functionality of the plan of the city
36
3.2. The functioning of the
transport system
42
3.3. Impact in the field of the road
safety
53
3.3.1. Human factors
55
3.3.2. Factor vehicles
55
3.3.3. Infrastructural factor
55
3.3.4. Factors influencing the
quality of the road studies
57
GENERAL CONCLUSION AND RECOMMANDATIONS
60
4.1. Recall of the working
hypotheses.
61
4.2. Proposals of standard cross
sectional profile.
62
4.2.1. For the primary roadway
network system:
62
4.2.2. For the secondary roadway
network system
64
4.2.3. For the tertiary roadway
network system
65
ANNEXES
66
REFERENCES
69
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure 1: Dendritic structure in a surface.
3
Figure
2: A pneumatic sensor for automatic counting Source: Cours de
route 2006 Université d'Orleans I.U.T de Bourges
25
Figure3:
A radar
26
Figure 4: Sequence of the two models at the time of
the study
30
Figure 5: Modeling of the zone of study
33
Figure 6: Schematization of a system of
circulation
34
Figure 7: Repartition of the highway network system
of the town of Yaoundé
38
Figure 8: Total traffic on the roadway network
system structuring town of Yaoundé
46
Figure 9: Routes on which run times were
measured
49
Figure 10: Theoretical curve of the relation
between the flow and speed on a way
51
Figure 11: Reorganization of the offer of public
transport with anUrban Transport System of Mass
52
Figure12: Example of a multiplicity of small
islands and useless use of a STOP
59
Figure
13: Modeling of national roads forwarding in the city
63
Figure 14: Modeling of fast tracks
63
Figure 15: Modeling of the different types of way
for the secondary roadway system
64
Figure 16: Modeling of a way of the tertiary
roadway system
65
LIST OF TABLES
Table 1: listing of the districts constituting the
zone of study
3
Table 2: Indicators of roadway cover of
Yaoundé
36
Table 3: Hierarchisation of the highway network
system of the GIS of the town of Yaoundé
37
Table 4: Distribution of the traffics in the town
of Yaoundé
40
Table 5: State of the road in the town of
Yaoundé according to the GIS of the YUC
41
Table 6: State of the priority ways of
Yaoundé in 2006
42
Table 7: Numbers of ways by direction in the
streets of the town of Yaoundé
43
Table 8: Distribution of the principal traffic
motivations in the town of Yaoundé
44
Table 9: Listing of the routes
50
Table 10: Results of the investigation of running
times (in minutes) (Cars)
50
Table 11: Results of the investigation of running
times (in minutes) (Motor bikes)
51
Table 12: Numbers of road accidents in urban areas
for the year 2007
54
Table 13: Average road accidents per day recorded
during the year 2008 in the center region
54
ABBREVIATIONS
DSCE: Document de Stratégie pour la
Croissance et l'Emploi
GIS: Geographic Information System
MAETUR: Mission d'Aménagement des
Territoires Urbains et Ruraux
MINDUH: Ministère du Développement
Urbain et de l'Habitat
MINTP: Ministère des Travaux Publics
PDU: Plan de Déplacements Urbain
PDUY 2020: Plan Directeur d'Urbanisme de de la
ville de Yaoundé horizon 2020
PSU: Plan Sommaire d'Urbanisme
RGPH: Recensement Général de la
Population et de l'Habitat
TOR: Terms of References
UTSM: Urban Transport System of Mass
YCC: Yaoundé City Council
GENERALINTRODUCTION
BACKGROUND OF THE STUDY
The roadway system is the whole of the road
transportation routes serving a given space. Thus, when one speaks about urban
roadway system, we refer to the whole of the highway network of the aforesaid
urban space.
The roadway system in urban environment is characterized by
the multiplicity of the forms thatit can cover. According to the importance of
its influence, its localization within the urban space, it knows an active
range of situations from the smallest access road of the residential district
to the expressway leading to the downtown area.
Since many years already, the principle of hierarchisation of
the road transportation routes in urban environment aims at specifying the
functions of the ways with respect to their places in the transport system.
Thus, we distinguish from there ways of transit, local distributers and access
roads. This mono technical functional approach must be supplemented by an
approach relating to the interaction between the road and the environment
crossed.
The diversity of the forms of roadway systems represents the
process of appropriation of the roadway system by the various functions which
it fills. Thus, because the street service road knows a weak traffic, its space
can be largely occupied by the parking of the vehicles of the residents. Its
installation will have to thus emphasize this aspect of its use while on the
way of transit on which circulation is dominating; we will tend to reduce to
their smaller expression installations such the pavements or the plantations in
order to allot the maximum of possible space to circulation.
PROBLEM STATEMENT
The problem thus posed in this work is that of dimensioning,
of the design of the cross sectional profile of a roadway in urban area and of
its impact on the output, on the functioning of the section road to
consider.
It is therefore question of proposing a dimensioning which
depend on the frequency of use, on function of an urban road way and
neighboring social activity; of knowing how to organize, to set out
distribution of a roadway (numbers of ways, installations to be brought) in
order to make it practical according to the zone of localization and the time
period considered, especially when it is known that the urban environment in
Cameroon is characterized by a remarkable disorder.
In fact, for any road study:
· The alignment is a sight in plan of the highway design
(the center line of highway, various widths) in its environment support. It is
composed of a succession of segment of right-hand side (general alignments)
connected by curves which are either of the clothoïdes or of the circles
or a combination of both (clothoïdes and circles)
· The longitudinal section is a cut carried out
longitudinally along the axis of the road (defined by the alignment) and
perpendicular to the original ground. It consists of a succession of slopes and
slopes connected by circular or parabolic elements and is conceived after the
final choice of the alignment
· The cross sectionof a road is represented by the layout
of the roadway and the original ground on an orthogonal vertical plan with the
center line of highway. In other words, it is a cut perpendicular to the center
line of highway and original ground (on the longitudinalprofile). It gives as
other information, the various dimensions of original ground, projects, the
gauge (width of the road), etc.
Thus, talking of cross sectional profile for a road project
mean to integrate these three defined terms because the study of the cross
sectional profile of a road could not be isolated from the
longitudinalprofilewhich itself is dependent on alignmentof this road.
But, the problem as posed up will treat mainly dimensioning of
the gauge, of the width of the roadway. In fact, throughout our document, we
will speak about cross sectional profile with regard to the distribution, the
number of ways and dimensions which comprise the roadway itself and various
installations which can be annexed there in order to improve its
effectiveness.
JUSTIFICATION OF THE CHOICE
OF THE TOPIC
Our study isinfluenced by a contextin which Cameroon fixed
itself as objective to be an emergent country at horizon 2035. The reaching of
this major goal will be done by the achievement of multiple secondary or
specific objectives as presented in the DSCE, in particular those having link
with the urban development such:
· The development of the urban infrastructures
(construction of 150 km roadway system and construction of 17000 social
housing),
· The maintenance and the rehabilitation of the urban
infrastructures,
· Improvement of the access to the basic urban
services,
· Control of the occupation of the ground,
· The protection of the vulnerable social groups and,
Thus, the urban development being made mainly by creation,
equipment and the maintenance of the road infrastructure, it is therefore in
this spirit that the DSCE envisages a number of km of urban roadway systems
built since 2010 which will pass to 63 km in 2015 to 150 km in 2020.This urban
growth will inevitably be done by the means of an increase in urban population
(estimates making state of a rate of urbanization of 57,3% in 2020 according to
the DSCE), and thus, of important urban displacements.
However, in this policy of the improvement of the frame of
life on the national territory in general and in the various urban centers in
particular, how to boost or how to improve the output of our cities which are
not very productive with the sight of the multiple problems to which they face
such as difficulties of installation of effective and durable transport system,
the problems of traffic jam, etc.? In order to bring a solution to these
problems, we propose to focus throughout this work on the installation of the
roadway system which ascertains to be the structure carrying the urban
development. How to improve the characteristics of the roads in our cities in
order to improve their productivity? Which is the impact of the profile across
a road in urban environment?
Such are the various questions which found the
justification of the choice of the present thesis.
PURPOSE OF THE TOPIC
Just like it was underlined in the heading of this thesis, we
will attach throughout this work to seek if the profile across a roadway in
urban environment has an impact on its output.
The aim had here is that of presentingthe importance of the
hierarchisation of the roadway network system of a city and the impact of its
presence or absence on the functioning of the town. Indeed space being one of
the major factors or the most important limiting factor of urban environment
growth's, it is question of building roads allowing to evacuate a more or less
important flow of vehicles and this with an optimal width because if the road
is narrow, the evacuated flow is reduced and it is the function, the utility of
the road which is called into question; on another side, if the road is too
broad, the economic and socialaspects are the problems because of the costs of
construction, of the operations of expropriations, compensations and
displacements of the bordering populations.
The present study finds all its importance in the fact that it
makes it possible to show the narrowness relation existing between the category
of a way in urban environment, its width and its output. All this having for
finality a profit so much on the financial plan, sedentary and social when
designing and/or the refitting urban roads by the various competent services.
Thus, instead of increasing a road independently of his category or his
localization, we could either make particular lay out or to organize it better,
which would make it possible to make important financial profits or then if
necessary to precede any enlarging or installation work by a study of traffic
in order to estimate and to envisage the efficiency of the aforesaid work.
RESEARCH QUESTIONS
What is the impact of the type of a cross sectional profile of
a road in a urban zones area?
This main research question intends to answer the following
specific research questions:
· Does the categorization of a roadway system of an urban
area have an importance?
· Does the cross sectional profile, the width of a road
and the various installations that it has, change its functionality in the
urban area?
FORMULATIONS OF
HYPOTHESIS
It is reminded that throughout our study we will limit
ourselves to road infrastructures in urban environment. Indeed the hypothesis
on which the present report will be based is the following one: the
type of the cross sectional profilesof a roadway on urban zone have an impact
on the output of the aforesaid road.
· The categorization of a roadway system of an urban area
has an importance.
· The cross sectional profile, the width of a road and
the various installations that it has, can change its functionality in the
urban area.
FORMULATION OF RESEARCH
OBJECTIVES
The main objective of this study is to present the impact of
the cross sectional profile, the width of a roadway on the efficiency of a road
in urban environment
In order to ensure this study, meet its purpose, the specific
objectives are:
· To underline and to present the importance of the
hierarchisation of the lanes in an urban environment, then we will list the
various parameters entering the process of hierarchisation of a lane in urban
environment.
· Present a standard cross sectional profile, a width of
a road and various installations that can change its functionality in the urban
area. By-there, we intend to define for example, a number of ways having each
one a precise function and according to the case allocated with a particular
traffic (private cars, exclusive right of way, two wheels, etc.); once this
traffic, this use to determine, we will allow ourselves to propose a
dimensioning, a standard structure to adopt.
HYPOTHESIS TESTING
APPROACH
In order to verify our hypothesis we will follow the following
testing approach:
v Verification of the impact of the cross sectional profile on
the functionality of the town.
v Verification of the impact of the cross sectional profile on
the transport system.
v Verification of the impact of the cross sectional profile on
the road safety.
GENERAL AUDIT APPROACH
Throughout this document, we will follow the following general
audit approach
v Generalities on roadway system and hierarchisation of road
in urban environment,
v Methodology and materialsused
v Presentation and discussion of results
v Conclusion and recommendations
CHAPTER I:THEURBAN HIGHWAY
NETWORK: DESIGN, FUNCTION AND ORGANIZATION.
