DESTINATION MANAGEMENT SYSTEM FOR MOROCCO TOURISM
By Inan Elmerini
An Executive Project submitted in partial fulfillment of the
requirements for the degree of
Master in Business Administration for Aviation and
Aerospace Professionals
Embry-Riddle Aeronautical University
Daytona Beach, Florida April 2001
Copyright (c) Inan Elmerini 2001
DESTINATION MANAGEMENT SYSTEM FOR MOROCCO TOURISM By Inan
Elmerini
This graduate research project was prepared under the direction
of the candidate research advisor, Dr Easwar Nyshadham, Department of Business
Administration and has been approved by the Project Review Committee. It was
submitted to the Department of Business Administration and was accepted in
partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Executive Master in
Business Administration For Aviation and Aerospace Professionals.
PROJECT REVIEW COMMITTEE Approved by:
Dr. Easwar Nyshadham Earaar /1(tekadkaff Date: April 2001
Project Advisor
Dr Blaise Waguespack 8laise lagueepael
Graduate Program Coordinator Date: April 2001
Dr Dan Petree Pax Pet ee
Department Chair Date: April 2001
ABSTRACT
TITLE: DESTINATION MANAGEMENT SYSTEM FOR MOROCCO TOURISM AUTHOR:
Inan Elmerini
INSTITUTION: Embry-Riddle Aeronautical University.
DEPARTEMENT: Business Administration
DEGREE: Master in Business Administration for Aviation and
Aerospace Professionals YEAR: 2001
The rapid development of Information and Communication technology
(ICT) in the distribution and intermediation of tourism products has set new
competitive environment for destination's tourism industry. A comprehensive
research on ICT implications on the tourism and travel industry was conducted
to demonstrate the critical competitive factors of comprehensive database of a
Webbased Destination Management System and the seamless marketing chain it
creates: Awareness-Information-Booking-CRM. This project proposes a Destination
Management System for Morocco's Tourism Destination and carefully evaluates
strategic implications of its realization. Marketing, financial and
organizational strategic requirements are analyzed for a successful
implementation. This executive project demonstrates how a DMS will enable the
Moroccan National Tourism Office, as an organization, to establish a critical
competitive advantage for Morocco's entire tourism industry.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
ABSTRACT .. iii
LIST OF TABLES v
LIST OF FIGURES ..vi Chapter
1. INTRODUCTION ..1
2. WORLD TOURISM: AN OVERVIEW ..4
Historical Trend 4
International Tourism in 2000 ... .4
Regional Highlights ....6
International Tourism Expenditures 10
Morocco Destination Overview ...11
Destination Positioning . 11
Market Share .. ..11
Competition and Potential Development . 12
3. TOURISM INDUSTRY 14
Global Characteristics ..14
Core Characteristics .15
Market Characteristics .16
Competitive Constraints for Destinations 20
Industry's Driving forces 20
Marketing Constraints for Tourism Boards .21
4. TOURISM AND INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY .23
Demand Trends and Information Technology .23
ICT Strategic Implications for Tourism ....27
5. INTERNET TRAVEL ...34
The Global Net ...34
Internet Business Travel ..35