«What is awaits from a research task is the
originality. It is not a question of a quality in oneself, but of a step: the
purpose of a report, a thesis, an article, are to bring something new, of
original. The originality is all the direction of the review of literature. It
is necessary to master what was already made as regards research to be able to
position its own research so that it brings something moreover, so that it is
original (at the border of the knowledge and the
not-knowledge)»(Dumez, 2011, p. 17).
Throughout our research task, in which the purpose is to
discover or establish the existence of the relation between two common aspects
of the urban roadway system: the gauge of a way and its output, we leaf through
several documents, articles and theses going in the direction of our research.
Thus, in order to be a scientist during this study, we have judge adapted to
start by defining the term urban roadway system.
1.1. The urban roadway system: what is it
The roadway system is historically definite like the whole of
the transportation routes of a territory given i.e. the whole of the
infrastructures necessary to support the circulation of the goods and people in
the aforementioned locality. However, in urban environment, the roadway system
is collective before being an infrastructure dedicated to the only circulation;
it is a social space which structure urban space(d'ARCIER, 1992). On another
side, the roadway system appears being a basic urban transport infrastructure
and like such, it is defined as being a fixed public installation being used to
provide essential services(NOUNDJEU, 14 au 15 février 2011). From these
definitions, it comes out that to have for object of study the urban roadway
system, it is to make a study which will have to take into account several
forms and point of view as well technical as social. The urban roadway system
thus proves to be the carrying structure, tallies of the development according
to the old proverb which says: «where the road passes, the
development follows.»
In urban environment, that always applies and even with an
impact much stronger because one very often saw real estate goods and others to
be object of important speculations after the built of a more comfortable
access road was restored. Bruno FAIVRE d'ARCIER (1992) puts forward this aspect
developing and devaluing by the road in urban environment in his thesis la
voirieurbaine: de l'accumulation à la gestionpatrimoniale. The
roadway system is, consequently this network, this infrastructure of
communication around of which will organize the life in urban environment (in
all or if not, large majority of the circumstances). The urban roadway system
will thus be characterized by its multifonctionnality, the multiplicity and the
diversity of the users whom it gathers;In its thesis, B. FAIVRE d'ARCIER (1992)
made a short summary of the various possible approaches of definition of the
urban roadway system: like public domain, like infrastructure, network and
space.
· In the approach of the roadway system like
network, the roadway system is comparable with a whole of sections and
crossroads primarily being used with circulation of the goods and the people to
the means of modeof transport motorized or not.
· The approach infrastructure, which is
prevalent for the town planning engineering, is based on the concept of
network, but privileges the roadway system like basic infrastructure rather,
support of other network (electricity, water, telephone, etc.)
· In the approach of the roadway system like
space, prevalent for the architects and the town planners, the roadway
system is seen like a volume and constitutes an element of the urban landscape.
In addition to that, for the town planners, the urban development and of its
activity is closely related to the conditions of accessibility in a context
where it is necessary to differentiate the places of residence and the places
from activities.
· The approach in terms of domain which
is used as pillar to legitimate the intervention of the public authorities
because it allows given again the public space which is the roadway system, its
place vis-a-vis approaches of the functionalist types.
The following quotation, from the general guide of the urban
roadway system as cited by(d'ARCIER, 1992, p. 2)thus appears to be, we think it
enough adequate to summarize the point of view supported up: «what
characterizes a street, it is its complexity the multiplicity of its roles. It
accommodates activities which should be served, it is to border of trade, it
shelters the walk or the rest of the townsmen, it ensures the service road of a
district while supporting calm residents, or even it runs out an important
traffic that it is necessary to reconcile with a correct environment with the
inhabitants».(CETUR, AIVF, 1988)
Of all what precedes, it is thus clear that the concept of
design of street could not be universal or at least, should more or less adapt
according to whether one is in such or such medium where the social behaviors
and the daily intrigues differ, question of guaranteeing the safety of the
motorists and the residents which interact both with the road: it is clear that
we does not drive in the same way on an urban boulevard as on one street
crossing a market or a road access in full district. The design will have to
implementfactors which will have to make recognize with the motorist function
(service road, fast track, etc.) of the way where it is, and thus, to lead it
to adapt its speed which would be finally only the translation, in terms of
control, of this function.With respect to the road safety, it is important that
installation makes it possible to the motorists to correctly identify nature
and the uses of the way which they borrow so that they can anticipate, to some
extent, the inherent risks has this space and thus to adapt their behavior (in
particular their speed) has these characteristics (the space). In their
articles,(BRUSQUE, MENARD, MONTEL, DUBOIS, & RESCHE-RIGON, 1997)starting
from an experimentation of categorization carried out using catches of sights
of urban sites, identified the categories of ways which the various users and
the criteria from differentiated which these categories are constituted. They
pushed their work further by evaluating also up to what point night environment
modifies the mental representations than the users have this space.
1.2. Parameters to be considered during the dimensioning of
the width and the appendices of a road in urban environment
Because the roadway system in urban environment is in the
center of multiple waiting, it is being a subject transversal, object of
several centers of interest and fields of studies.
As follows:
· In space economy and economics of the transport, the
roadway system is largely taken into account like network of circulation. In
these two sciences, the creation and/or the improvement of the quality of a
transportation route (road way) have for principal drank the production of
easement rights to space and the reduction of the constraints of distances. The
roadway system, its quality and its quantity are thus to have a contribution,
an economic impact on the exchanges, the localization of the activities and the
valorization of spaces.
· The town planners as for them, foresees the creation of
transportation route like factor of urban development. Indeed, they have there
recourse like tool of planning and structuring of urban space.
· Civil engineering as for him perceives installation the
roadway system like a transport infrastructure and like such, the aim had
during the construction of a road remains the improvement the speed of course
and comfort as well in urban environment, sub urban as in open country. Like
result, we have «a very road treatment, which denies practically the
existence of other uses, or segments the roadway space in two components which
is unaware of, the roadway and the remainder»(d'ARCIER, 1992, p.
5)
In order of not to be dispersed in our study, we will take
into accounts (generally) two of the four approaches of definition of the
roadway system stated upper: approach of the roadway system like space and that
of the roadway system like network:
Indeed, insofar as the roadway system appears being to regard
as a space, the aim had during its creation is to conceive a roadway system
which will fit (with esthetics) in the urban panorama just as it will have to
make it possible to serve different the poles from activities composing urban
fabric: zone of activities, residential zones, retail parks, etc.
On another side, to foresee the roadway system from the
infrastructure point of view supposes that a good road, a well done roadway
system should allow the circulation of the goods and people within better times
(speed factor) and under conditions of optimal comfort and safety.
This double aspect can be retaking and further in a rather
realistic way in two models(STRANSKY, 1995) :
A first model which has a representation, «where the
street is cut out in fragments and absorbed by the pieces which border it, the
«circulation» dimension of the urban space-roadway system can only
miss.» (STRANSKY, 1995, p. 14)and a second says model of traffic
where, all that is not flows car and strict roadway with the direction of the
term (expressed of «number of ways») is evacuated.
Which are the stakes, the impacts of
installation, the improvement of a «cross sectional profile»1(*)of a road in urban
environment?
This interrogation rests on the difficulty of a bond between
two characteristics of the roadway system in urban environment:
On a side, we have his function which is to seek the
displacement of the goods and the people from one place to another of the city
by the means of vehicles motorized or not.
Here, it does not matter the sector, the frame of life
crossed, the priority remains granted to the traffic which must circulate under
optimal conditions and deadlines reduced.
On another side, we have his form which it, deal with its
configuration, dimensions which are to allot to him, «its cross
sectional profile». The governing idea here remains that of the
priority of the place where the road passes: When it is a medium where it does
not interfere with the framework of life of the bordering populations, then
there is no objection so that it is as broad as possible2(*)(with all that implies like speed
of circulations and noise pollutions).Only when it has to crossmiddle
assiduously attended by the Man, it must adapt.
Only, formulated in this manner, this question proves to be
rather broad and dispersed to be able to be used as starting point with a
research task. In order to limitit extent, we (in the sight of the type of
research task3(*) of this
memory) will subdivide this principal interrogation into questions, the
objective being to best encircle it.The options selected are in particular: is
it necessary to treat influence of the form on the function, or that of the
function on the form?
The difference between these two alternatives lying in the
fact that, in the first case, the idea is that of a space configuration of the
roadway infrastructure taken as being a fixed data which one wonders whether,
which and how are the influences which it has on the characteristics of the
traffic which it supports; a priori, and whatever the definition of the
traffic, this type of study concerns the behaviors of the motorists placed in a
given situation. In the second option, research is evolutionary since it would
be a question of studying the process of evolution of the space configuration
(in terms of installations, inter alia) of rue when it changes
function-displacement. We chose to interest us, in this memory, with the
second aspect of the question; that of a possible influence of the function on
the form.
The encyclopedia(LAROUSSE, 2009)definite the city like a
relatively important agglomeration and whose inhabitants have community
activities diversified in particular in the tertiary sector.
This concentration of inhabitants in a rather reduced surface
creates important constraints more especially as it is necessary to manage and
ensure displacements of the aforesaid populations from one point to another of
the agglomeration and for various reasons. One of the means if not the
principal means of organizing and of making profitable an urban space remains
by creating there transportation routes which will have to fill of the
different functions.
1.3. Functions of a roadway system in urban environment
Indeed, during the estimates in study of traffic with the
macroscopic model4(*)(COSTESEQUE Guillaume, Avril 2012), the streets
(minors) are supposed to be non-existent and neglected because not being useful
which the vehicle has to fold back on the main roads (object of the study of
traffic). It is to say that during a displacement from one point A to a point B
(relatively distant) of a city, a motorist starts at the time of the first
minutes of his travel by folding back himself on one of the «main
roads» in order to go faster and carries out there most of his travel.
Arrived at the end of the course, it is folded back towards the small streets
which will thus enable him to arrive at destination. One can consequently
speak: «of bursting and folding
back»(STRANSKY, 1995).
Thus described, urban space is connected with a whole of block
made up of the various urban sectors such the downtown area, the residential
zones, etc. which the lanes will have to connect between them.
It is thus clear that the roadway system in urban environment
will have to fulfill various functions namely:
· A circulatory function because the streets are
judicious to support the displacements carried out by the motorized vehicles or
by the alternative modes (bicycle, walk, transport, etc.). This function often
induces stereotyped installations being based on the separation of the modes: a
roadway for the motorized users, of the bands or cycle tracks and the pavements
for the pedestrians.
· A function local life where the streets are also to
regard as public spaces, places of animation, user-friendliness and meetings,
relaxation, walk and even sometimes of plays for the children. This local life
pains to exist vis-a-vis installations of the «road» type which
privilege the car.
Practiced and/or authorized speeds are adapted often little to
the cohabitation between functions circulatory and local life.
However the development with the profit of this function of
local life answers 3 stakes (Direction départementale des Territoires de
l'Ain, 2013):
· A stake of social cohesion: The
experiment shows that the more speeds are raised, the more the axes of
circulation are felt as urban cuts which do not support the social relations of
vicinity. The moderation speeds thus makes it possible to weave more easily of
the bonds (space, social) to facilitate the meeting with others.
· A public health issue:
Excessive speeds induce a deterioration of the quality of the frame of life by
accentuating noise pollutions with consequences often underestimated on the
human health. Sound environment in night period has an influence on the quality
of the sleep. The moderation speeds in medium of social life thus proves to be
of a public health issue.
· A stake of public safety: The
moderation speeds supports the reduction of the number and the gravity of the
traffic accidents. It contributes in particular :
o To reduce the feeling of road insecurity which always does
not result in an important accidentology but constitutes an important brake for
the use of the walking and bicycle in particular for the children and the
elderly;
o To widen the field of view of the motorists and thus to
support the taking into account and the interpretation of information over all
the width of the roadway and around. That makes it possible in particular to
anticipate the random movements more quickly users pedestrians or cyclists in
places with strong frequentation pedestrian as in the neighborhoods of the
schools or the markets.
o To reduce the stopping distances, the violence of the
possible shocks and thus the gravity of the accidents. Indeed, an even light
reduction speed to the impact, strongly limits the consequences of an accident.
The chances of survival of a pedestrian are much higher at the time of a shock
to 30 km/h than to 60 km/h. It is advisable moreover to take account of the
reaction time of the drivers before braking vis-a-vis an obstacle. This time
is estimated at approximately 1 second whatever the speed. Thus, for example,
to 60 km/h (16,67 m/s), a motorist seeing a pedestrian engaging has thus 17
meters to traverse in front of him before it has time to start to slow down; he
will thus strike it (certainly) at full speed; on the other hand, while rolling
to 30 km/h (8,33 m/s), it largely has time to stop and avoid the collision or
at least the violence of the shock will be largely attenuated.
From these various functions, it will thus result from this
the different characteristics from the roadway according to whether one is in a
zone with strong pedestrian frequentation or machines with two wheels as in
zones residential or on the other hand that one is in zones has strong traffic
where the use of the car remains dominating such on the loop lines, ways of
penetration and those leading towards the urban center where the practice of an
high speed remains necessary and/or authorized.
From this concept of difference in characteristics of the
roadway according to the traversedmiddle, we can say that it results from this
the notion of hierarchisation of the roadway system which is particular with
urban environment. Indeed, the road which hardly starts to adapt on arrival of
the car will have to be constrained now in turn to adapt to the frequentation
pedestrian as Bruno d'ARCIER underlines it(d'ARCIER, 1992)when it quotes
A. GUILLERME at the time of a communication to the seminar of
the Urban plan «City and transport» of March 18th, 1992 which,
speaking about the first version of the highway code, stresses that the
pedestrian had the right to be informed on arrival of a car by an aural signal
and that him in return, has the duty to leave him (the car of course) the
passage. To improve the circulation terms inside the agglomeration it
is advisable to support the installation of the roadway systems on their
hierarchisations; Hierarchisation which is conceived according to two criteria
namely:
· The function of the way according to the type of
supported traffic (transit, exchange, internal service road) and the
characteristics of its installations.
· The urban infrastructurecrossed.
1.4. Various categories of ways in urban environment
The junction between the two criteria enumerated upper will
thus make it possible to distinguish four categories of ways:
· Access roads to the agglomeration built for the through
traffics such the interpolate connections which have origins and/or external
destinations with the agglomeration and which are consequently, the privileged
field of the car.
These axes, for their integration and the prospects which they
offer, can cover two categories:
o Highway axes or with highway matters of which the
characteristics can allow a high speed of about 90 to 130 km/h. These ways have
characteristics such the need for installation of the grade-separated
junctions, the prohibition of access to the bordering populations and a parking
being carried out except roadway system (out of the roadway thus on verges
envisaged for this purpose and named emergency lanes).
o The structuring ways (insub urbanzone) on which the
functional relationships to the environment are restored. Coherence in
installations on these ways ensures safety, fluidity and location: Speed is
limited and the crossings are made possible by the installation of fires and
the plates of crossings.
· Loop lines which protect the heart of the agglomeration
and the other secondary centers: they have as a function to protect the urban
centres from parasitetraffic and to connect between them axes of penetration.
These ways offers a time-saver for the exchange and through traffic while
releasing the centers of the agglomeration of any additional and useless
traffic. Their installation is completely integrated into urban infrastructure;
speed is restricted there with a limit lower than the access roads to the
agglomeration. On these ways, the principal characteristic is the optimal
research of the fluidity of circulation.
The installation of the crossroads between the loop lines and
the penetrating ones are paramount. To encourage with the use of skirtings, it
would also be necessary to offer a good legibility to the crossroads and to set
up an effective marking out.
· Ways of penetration towards the centers which will have
to support constraints arranged hierarchically according to the density of the
crossed middle: The local life on these ways becomes more perceptible.
«Generators» of displacements (trade, services and public equipment)
fit bit by bit in the urban infrastructure. The soft modes can be present, but
the place of the motorized vehicles prevails. Dimensions will have to thus be
generous for the motorized vehicles, but the characteristics of these ways
(bordering accesses very few, restriction of side parking...) would not make
economic a speed limit to 30 km/h. One can classify in this category certain
avenues and important ways inter districts as well as the majority of the ways
of zones of activities.
· Access roads intern with the various communes or
constituent districts the agglomeration. With this scale, the roadway system is
regarded as being a public space where a balance between the circulatory
functions and local life must prevail (cohabitation between the various users).
The description of the stakes showed that a limitation to 30 km/h constitutes a
good compromise between the motorized traffic flow, the safety of the
pedestrians, cyclists and the quality of the frame of life in the districts.
This typology of installation can apply to a very broad range of ways: service
roads of residential district, ways of retail parksand streets of downtown area
where bordering activities (trade, services, tourism...) a frequentation
important pedestrian and cyclist induce. She can also have the aim of
dissuading the through traffics when those have more adapted alternative
routes.
Figure 1: Dendritic
structure in a surface.
Source: MANDELBROT, B. The fractal Geometry of
Nature, W.H. Freeman, New York, 1983
1.5. Hierarchisation ofroadways in urban environment
The conclusion at which we arrives according to a study of
STRANSKY (1995), is that the behavior of a motorist, which can result in speed
that it practices on an axis given, is influenced by the elements of the
surrounding visual scene and thus can force it to adopt changes. From this
assertion, it results from it that speed practiced on a way is function of the
installation of this way. Thus, it appears for reasons of functionalities,
safety and economy, useful to adapt each section of roads during its
construction or of its requalification to the function awaited from this one
(influence of the function on the form): from where concept of hierarchisation
of the ways in urban environment.
Indeed, it is at the time of Chatre of Athens in
1933(CORBUSIER, 1957)which one really starts to grant an importance to the
adaptation of the road to the car. And due, this one did not correspond any
more to the old characteristics of the street as well by its new geometrical
characteristics, mechanics as by its speed.
The «rule of the 7V» is one of the
first rules of hierarchisation which was formalized by UNESCO in 1948(d'ARCIER,
1992, p. 27). It consists of:
V.1: national road or of province crossing the country
or the continents
V.2: municipal, standard creation of arteries
essential for an agglomeration
V.3: held primarily for mechanical circulations, they
do not have a pavement; no door of houses or buildings opens on them.
Regulating fires of colors are laid out the every four hundred meters, thus
allowing the vehicles a considerable speed. V.3 has as a consequence, a modern
creation of town planning: the sector.
V.4: the commercial street of sector
V.5: penetrating in the sector, it drives the vehicles
and the pedestrians to the doors of the houses, with the assistance of
V.6
V.7: feeding all with length the green zone sees where
are the schools and the sports.
V.8 came since, channeling the
bicycles.
By what precedes, it appears that the hierarchisation of the
roadway system in urban environment does not date nowadays and wants to be to
be a means of representing a network of ways starting from several beforehand
definite criteria. It is a tool for analysis, meeting a need for classification
and organization of the network of circulation. It can also be useful during
the programming of installations, to which it is used as reference(CERTU,
2008). It thus makes it possible to obtain profits in terms of safety, in
particular by a greater coherence between classes of ways and thus by a better
legibility of the network for the users. Nowadays, the possible forms of
hierarchisation many according to whether one is in urban environment or are
perished urban.
For the ways in urban environment, the forms of
hierarchisation are more complex. Thuswe have a hierarchisationwhichcanbe:
· Functional according to the type of connection, for
example: primary ways (structuring), secondary (distribution), tertiary sector
(service road);
· By typology according to the influence of the way in a
logic of urban development (urban fast tracks, boulevards, avenues, streets...)
;
· By typology of way according to the nature of the
bordering frame (in withdrawal, alignment, height...);
· By typology according to the social practices (local
life, places emblematic...) ;
· By an analysis multicriterion integrating the multiple
uses and needs for public space.
Hierarchisation rests more and more on the taking into account
of two principal functions: the function
«circulation» which milked with the flow that can
run out the way, and the function «local life» which
is concerned with impacts that the road has on the traversed environment. It is
thus question here of safety of the residents.
One defines the class of way according to the preponderance
granted to such or such function. The characteristics desired for these classes
must correspond to the objectives initially envisaged in the documents of city
planning namely: share roadway system, development of the alternative means of
transport, safety of the users.
Today with the example of the European countries, Germany in
particular, a hierarchy resting on two great levels is usually advised with:
· main roads where the circulatory function is dominating
on the function local life. The organization of space on these ways is
structured in theory (crossroads, crossed pedestrians...);
· zones with alleviated circulation, generalized on most
of the urban territory, but also of the zones of meeting and surfaces
pedestrians, to privilege the local life and to ensure the safety of the
various uses of the network, by moderating speeds and by eliminating the
parasitic traffics in these zones.
CHAPTER II: METHODOLOGICAL
CONSIDERATION
2.1. Description of the course of the data-gathering
By who will be carried out measurements? Who holds
the various databases necessary to the study? Which steps is it necessary to
get them? ...
Such were the questions which should prevail during the
proceed of the data-gathering.
The people to«investigate» should be selected on the
basis of data and preliminary library search, i.e. according to their
susceptibilities to have resort to the use of the data specific to urban
environment or other various data for which we had needs for our study. Among
the preselected organizations, we had: the MINDUH, different CameroonianCity
Council in particular that from Yaoundé, Douala Bafoussam and Bamenda;
various communes of district and different research department and companies
having taken part in construction and/or realization of various works requiring
such data in particular EGIS, MAETUR, etc.
At the end of this pre investigation, it was reported to us
that the Yaoundé City Council had various document of city planning
among which figure the «Plan de Déplacement de la Ville
de Yaoundé»: a document which the development
required the realization of the almost totality of the investigations and data
we needed for our study. This document, plus the «Plan
Directeurd'Urbanisme de la ville de Yaoundé 2020» and
the «Plan
Somaired'UrbanismedeYaoundéNord» et
«Plan Somaired'Urbanisme de Yaoundé
Sud» which we already had should thus constitute a reliable
source data enough for the realization of our study
So, rather than to remake the investigations and research
(which would cause important waste of time and money) we decided rather to
resort in the search of this document (the «Plan de
Déplacement de la Ville de Yaoundé»).
We thus could have it within the services of the documentation of
the YCC.
However, because of quality of the investigations carried out, of
the quantity of data provided and finally of the relativerecent of the studies
(compared to the other available), we chose to work, throughout this memory,
much more on the basis of the studies made at the time of the realization of
the PDU.
2.2. Description of the environment targets of study
The selection of the environment of study will have been
strongly influenced by the availability of the data necessary to unfolding of
the study.Once all these data defined, and their availability checked, the
following stage was to make the choice of a ground of study which would gather
the various criteria to be defined for the model. Moreover this field of study
should allow the application of the various methods of investigations and data
acquisition.
Thus, at the end of the preliminary stage of pre-collection of
the data, with the sight of the importance of the database put at our
availability we decided to make the town of Yaoundé, our environment of
study.
Capital of Cameroon and second bigger city of the country
after Douala, Yaoundé shelters the essence of the administrative
superstructure of the country and part of the head offices of the enterprises.
It is also the chief town of the Centre region. Its economic activity, the
daily mobility of the inhabitants and the offer of transport are strongly
influenced by the presence of the central public administrations.
The administrative territory of the Yaoundé City
Councilcovers a surface of 28.798 hectares. The city is located in anirregular
relief, plates staged between 700 and 800 m of altitude and the mountainous
solid masses reaching up to 1200 m of altitude. If the site presents a certain
charm, it imposes constraints on infrastructures and transport. It increases
the cost of the transport infrastructures which must be lengthened to avoid too
stiff slopes and also to include several works of crossing. Lastly, the
irregular relief increases the painfulness of the walking and the use of the
bicycle. In 2002, the urbanized site occupied nearly 16.000 hectares, that is
to say 56% of the administrative surface of the city. The average density of
urban infrastructure was of approximately 100 inhabitants per hectare. This
weak density leads to a lengthening of the distances from displacements for the
population. The climate of Yaoundé is subtropical moderate with two dry
seasons in alternation with two wet seasons and of precipitations exceeding
1.600 mm on the whole per year. The strongest rains intervene in September and
in October, period of beginning of school year. The temperatures oscillate
between 18°C and 28°C during the wet seasons, and between 16°C
and 31°C, during the dry seasons.
In 2005, according to the results of the 3rd General Census of
Populations (RGPH), the population of Yaoundé was of 1,8 million
inhabitants, that is to say approximately 10% of the population of Cameroun.
Between 1987 and 2005, that is to say 18 years, the population of the city has
almost triplet, recording an intercensal growth annual average of 5,9% per
year.
2.3. Description of the instruments of research
In order to carry out the collection of relative data to the
creation of a suitable and adapted model of study, it will have been necessary
the use5(*)of various and
different instruments according to whether needs data relative to a precise
field.
Thus with regard to thetechniques of collection of
variables of traffic, theprincipal source of data of traffic is the collection
by equipment indicated under the generic term of sensors. In general, they are
elements sensitive to a physical quantity: speed, the presence, or passaged' a
vehicle. We distinguish:
2.3.1. Pneumaticsensors
Figure 2: A pneumatic
sensor for automatic countingSource: Cours de route 2006
Université d'Orleans I.U.T de Bourges
This type of sensor consists of a rubber cable tended across
the roadway and connected to a detector; the crushing of the cable causes an
overpressure detected by a pressure gauge actuating a relai: this system thus
counts the number of axles which pass (we divides by 2 to obtain the number of
vehicles). Easy to pose and autonomous, this system is rather expensive and
fragile because it can betorn off by a heavy vehicle, moreover, the error
ratecan go beyond the 20% in saturated rate; what seems to us rather enormous:
because a variation of a few percentages is sufficient to distinguish a fluid
rate from a saturated rate.
2.3.2. Electromagneticloops
It consists of an inductive loop drowned in the carriageway
surfacing, detecting the variation of the electromagnetic field caused by
passaged' a vehicle (metal mass), which results in a «crenel of
tension» whose characteristics make it possible to know the length and the
time of passage of the vehicle. The installation of two inductive loops close
one to the other makes it possible to know the instantaneous speed of the
vehicles. The technique of the electromagnetic loops has the advantage of
being cheap and robust (important lifespan); its great weakness is the
dependence of its reliability to quality of the adjustments and
maintenance.
2.3.3. Acoustic detectors
Of current employment in Japan but not very widespread in
Europe and in the United States in spite of the facility of their maintenance,
these detectors are consisted a directing antenna emitting an ultrasonic wave;
part of this wave is considered at the time of passage of a vehicle in the
surface of detection of the device; a fraction of this considered wave is
collected by a receiver, which makes it possible to calculate the occupancy
rate of the road.
2.3.4. Radars with Doppler-Fizeau
effect
Figure2: A
radar
Source: Cours de route 2006 Université
d'Orleans I.U.T de Bourges
It is about a directing antenna emitting an electromagnetic
wave whose a fraction - after reflection on the vehicle - is consequently
collected by the same antenna; the difference between emitted frequency and
considered frequency is proportional to the instantaneous speed of the vehicle,
which makes it possible to calculate the value of the speed of the vehicle with
a precision of about2 km/hfor speeds lower than100 km/h.
Concurrently to these techniques of automatic countings, there
exist also techniques of countings said «at sight»; we
gather under this heading all the techniques based on the vision, natural or
artificial, which includes the direct observation in situ, by air photography
or via fixed cameras installed at certain places of the infrastructure.
In what concern the linear of the roadway system and similar
data such the populations of various zones, etc. we will use software of
numerical cartography and Geographical Information System in particular
ArcGIS or Mapinfo (which is used by the YCC) in order to obtain
data relating to it.
Obtaining data on operation of the transport system and the
road safety in urban environment, was made possible by the means of the
realization of investigation of ground near households and sectorial of the
field of the urban transport in particular the taxi drivers, of motor bikes,
etc. brief of the various actors and users of the various modes of
displacements intervening in the field of the urban transport.
Within the framework of our work, it is to be recalled that we
much more had recourse to final the diagnosis report of the Plan of Urban
Displacement of the town of Yaoundé which comprised already the results
of the various investigations carried out at the time of the study.
2.4. Description of the model of study
If it is true that the «cross sectional
profile», the installation of a road can have an impact on the
output of this road in urban environment, this impact should be able to be
checked or to be highlighted by the construction of a model which should make
it possible to confront this road with its output according to its category and
of the hours when the frequentation is maximum there.
The model adopted for the checking of the basic assumption of
the present report will thus have to take into account:
2.4.1. The
legibility and functionality of the plan of the city
The first of these requirements should allow an evaluation of
thefunctionality and legibility of the plan of the city and this through data
on the quantity and quality of the roadway network of the town of
Yaoundé.
Consequently, this criterion emphasizes the importance of the
structuring of space by suitable transportation routes which thus make it
possible to make readable the plan of the city just as it allow a better
functionality.
2.4.2. Requirements
of temporal delimitation: rush hours.
This criterion is relating to the period of collection of the
data: the data obtained should make it possible to know the capacities of
traffic at the hours of maximum frequentation.
Thus in order to be regarded as representative, a good
counting will have:
· To move away from the edges (January, December) and to
move away from the tops (July-August)
· The months representative of the year are the months
of: February, April, October,
· The weeks most representative of the month are the two
weeks of the medium
· The days representative of the week are: Thursday -
Friday - Saturday or Sunday - Monday - Tuesday
· The hours representative of the day are 7:00 - 10h or
16:00 - 19h what corresponds to the rush hours.
2.4.3. The
functioning of the transport system
This criterion is relating to urban mobility in the city
because it should enable us to evaluate mobility in the city object of the
study.
The models of simulation of traffic are important tools of
which the use is not limited simply to the planning of the transport
infrastructures. Daily, they can also be used for the regulation of the traffic
by testing the effects of technological innovations such as the Intelligent
Transport systems. They can finally be more generally used for the city
planning in general and the localization of the services and the urban
activities.
Thus, are studied there major elements for the urban
mobility such the offer of transport, the demand for transport, the traffic
motivations, the existing means of transport and reasons justifying their
choice during a displacement and finally the various zones between which
accomplishes transport in the zone of study. The delimitation of the zones of
transport constituting the key factor of this criterion, we renewed the model
made up at the time of the investigations carried out at the time the
production of the Urban Plan of Displacement of the town of Yaoundé.
This model of displacements in Yaoundé aimed at the
simulation of the traffic on the roads and the railroad in the city in order to
test scenarios of installation of the offer of infrastructures to check that
they would answer well the present needs (2010, date of realization of the
document) and futures of urban mobility. For this simulation, the Consultant
had actually built two models.
· The first is a static model, (traditional tool of
modeling based on a step at several stages which makes it possible to estimate
the various types of traffics on the whole of the network of roadway system and
of the rail network) which simulates the transport demand during the rush hour
on the whole of the network of the city and makes it possible to estimate the
various types of traffics on the whole of the network of roadway system
(mainly); It thus proves to be an extremely powerful tool to appreciate the
impact of specific installations on the general flow of the traffic.
· The second is a dynamic model of micro-simulation the
purpose of which is to optimize the time of crossing of the crossroads and the
geometry of the intersections which are often at the base of congestions. This
optimization, which is made by a simulation of traffic on precise sections is
obtained graces to the results (in flow of vehicles) of the static model.
The figure below illustrates the sequence of the various
models.
Figure 3: Sequence of the
two models at the time of the study
Source: PDU
The two models were gauged over the year under review (2010)
and were then used to simulate the situations by 2030.
Thus, the zone of study defined during the courses of this
investigation was consisted of the distribution in districts defined by the GIS
of the YCC. This distribution includes 87 internal zones and 9 external zones
(related to the penetrating roads). In order to better represent the traffic in
the downtown area, the Consultant moreover divided the zone of the
administrative and commercial center into three zones.
The table hereafter gives the names of the zones finally
retained for the study, while the chart it shows the extent of the zone.
Table1: listing of the
districts constituting the zone of study
AHALA
|
MBALLA 1
|
NGOUSSO 1
|
RN1 Nord
|
AWAE 1
|
MBALLA 2
|
NGOUSSO 2
|
RD46 NE
|
AWAE 2
|
MBALLA 3
|
NKOLBISSON
|
RN10 Est
|
BASTOS
|
MBALLA 4
|
NKOL-EBOGO
|
RD11 SE
|
BITENG
|
MBALLA 5
|
NKOL-MESSENG
|
RN2 Sud
|
BIYEM-ASSI
|
MBANKOLO
|
NKOL-NDONGO 1
|
RN3 SS
|
BRIQUETERIE
|
MELEN
|
NKOL-NDONGO 2
|
Route Kribi
|
CITE-VERTE
|
MENDONG 1
|
NKOM-KANA
|
Route Douala
|
EFOULAN
|
MENDONG 2
|
NLONGKAK 1
|
6751
|
EKOUDOU
|
MESSA CARRIERE 1
|
NLONGKAK 2
|
|
EKOUMDOUM
|
MESSA CARRIERE 2
|
NLONGKAK 3
|
|
EKOUNOU 1
|
MESSAME-NDONGO
|
NLONGKAK 4
|
|
EKOUNOU 2
|
MFANDENA 1
|
NSAM
|
|
ELIG-EDZOA
|
MFANDENA 2
|
NSIMEYONG 1
|
|
ELIG-ESSONO
|
MIMBOMAN 3
|
NSIMEYONG 2
|
|
EMANA
|
MIMBOMAN 1
|
OBILI
|
|
ESSOS
|
NKOMO
|
OBOBOGO 1
|
|
ETAM-BAFIA
|
MOKOLO
|
ODZA
|
|
ETETAK 1
|
MVAN
|
OLINGA
|
|
ETETAK 2
|
MVOG EBANDA
|
OYOM-ABANG
|
|
ETOA-MEKI 1
|
MVOG-ADA
|
SIMBOCK
|
|
ETOA-MEKI 2
|
MVOG-BETSI 1
|
TSINGA 1
|
|
ETOUDI
|
MVOG-BETSI 2
|
TSINGA 2
|
|
ETOUG-EBE
|
MVOG-MBI
|
CENTRE ADMINISTRATIF 1
|
|
GRAND MESSA
|
MVOLYE
|
CENTRE ADMINISTRATIF 2
|
|
KODENGUI 1
|
NDAMVOUT 1
|
CENTRE ADMINISTTRATIF 3
|
|
KODENGUI 2
|
NDAMVOUT 2
|
CENTRE COMMERCIAL 1
|
|
KODENGUI 3
|
NGOA-EKELLE 1
|
CENTRE COMMERCIAL 2
|
|
MADAGASCAR
|
NGOA-EKELLE 2
|
CENTRE COMMERCIAL 3
|
|
Figure 4: Modeling of the
zone of study
Source: Communauté Urbaine de
Yaoundé: Yaoundé 2020, Plan Directeur d'Urbanisme,
AUGEAINTERNATIONAL-IRIS CONSEIL-ARCAUPLAN, 2008
2.4.4. The road
safety
The system of circulation is made of constant confrontation
between the various elements constituting it namely: drivers, pedestrians,
environment of circulation, the infrastructures support of circulation and
vehicles. The road safety will have to aim reducing to the minimum, the number
and the consequences of the dysfunctions of the system of circulation (usually
called road accidents) between these various inputs of the system of
circulation.
Figure 5: Schematization
of a system of circulation
Modeling in this case will thus consist of a simulation of a
confrontation being able to lead to a traffic accident. Thus we will try to
have the potentials causes of them in particular those having milked to the
infrastructures and the environment of circulation.
CHAPTER III: PRESENTATION
OF THE RESULTS AND DISCUSSION.
At the sight of all that was presented up in
particular the importance of a hierarchisation of the lanes in urban
environment and the different categories which constitutes or should constitute
an urban space, we think that the structuring, the installation and the
adequate hierarchisation of the roadway system of a city have an impact on his
functioning. Indeed, this impact or rather these impacts is found on several
scale and aspects among which on the functioning of the aforesaid city, the
field of road safety etc.
3.1. The legibility and functionality of the plan of the
city
The YCC has a GIS exploited under
the software Mapinfo. It is indicated on the roadway system, public
equipment, the marketing activities, the school and medical
infrastructures...
This GIS is thus a reliable source of information on the
roadway network of the town of Yaoundé. Indeed, according to its data,
the roadway network of the town of Yaoundé is estimated at 2.536
km of lanes of which 755 km are paved. Even if, part
of linear of the total roadway network of the GIS is out of the territory of
the YCC, the network of the city is being quite higher than the advanced
figures in all the municipal official documents, in particular 435 km of paved
routes and 465 km of unpaved routes.
Therefore, if we consider the whole of the roadway network of
the city, the level of coverture proposed in Yaoundé is in the average
of the developing countries. However, the covered network of the city has a
lower level of cover among to the world.
Table2: Indicators of roadway
cover of
Yaoundé
Indicator
|
Yaounde (total network)
|
Yaounde (covered network)
|
Developing country
|
Developed countries
|
Mètres/1000 inhabitants
|
1200
|
350
|
150 - 3000
|
530 - 10000
|
Meters/hectares
|
90 - 120
|
26 - 35
|
40 - 220
|
60 - 320
|
Source : PDU Yaoundé
The roadway network of the town of Yaoundé is arranged
hierarchically according to several types of ways. Although there do not exist
formal basic for this classification within the YCC. Wedistinguish there:
· the National roads, which are urban portions of the
national roads, long of 65 km, including 61 km paved;
· A network of 166 km of primary roadways system, of
which 159 km are paved;
· A secondary roadway system, having an overall length of
78 km, of which 57 km are paved;
· ATertiaryroadway network, of which 478 km of ways are
paved.
Table3:Hierarchisation of the highway network system
of the GIS of the town of Yaoundé
Classifyroadway system
|
Total (in km)
|
% of the total
|
Paved (km)
|
% Paved by Class
|
National roads
|
65
|
3%
|
61
|
94%
|
Primary
|
166
|
7%
|
159
|
96%
|
Secondary
|
78
|
3%
|
57
|
73%
|
Tertiary
|
2.227
|
88%
|
478
|
21%
|
Total
|
2 536
|
100%
|
755
|
30%
|
Source : PDU
Figure 6: Repartition of
the highway network system of the town of Yaoundé
A weakness in the organization and the structuring of the
roadway network system makes it possible to highlight important dysfunctions
such:
· Problems «of use of the ways» i.e. important
loads of traffic on unsuited axes;
· Problems of grid of the network;
· Problems of legibility and marking out: because in a
badly structured space, it becomes difficult to know «spontaneously»
if we are or not on an main road, standardized crossroads and the great number
of roundabouts disturbing the comprehension of the routes network;
· Difficulties to make cohabit on the same space cars and
other alternative modes of displacements.
It thus appears essential to be concerned with hierarchisation
of the roadway network system to put in adequacy the treatment of a way and the
functions which it ensures in the network.
So, an urban space well organized must emphasize
· Ways with large transit which have as roles to direct
the national and regional transit through the city (flow which have nothing to
doin the urban perimeter but are just pass through ) just as it will have to
give access to the urban perimeter since and towards outside. The objectives of
the construction of this type of work are the fluidity and the safety of the
light vehicles and the heavy trucks, of the exchanges satisfactory with the
perimeter around. Thistype of ways has the characteristic of a highway
· Penetrating ways which have as roles in the roadway
network system, to allow an exchange between the transit ways and the internal
road network of the city. These ways have characteristics of fast tracks.
This hierarchisation brought back to the context of the town
of Yaoundé is almost the same. Thus, we distinguish four classes there;
from whose only the two first ways are regarded as being structuring ways of
the agglomeration. We have there:
· The primary Roadway system: it includes the whole of
the ways which constitute the principal grid of the urban highway network:
national roads, the principal penetrating, by-pass, ways connecting between
them principal public equipment and with the great centres of population;
· The secondary Roadway system: the secondary network of
roadway system here ensures the connection between the zones bordering located
inside the meshs on the primary distributers. Connected to the primary network
of roadway system, it supplements the structuring grid of the city;
· The tertiary Roadway system: the tertiary network is a
network of service road which makes it possible to reach in the middle of the
various districts of the city;
· Particular Roadway systems: the ways of the industrial
parks, of the zones where circulation is partially or completely prohibited,
are the subject of a classification and a specific standardization.
The current network structuring town of Yaoundé is
equipped with 270 kilometers structuring ways; is
13% of the total linear of the roadway system of the city
including 120 kilometers of primary ways and 150
kilometers of secondary roads. The current configuration of the
network shows a concentration of structuring ways in the center town area.
Indeed, the administrative center and the shopping mall are best equipped in
broad avenues and paved boulevards. Because of their localization, on one hand,
and limited number of loop lines, on the other hand, they constitute the zone
of passage of important flows of traffic.
The structuring network of the town of Yaoundé appears
being thus relatively weak. Moreover, in this classification,
10% of the total network are consisted of the primary
distributers (and national roads), against 3% for the
secondary roadway system what is rather inadequate because the primary
distributers having to be lower than the secondary roadway system.
As corollaries of this
insufficiency of the structuring network of the city, we have a saturation of
the principal access roads to the city just as it is noticed there a presence
of traffics and misfit practice sources of multiple traffic accident and a
functionality of the plan of the city which appears rather poor.
Indeed, a study of the various types of traffic having an
origin and/or an internal or external destination of the city reveals that the
inbound traffic towards outside amounts to approximately 4% of
the total traffic. Moreover, 0,4% of the counted total traffic
are a through traffic thus inappropriate because being a traffic having an
origin and an external destination at the city. This figure, in spite of that,
has to being raised to take account of the night traffic, since the trucks of
more than 20 tons, like the timber trucks, cannot circulate in Yaoundé
during the day. This through traffic can be estimated at approximately
1% of the total traffic by the night counting carried out
during the investigations. The buses and the minibuses have a ratio of exchange
close to 35%. Transport by bus ensures the service road close
to Yaoundé and that of the big cities of the country.
Table4: Distribution of the
traffics in the town of Yaoundé
|
Intern
|
Importation
|
Export
|
Transit
|
Motor bikes
|
94,9%
|
2,5%
|
2,5%
|
0,0%
|
Cars and 4X4
|
92,9%
|
3,4%
|
3,4%
|
0,3%
|
Taxis
|
95,3%
|
2,2%
|
2,2%
|
0,3%
|
Mini bus
|
65,8%
|
16,4%
|
16,4%
|
1,4%
|
Bus
|
62,8%
|
17,9%
|
17,9%
|
1,4%
|
Van
|
88,8%
|
5,5%
|
5,5%
|
0,2%
|
Trucks (=2 axles)
|
78,4%
|
9,8%
|
9,8%
|
2,0%
|
Trucks ( 2 axles)
|
77,8%
|
11,1%
|
11,1%
|
0,0%
|
Trailers
|
100%
|
0,0%
|
0,0%
|
0,0%
|
Source : PDU
3,9%
Moreover, the GIS of the YUC provide information on the state
of 267 kilometersof ways. Thus, even if more than
90% of this linear is judged in a good or average state, it
should be recalled that the analysis related only to 11% of
the total highway network and 72% of the structuring
network.
Table5: State of the road in the town of
Yaoundé according to the GIS of the YCC
Class of ways
|
Good
|
Means
|
Bad
|
In the course of work
|
Total
|
% analyzed by class of ways
|
National roads
|
44
|
4
|
0
|
0
|
48
|
74%
|
Primary
|
107
|
14
|
4
|
3
|
129
|
78%
|
Secondary
|
30
|
9
|
6
|
0
|
45
|
57%
|
Tertiary
|
21
|
16
|
6
|
1
|
44
|
2%
|
Total
|
202
|
45
|
16
|
4
|
267
|
11%
|
Another study carried out by
ECTA-BTP in 2006 fact the point on the state of the structuring network of the
city. This study aimed to work out a multiannual program of maintenance of the
priority roadway system of Yaoundé and related to 281 kilometers of
«structuring» ways, mainly paved. Three criteria of synthetic
qualification of the state of the sections were given for the needs for the
study:
· «Good» if degraded surface is lower or equal
to 10% of the entire surface of the section;
· «Average» if degraded surface lies between 10
and 30% of the entire surface of the section;
· «Bad» if degraded surface is higher than 30%
of the entire surface of the section.
The results of this analysis are deferred in the table
hereafter.
Table6: State of the priority
ways of Yaoundé in 2006
State
|
Roadway
|
Dependences of the roadway
|
Cleansing
|
Lighting
|
Indication/safety
|
Good
|
75%
|
34%
|
42%
|
32%
|
7%
|
Means
|
17%
|
15%
|
11%
|
2%
|
1%
|
Bad
|
8%
|
47%
|
43%
|
62%
|
89%
|
No value
|
0%
|
4%
|
3%
|
3%
|
3%
|
Total
|
100%
|
100%
|
100%
|
100%
|
100%
|
Source : PDU
If the state of the roadways is described as «good»
in 75% of the cases, the other elements were often recognized
«bad», in particular the lighting, the street signs and safety.
It is to note efforts which are made in the direction of the
resolution of these various failures in particular through constructions of
various penetrating ways and of skirting which will make it possible to better
manage the through traffics in the town of Yaoundé.
3.2. The functioning of the transport system
A collective transport system includes three components:
vehicles, infrastructures, and techniques of exploitations. Each one of its
elements influencing as well on the capacity of this transport system as on its
rate per hour which is the number of passengersto transport per hour and
direction.
Indeed, the road infrastructure being the support of any road
terrestrial displacement, it is possible to optimize and make profitable the
functioning of the transport system by improving its characteristics.
In the town of Yaoundé, the average width of the
streets (between frontages) is around 20 Meters the roads have an influence
going from 6 meters to more than 60 meters (Boulevard of May 20th) of width
between frontages. The Table hereafter which gives the distribution of the
roads raised according to the number of lanes by directionwatches that only a
third of the raised ways thus has 2 to 3 lanes by direction.
Table7: Numbers of ways by direction in the streets of
the town of Yaoundé
Types
|
Kilometers
|
Percentages (%)
|
1 way
|
108
|
67%
|
2 and 3 ways
|
42
|
26%
|
Separateways
|
12
|
7%
|
Total
|
162
|
100%
|
Total
|
162
|
100%
|
Source : PDU
In fact, this narrowness of
streets observed in the town of Yaoundé can be conceded with the
insufficiency of the secondary roadway system; This level of roadway system is
essential because it relates to ways which strongly structure the internal
exchanges with the perimeter of study (urban space in this case) but also with
outside. Today, it is this level of roadway system which is the least readable
in the town of Yaoundé. It (secondary roadway system) does not provide
correctly its functions in particular for the soft modes and public
transport.
The objectives of installation of this type of infrastructure
must be:
· To define characteristics which make it possible to
ensure the fluidity and the safety of all the modes of displacements;
· To allow public transport to be powerful and to provide
to the cyclists continuous cycle installations.
A hierarchisation of the principal traffic motivations carried
out in the town of Yaoundé gives the percentages gathered in the
following table
Table8: Distribution of the
principal traffic motivations in the town of Yaoundé
Reasons
|
Numbers
|
Percentages (%)
|
Residence - work
|
3654
|
20%
|
Work - residence
|
2068
|
12%
|
Residences - Visits
|
1437
|
8%
|
Work - Work
|
1270
|
7%
|
Residences - Stores (Markets)
|
886
|
5%
|
Visits - residences
|
754
|
4%
|
Residences - businesses
|
731
|
4%
|
Stores (Markets) - Residences
|
721
|
4%
|
Residence - School
|
692
|
4%
|
School - Residence
|
562
|
3%
|
Total
|
12775
|
71%
|
Total investigations
|
17955
|
|
Source : PDU
These reasons account for 71% of all the
traffic motivations raised at the time of the investigations. The reasons
related on the residence and works are most important, those related to the
visits, stores and schools follow them of rather far. These data must thus be
taken into account in the installation of a powerful roadway network system
especially with regard to urban displacements.
2.183.000 vehicleswere counted during the
investigations of traffic, that is to say an average of 13.400
vehicles per section of roadway system on which a station of
investigation was located. The traffic ranges between 1.500 to
33.400 vehicles by direction on the whole of the surveyed
sections. The morning traffic is roughly distributed 60-40
between the two directions, with a maximum traffic of 800
vehicles per hour for the most charged direction. Within the city, the
traffic of the vehicles is highest on the network in the north of the
roundabout of Nlongkak and at the level of the crossroads of Warda and the Post
office. The traffic generally has a radial structure in the town of
Yaoundé. It moves mainly towards the center town area, the commercial
districts and the administrative buildings. The motor bikes meet especially in
periphery of the city. The decree prohibiting the motor bikes taxis in the
center of Yaoundé thus seems respected. We observe in particular many
displacements in the motor bike in the western part of the city.
Figure 7: Total traffic on
the roadway network system structuring town of Yaoundé
Source: PDU
The average rate of congestion on the network at the rush hour is
of 0,3; knowing that a rate of congestion higher than
1 would mean a saturation of the network. The saturated sections
represent 14 kilometers out of the 270
kilometers of the structuring network, that is to say
5% of the linear total.
The proportion of the taxis and the cars in the total traffic
is exceptionally high in Yaoundé; Together they account for
91% of the counted traffic. The proportion of the taxis on the
sections where counting took place varies from 19% to
72% of the total traffic of the vehicles with an average of
52%. It is a very high figure which proves the insufficiency
of the services of public transport per bus and minibus.
With regard to the vehicles used in the installation of a
powerful transport system, it would be preferable to have large vehicles which
have important capacities such a bus which has a capacity from 60 to
100 places or 270 places for the Bi-articulated
buses, against 10 to 20 for the minibuses, 05
for the taxis and finally of 01 place for the motor bikes.
These different modes, it is clear, compared to the bus have a
highercoefficient occupation time of space per passengers.
From which does it thus come that these various other
means of transport (minibus, taxis and motor bikes) make remarkable great
strides in the various Cameroonian cities in general and in the town of
Yaoundé in particular?
Their rise can be to regard as letting show through a failure,
a weakness of the various transport systems undertaken by the public
authorities through the country.
The fact of being owner has importance for the people using
their car and their motor bike. Nearly a quarter of the questioned population
stated not to have the choice between various means of transport, for various
reasons such as:
· Not-adequacy of the transport infrastructures,
· Absence of freightvehicles
· Insufficient income to take another means of
transport.
20% of the people investigated declare that
they choose the fastest means of the transport; it is particularly true for the
motor bikes on the short distances. 13% choose the mode the
least expensive, primarily the buses, and 9% seek best comfort
in the mode than they chose. The average time of displacements all modes raised
by the investigations is 29 minutes. On the other hand the
users of the buses have on average 50 minutes of voyage,
including waiting, which is clearly a brake to the use of the transport system
by bus.
A study of speeds of course by motor bikes and by cars on
05 routes in the town of Yaoundé emphasizes an average
rate of travel in the car of 16,5 km/h. The mean
velocity of the cars is lower by 3 km/h than that of the motor bikes, because
these last circulate more easily than the cars in the zones of strong
traffic.
Figure 8: Routes on which
run times were measured
Source: PDU
Table9: Listing of the routes
Route
|
Origin/Destination
|
Distances in km (02 cumulated directions)
|
1
|
Messassi gendarmerie/OnambeleCrossroads
|
40,8
|
2
|
Crossroads Onambele Barrier/Crossroads Entered College of
Ngoulemakong
|
35,0
|
3
|
Bitotol (Crossroads Horeb College) /Mendong Village
|
32,8
|
4
|
Crossroads Nkolbison/Febe Village
|
49,3
|
5
|
Crossroads of the Palace of the Unity/Crossroads Tradex
service station
|
43,1
|
Source : PDU
Tableau 10: Results of the investigation of running
times (in minutes) (Cars)
|
Direction 1
|
Direction 2
|
Total
|
Length
|
Time
|
Speeds
|
Length
|
Time
|
Speeds
|
Length
|
Time
|
Speeds
|
1
|
20,6
|
88,0
|
14,0
|
21,1
|
78,0
|
16,2
|
41,7
|
166,0
|
15,1
|
2
|
18,2
|
57,0
|
19,2
|
18,1
|
49,0
|
22,2
|
36,3
|
106,0
|
20,5
|
3
|
16,8
|
59,0
|
17,1
|
16,8
|
67,0
|
15,0
|
33,6
|
126,0
|
16,0
|
4
|
26,0
|
108,0
|
14,4
|
25,9
|
106,0
|
14,7
|
51,9
|
214,0
|
14,6
|
5
|
22,5
|
80,0
|
16,9
|
22,3
|
85,0
|
15,7
|
44,8
|
165,0
|
16,3
|
Moy
|
20,8
|
78,4
|
16,3
|
20,8
|
77,0
|
16,8
|
41,7
|
155,4
|
16,5
|
Tableau 11: Results of the investigation of running
times (in minutes) (Motor bikes)
|
Direction 1
|
Direction 2
|
Total
|
Length
|
Time
|
Speeds
|
Length
|
Time
|
Speeds
|
Length
|
Time
|
Speeds
|
1
|
20,6
|
56,0
|
22,1
|
21,1
|
53,0
|
23,9
|
41,7
|
109,0
|
23,0
|
2
|
18,2
|
60,0
|
18,2
|
18,1
|
52,0
|
20,9
|
36,3
|
112,0
|
19,4
|
3
|
16,8
|
57,0
|
17,7
|
16,8
|
57,0
|
17,7
|
33,6
|
114,0
|
17,7
|
4
|
26,0
|
78,0
|
20,0
|
25,9
|
80,0
|
19,4
|
51,9
|
158,0
|
19,7
|
5
|
22,5
|
72,0
|
18,8
|
22,3
|
87,0
|
15,4
|
44,8
|
159,0
|
16,9
|
Moy
|
20,8
|
64,6
|
19,3
|
20,8
|
65,8
|
19,5
|
41,7
|
130,4
|
19,3
|
Source : PDU
Studies made it possible to model the relationship between the
flow and the speed of circulation on a way; they thus make it possible to
define and this with a function represented by an ellipse, this relation.
Flow
When we places in X-coordinate the flow «Q» and in
ordinate practicable speed «V», we notes that to a low flow
correspond two very different practicable speeds: one high and the other weak.
The corresponding concentration is then inversely proportional to the speed:
the higher speed is, the weaker the concentration is.
Speed
Figure 9: Theoretical
curve of the relation between the flow and speed on a way
The relation between the flow and the speed of circulation
establishes that in situation of «hyper congestion» in the lower part
of the curve, the increase in the traffic decreases the number of vehicles per
hour circulating on the way (numbers of passengers per hour, if we consider
only public transport). The important congestions that occur on the main axes
of connection centers/periphery in the agglomeration of Yaoundé let
think that we are in situation of hyper congestion at the rush hours. The
recourse by artisanal transport, majority in the traffic, to vehicles of low
capacity involves a loss of capacity of the access roads to the center thing
which tends to worsen with the narrowness of the streets observed in the town
of Yaoundé.
The resolution of these multiple problems with which is
confronted the operation of the transport system in the Cameroonian cities in
general and the town of Yaoundé in particular thus passes inevitably by
solutions such the urban installation of a urban transport system of mass which
will make it possible to reduce the number of vehicles on the ways and thus to
reduce the levels of congestion on the various ways components the roadway
network system.
Figure 10: Reorganization
of the offer of public transport with anUrban Transport System of
Mass
It is important to point out the fitting of adequate
installations which will have to allow the good installation and the good
performance of this urban system transport of mass. We can list
· The increase in linear of the secondary network roadway
system,
· The maintenance of this network
· The installation of certain facility for the joint grid
system such the exclusive way which is a way reserved exclusively or not for
the circulation of the bus or any other particular transport system such the
tram. The installation of this type of way makes it possible to separate the
bus for example from the current traffic what contributes to improve its speed
and thus its profitability like transport system.
Indeed, Because of weakness of the level of coverture of the
urban highway network (paved and in good state) in the Cameroonian cities, to
integrate these installation on all the access roads would be utopian and
unsuited. In order to be realistic, we recommend an integration of this type of
installation on the major axes of the agglomerations. For example, with the
configuration of the roadway network structuring the town of Yaoundé as
higher presented, it more suitable to integrate this installation (exclusive
way for Autobus) on the secondary routes of the city. Thus, this modification
of the profile across the primary and secondary roadway system would make it
possible the transport system by bus to be better integrated in the city
because it would serve the various major axes effectively leading to the
various districts of the city and thus would leave the relay to the other modes
such the taxi and/or the motor bike the care to continue the service road in
the depths. That would make the transport systemby Autobus more effective
because it would combine this time speed, comfort and safety.
3.3. Impact in the field of the road safety
The inadequacy of the installation of
the roadway system of a city can also have impacts on safety in road.
The following tables give some statistics on this road
insecurity.
Table12: Numbersof road
accidents in urban areas for the year 2007
|
Center
|
Littoral
|
West
|
N.O
|
S.O
|
South
|
Adam.
|
Ea
|
North
|
Fa-No.
|
Total
|
January
|
407
|
21
|
24
|
0
|
5
|
0
|
11
|
6
|
0
|
5
|
479
|
February
|
410
|
0
|
12
|
18
|
12
|
10
|
0
|
3
|
0
|
1
|
476
|
March
|
379
|
0
|
21
|
0
|
10
|
16
|
0
|
5
|
0
|
0
|
431
|
April
|
273
|
0
|
15
|
4
|
5
|
11
|
0
|
5
|
0
|
0
|
313
|
May
|
315
|
0
|
5
|
0
|
18
|
3
|
0
|
2
|
0
|
0
|
343
|
June
|
288
|
179
|
5
|
0
|
6
|
17
|
0
|
4
|
0
|
4
|
503
|
July
|
363
|
210
|
4
|
1
|
9
|
5
|
0
|
6
|
3
|
3
|
604
|
August
|
297
|
12
|
1
|
2
|
9
|
8
|
0
|
10
|
2
|
0
|
341
|
September
|
293
|
178
|
17
|
0
|
16
|
10
|
6
|
0
|
4
|
0
|
524
|
October
|
422
|
63
|
20
|
9
|
17
|
9
|
0
|
3
|
22
|
0
|
565
|
November
|
295
|
171
|
9
|
22
|
34
|
9
|
4
|
8
|
16
|
3
|
571
|
December
|
277
|
160
|
10
|
24
|
29
|
8
|
7
|
7
|
19
|
6
|
547
|
Total
|
4019
|
994
|
143
|
80
|
186
|
111
|
17
|
59
|
66
|
22
|
5697
|
Source : PDU
Table13: Average road accidents per day recorded
during the year 2008 in the center region
Accidents Fatal
|
Personal injuries
|
Material accidents
|
Died
|
Wounded
|
Damagedvehicles
|
2,3
|
4,92
|
2,12
|
2,92
|
12,69
|
18,75
|
Source : PDU
From these figures, it
rises that the physical and material accidents in the area of the center region
in general and the in town of Yaoundé are one of the leading causes of
mortality (1056 died, 851 cases of accidents fatal) and of the
loss of the tangible properties (6844 damaged vehicles).
These accidents, for those which are done following a
collision pedestrian/vehicle are the result of the inadequacy of the functions
local life and road traffic as higher presented in this memory.
Several factors are thus found to be the source of these
multiple traffic accidents.
3.3.1.
Humanfactors
The users are the principal responsible of the accidents. The
reasons are varied. The imprudence of the driver, the non-observance of the
driving code, the lack of control of the vehicle, the excess speed, the catch
of alcohol or narcotic products are as many human failures which involve
accidents here. One can indicate besides that these the last two factors are
surely underestimated, because they are not the subject of detection.
3.3.2. Factor
vehicles
The mechanical or technical causes are those which are related
to the bad condition of the vehicles, this is due to the absence of
maintenance. On this aspect, the Cameroonian government tried to bring a
solution by instituting a control of a periodicity determined by category of
vehicles, but although there is an obligatory process of technical control of
the vehicles regulated by the decree n° 011/A/MINT of February 23rd, 1998,
mow is to note that the vehicles often do not have the technical elements of
safety complete and that one can circulate in Yaoundé with vehicles with
the windshield postpones lack and with defective concerned with safety units.
They are mainly the taxis and the minibuses. The strong frequency of controls
to which they are subjected does not improve of anything park quality. As this
study carried out in the town of Douala shows it and attests it the engineering
service of CADCIA, technical control raises the failures related to braking,
with the state of the tires, the shock absorbers, the traffic lights, the
headlights and the problems of direction. According to the statistics of the
approved centers, for the technical visits of car of the town of Yaoundé
in particular CADCIA and WCI, on the 150 vehicles received on average per day,
1/3 are returned for this type of failures.
3.3.3.
Infrastructural factor
It is the factor on which a local government agency can
influence, and by there, influence the human factor, by the control speeds
practiced in particular. The user makes a reading of the borrowed way and it
adapts its behavior, sometimes in a perfectible way, with the crossed
environment. Also one does not arrange a street like a highway, because one
does not circulate there in the same way.
The report of the national mission details very well, for a
community which arranges the ways, the risks of fight against the accidents in
these installations. We have then illustrated this very important point for
examples of problems raised in Yaoundé without denying all the completed
work for several years and which gives partly satisfaction.
The design of the roads is subjected to standards varying
according to the countries. In Cameroun, the standards used are the French
standards. When these standards are scrupulously respected and sufficiently
explicit, road installations for the users (markings, indication, automatic
measurements of deceleration, etc.), they can have a positive incidence on the
behaviors. However failures in the technical design can have negative
incidences on the behavior of the users, because rather causing additional
difficulties in circulation (absence of markings, bad or misses indication of
the obstacles, etc.) These failures increase the accident risks of circulation
and thus expose more the road users.
Design of the roads in Cameroun present in several cases the
defects which contribute to the accident risk. These defects very often
result:
· Bad design of the crossroads,
· Not taken into account of the agreement between the
alignment and the profile longitudinally of the road,
· Not taken into account of the heterogeneity of the
traffic, variable speeds, and attractivity of the road,
· Of a design allowing a great disparity with regard to
practiced speeds and the types of vehicles.
There exist many accidentogenes places isolated or gathered
along the roads. These places often remain without treatment leading thus to
other traffic accidents in these same places. With regard to the safety
equipment, certain aspects of the design must be followed with a certain
attention:
· The material constituting the safety equipment: The
originators were sometimes led to the choice of the rigid material equipment
such as the concrete (control panels out of concrete, concrete slides, etc.) in
order to reduce the maintenance costs of the aforesaid equipment. However, this
choice was made with the detriment of safety users, because by privileging the
longevity of a control panel by the choice of the concrete like constitutive
material, one exposes the vehicles which, in the event of shock with the panel,
find themselves seriously damaged (the panel which cannot absorb the shock),
and consequently the passengers seriously wounded. That goes in the opposition
even to the goal of the safety device which is rather judicious to protect them
from the accidents.
· Specifications concerning the safety equipment to be
set up: II is not rare that on the works of art built in urban environment, one
finds for example parapets having horizontal elements of cross-piece. These
elements thus laid out create a scale effect making it possible to the
pedestrians (especially with the children) to span the parapets, and this with
the danger of their life.
3.3.4. Factors
influencing the quality of the road studies
The taking into account of safety in phase of design of the
road infrastructures is subjected to certain constraints which put at evil the
quality of the studies carried out.
· Budgetary restrictions: The taking into account of
safety often imposes an increase in the level of installation of the road
(enlarging of the radii of curvature, reduction of the declivities, indication
and more important safety equipment, etc.), which creates additional costs thus
increasing the financial expenses that the country supports which is most of
the time borrower for the projects, and which return occasion consequently the
less profitable project.
· The level of priority of safety in the road design: One
of the difficulties at present in the realization of the road studies resides
in the terms of reference, because those do not impose in a clear and precise
way technical constraints related to safety at the Technical Research
departments (Study Bureau) and the Companies of realization.
· The dispersion of the made efforts: The intervenants in
the road safety are divided in various sectors, but each one carries out by her
side the fight against the road insecurity, and thus certain actors go
sometimes until being opposed between them by creating problems which harm the
good behavior of the studies. The absence of a structure responsible for the
road safety charged to coordinate the action of the various protagonists raised
previously in the analysis of the organizational device is to be regretted
because of inoperationnality of the inter-ministerial committee set up.
· Negligence of the economic impact of the accidents in
the evaluation of the projects of road infrastructures
It is necessary to rise that at present, the evaluation of the
projects of road infrastructures does not take sufficiently counts of it the
profit which the reduction of the number of accidents could generate on a road.
Indeed, within the framework of the evaluation, this profit should be put in
connection with the cost of the complementary investments to implement to more
guarantee safety, this in order to adopt the most advantageous solution, and
economically most profitable in the long term. It is about a criterion which
could be integrated in a formal way in the appreciation of the road
projects.
On the ground, one belongs to installations generating of the
behaviors at the risk or having consequences on the gravity of the accidents.
These configurations must be proscribed.
The multiplication of the points of conflicts in a crossroads
is one of the examples. One finds this design defect in several crossroads of
Yaoundé. They are insuperable small islands of form mainly triangular
which corresponded to one moment given to an installation, but which was not
adapted to the new circulation terms. These small islands, which authorizes to
practice without «prohibited direction», call into question the
principle of skirting by the line of an obstacle and especially multiply the
points of potential conflicts. This is why this configuration differently
indicated by «Bennett small island» is proscribed in many countries.
One finds this installation with the crossroads EtoaMeki, Coron, Cami-Toyota,
MvogMbi, Ngousso where the left-hand turns are not any not simplified.
It should be noted that new installations, if they allow
raised speeds, can unfortunately induce accidents with the pedestrians,
therefore serious accidents.
Thus the Préfecture exchanger includes/understands it
weaving lanes which can encourage at the velocity emission of crossroads and
the end of which crossings for pedestrians were marked. This configuration of
mixture between characteristics perceived like highway and local life is source
of accidents.
Most interesting information of accidentology is information
which one can locate. The observation of the behaviors is information source on
the non-observance of the rules (in particular that of the indication of
tricolor fires or the STOP). For this purpose, dust (as snow in the
Scandinavian countries) is also useful for us to distinguish spaces circulated
from uncommon spaces in a complex, vast crossroads or in current section of a
large artery.
In the same way, the visit on the ground with the agents
constatateurs proves to be more enriching and makes it possible for example to
detect minor roads which drain a district and whose outlet on the main road is
carried out under bad conditions.
The central police station n°4 evokes the sector of Mvan,
which is logical because we are at the exit of the city, on one of the most
attended arteries. Speeds are increased and the entries and exits of the
perilous and non made-up bordering properties. This axis should imperatively be
the subject of a thorough study of road safety.
At other places, it is the excess of indication which devalues
indication, or rather a bad choice of the mode of priority in crossroads. Thus
in a crossroads lately arranged, it was placed a STOP on the file of the
left-hand turn, concomitantly with a STOP on the minor road. As this STOP is
not respected, because unsuited to this place, they are all the STOP around
which is some devalued, as if one could cross any STOP without risk with
impunity.
Figure11: Example of a
multiplicity of small islands and useless use of a STOP
GENERAL CONCLUSION AND
RECOMMANDATIONS
4.1. Recall of the working hypotheses.
The starting point of this work was a rather simple and
alleviating statement: the cross sectional profile adopted for a road has an
impact on the efficiency of this road in urban environment. In order to be able
to bring answers to this question, we have begun researches which have deviate
from this starting assumption. Now, the question around which our work was
going to articulate was:what is the impact, the importance of the
hierarchisation of the highway network in an urban area? Differently summarize,
this new assumption, bases of our work would be of knowing what is the
importance of the function of the roadway system on its form (width) in urban
environment. This new question having been directed by a rather favorable
context general that by its rather relevant problems, the second phase at which
we had arrived (after the determination of this question) was to carry out a
review of the literature which would be articulated around the urban roadway
network in particular on its design, its function and its organization.
In this part, through the various articles, documents and
theses consulted, we presented the elements on which former work had dwelt too
long in particular on the design of the urban roadway system, its various
functions and how to organize it in order to make it efficient.
In order to be able to confront our assumption with reality,
we should consequently carry out the development, the design of a model.
However, at the time of the investigations of data acquisition, it was brought
back to us the availability of a document: Elaboration du plan de
déplacementUrbains de la ville de Yaoundé, which
was worked out in 2010 by the grouping Louis Berger/Beta
Consult.
We thus decided to use the data and results of investigations
contained in this document and this because of quality (detailed and veracious)
of the data and of their relatively recent age (5 years from 2010 to 2015).
This forced us to re-examine the model checking of the
assumption that we had fixed ourselves at the beginning. It is thus as in order
to be able to conform us to this news gives, we would base on the document
referred to above more precisely we would adapt our assumptions has those which
were formulated in this document. Thus our new models will relate to:
· The legibility and functionality of the plan of the
city and this through data on the quantitative and the qualitative roadway
network system of the town of Yaoundé;
· Thefunctioning of the transport system of the city
through a model of simulation of traffic.
· The road safety through a simulation of the conditions
being able to lead to a confrontation.
Once these various modelsadopted, it was a question for us to
pass to the presentation of the results of the investigations on site in order
to be able to confirm or to refute our basic hypothesis.
Thus at the end of this exercise, this reveals that the
hierarchisation of the roadway network system in an urban environment has
indeed a rather important impact on the aforementioned environment.
4.2. Proposals of standard cross sectional profile.
With regard to the various Cameroonian urban centers in
general and the town of Yaoundé in particular, we presented proposals
for a cross sectional profile depending of the category, and the hierarchy of
the way to consider.
4.2.1. For the
primary roadway network system:
This type of roadway system is provided:
· of a covered verge, released of any obstacle in order
to provide various functions of safety whose width varies between 2 and 3m;
· of band of rolling of which the number is function of
the awaited flow; the necessary width is of 3,5 m per lane
· of a central reservation equipped with devices of
reserve; its width minimum is of 1 m
· of device of reserve side.
As follows:
i. For the ways supporting traffic in source or direction of
the regional capital (national roads forwarding in the city), they should have
the characters of a highway; we suggest expressways with 2 X 2 ways: The
influence can be limited to 27 meters in order to reduce the costs of
acquisition land.
ii. Figure 12: Modelingof
national roads forwarding in the city
For the penetrating ways used for the exchange between the
transit ways and the internal roadway network, it is recommended fast tracks.
These roadway systems are used by a large variety of users, which gets an
important potential of insecurity. Consequently the top priority will be to
separate the users not having the same speed of advance. The configuration of
this type of roadway system will have to bring a maximum of safety to the users
who borrow it. The standard cross sectional profile of the penetrating ways
rises from that from the urban highways and by-pass, with possibility of future
extension to 2 X 3 ways (ways of 3,50 meters)
Figure 13: Modeling of fast
tracks
4.2.2. For the
secondary roadway network system
This network ensures the principal connections within the
urban perimeter. Thus connections between the poles of the urban perimeter on
one hand, and with outside on the other hand, are ensured by this category.
Pavements must be arranged on both sides roadway. Their widths
are induced by the level of frequentation. The crossings pedestrians must be
«in shoe» in order to facilitate displacements of the people with
reduced mobility. The presence of a cycle track/exclusive way is essential, and
if the widths available allow it, with a clear separation of the lanes. The
width of this one must be at least of 2m.
The minimal influence of the minor roads will be of 13 m, of
17 m in the event of adjustment of parking or 25 m for the ways with exclusive
way for bus. Certain influences of the town of Yaoundé allow more
important widths, and to consider a configuration of parking angle. Off-set
zones of stops of public transport will be arranged regularly, preferably at
the exits of the crossings to avoid blocking the crossroads. This localization
of the stops of public transport also has the advantage not of not too much
cutting down the pavements taking into account the broader influences with the
crossings. The crossings pedestrians will be also located at the entries and
exits of the crossings where it will be arranged central small islands of
protection of the crossings.
Figure 14: Modeling of the
different types of way for the secondary roadway system
4.2.3. For the
tertiary roadway network system
The influence of the way is generally fixed at 11 meters, but
could be modified during the studies of preliminary draft according to the
constraints of the site. The roadway will thus include two lanes of 3 m,
broadsides each by a pavement which can go up to 2,5 meters of width, the
gutters included. In the retail parks and near the schools, the pavements will
have to be broader, contrary to the residential zones.
In tertiary roadway system and in zone 30 in particular, one
can admit a distribution of the widths which makes slow down and which
increases the width of roadway to 5 meters, even 4,5 meters when it is about an
urban court and the vehicles cross with the step.
Figure 15: Modeling of a
way of the tertiary roadway system
ANNEXES
Circulation
Observations
51 the current network of the streets is a whole of
developed ramifications goshawks of the main roads of
communication.
The 52 great transportation routes were conceived to
receive the pedestrians or of cartages, they do not answer the mechanical means
of transport today any more.
53 the dimensioning of the streets, from now on
inappropriate, is opposed to the use new mechanical speeds and the regular rise
of the city.
The 54 distances between the crossings of the streets are
too weak.
55 the width of the streets is too insufficient. To seek
to widen those is often an operation expensive and besides
inoperative.
56 Opposite mechanical speeds, the network of the streets
appears irrational, conformity, diversity, flexibility, exactitude
lack.
57 Of the layouts sumptuary, working towards
representative ends, could or can constitute heavy hindrances to
traffic.
58 In many cases, the network of railways (railroads)
became, during the urban expansion, a serious obstacle with the urbanization.
It locks up districts of dwellings, depriving them of the useful contacts with
the vital elements of the city.
It is necessary to require
59 Of the useful analyzes must be made, on rigorous
statistics, of the whole of circulation in the city and its area, work which
will raise the beds of circulation and the quality of their flows.
The 60 lanes must be classified according to their nature
and built according to the vehicles and their speeds.
The 61 crossings with strong flows will be arranged in
circulation continuous by changes of levels.
62 the pedestrian must be able to follow other ways that
the car
63 Thestreets must be differentiated according to their
destinations: streets of dwellings, streets of walks, streets of transit, ways
main.
64 Thegreen areas must insulate, in theory the beds of
great circulation.
The chartre of Athens (extract)
Extrait de la chartre d'Athènes.
Source :d'ARCIER, B. F. (1992). La voirie urbaine : de
l'accumulation à la gestion patrimoniale, Thèse de doctorat.
Lyon: Université Lumière de Lyon II.
The plan of urban displacement of the town of
Yaoundé
The Consortium Louis Berger/Beta Consult (the Consultant)
subscribed on May 4th, 2010 to contract N°047/M/CUY/CPM/10 for the
Development of a Plan of Urban Displacements (PDU) of the town of
Yaoundé. This contract was approved on May 10th, 2010 by the Delegate of
the Government at the Urban Council of Yaoundé (UCY). Its financing will
be ensured by funds D registered in the Budget of the Ministry for the Urban
Development and Housing of 2009.
The PDU of Yaoundé has the following general aims:
· improvement of the urban mobility and the reduction of
times of displacements;
· improvement of accessibility to the peripheral
districts;
· improvement of the road safety for all the categories of
users;
· a strategy of regulation of the global offer of public
transport and the definition of the principles of exploitation of the grid
systems;
· a diagram of organization of transport to the horizon
2020, with programming of the actions necessary to the installation of the PDU
at short-term.
The TOR also includes a certain number of particular requests:
· the creation of a clean network of «pedestrians
displacements» on the scale of the agglomeration, by the development of an
adapted information system strategic plan;
· improvement of the conditions of the urban transit and the
management of the breaking bulks (stations, platforms and spaces parking);
· the forecast of installations allowing to dissociate the
transport of the other urban activities by in particular imposing a new
division of the roadway system in favor of the activities and spaces of
leisure, and the walking;
· the examination of the appropriateness of the installation
of an organizing authority of transport on the level of the town of
Yaoundé in order to ensure the coherence of the sectorial policies and
to coordinate the actions of the various actors.
The study of the PDU is divided into three missions as
follows:
Mission n°1: Concerted diagnosis
Mission n°2: Development of the Plan of Urban
Displacements
Mission n°3: Planning and finalization
Presentation of the Plan of Urban Displacements of the
Town of Yaoundé
REFERENCES
(2009). Document de Stratégie pour la Croissance et
l'Emploi.
CERTU. (2008). Fiche n°11 - Sécurité et
hiérachie des voies urbaines. Savoir de base en
sécurité routière.
CERTU. (2009). Le profil en travers, outil du partage des
voiries urbaines. Montpellier.
CORBUSIER, L. (1957). La chartre d'Athènes,
Collections Points. Paris: Editions de Minuits.
COSTESEQUE Guillaume. (Avril 2012). ANALYSE ET MODELISATION
DU TRAFIC ROUTIER : Passage du microscopique au macroscopique - Mémoire
de master MEGA - Génie Civil (éd. Première
édition). Marne-la-vallée: Chaire abertis - Ecole des Ponts
ParisTech - IFSTTAR.
d'ARCIER, B. F. (1992). La voirie urbaine : de l'accumulation
à la gestion patrimoniale, Thèse de doctorat. Lyon:
Université Lumière de Lyon II.
Direction départementale des Territoires de l'Ain. (2013,
Octobre). Hiérachisation des voies urbaines et modérations
des vitesses - Enjeux et méthodologie. Bourg-en-Bresse: Agb Print'
.
Dumez, H. (2011). Faire une revue de littérature :
pourqoi et comment? Le libellio d'Aegis.
LAROUSSE. (2009). Le petit LAROUSSE multimedia.
LOUIS BERGER; BETA CONSULT. (2010). Elaboration d'un plan de
déplacement urbains de la ville de Yaoundé - Rapport Diagnostic
Version Finale. Yaoundé: Communauté Urbaine de
Yaoundé.
LOUIS BERGER; BETA CONSULT. (2011). Elaboration d'un plan de
déplacement urbains de la ville de Yaoundé - Rapport
Final.Yaoundé: Communauté Urbaine de Yaoundé.
MANDELBROT B. (1983). The fractal Geometry of Nature.
New York: W.H. Freeman.
MONTEL Marie-Claude, N. C.-E. (2004). Voies urbaine:
représentations et attentes des conducteurs de journ de nuit et en
soirée. Marne la Vallée: Ifsttar.
NEUFERT, E. (2002). Les éléments des projets de
construction 8ème EDITION. Paris: DUNOD.
NOUNDJEU, F. C. (14 au 15 février 2011). Exposé sur
les infrastructures. Conférence annuelle des responsables ds
services centraux et déconcentrés du MINDUH.
Yaoundé.
STRANSKY, V. (1995). Forme et fonction d'un réseau :
cas de la voirie urbaine de desserte locale. Paris: Université
Paris XII Val de Marne.
* 1Cross sectional profile seen
such as presented in the general introduction of the present document
* 2 Abstraction is made on the
economic constraints due to the cost of the project. In this part, the stress
is laid on the interference with the bordering frame of life.
* 3As underlined at the
beginning of this review of the literature, this research wants to be to be
corrélationnelle because having for goal to discover or establish the
existence of a relation between two common aspects of the urban roadway system:
the gauge of a way and its output
* 4 Indeed, there exist
classically microscopic models and the macroscopic models of study of traffic.
The first endeavor to model the road traffic by individual evolution of each
vehicle. In this model, the dynamics of the vehicle is given by a law of
continuation and the speed of a vehicle is directly function of the distance
which separates it from the vehicle right in front of him, modulo a time lag,
which is the reaction time of the driver. On the largest scale (called
macroscopic scale), the simplest model used is the hydrodynamic model of
traffic, which supposes that the density of vehicle satisfies a law of
conservation. Here the speed of the vehicles is supposed to be a function
of the density of vehicles.
* 5By the consultant at the time
of the realization of the investigations necessary to the development of the
diagnosis of the town of Yaounde or by us even for a possible investigation the
purpose of which would be to confirm or to dispute a data or information
provided by the Plan of Urban Displacements of the town of Yaounde.
|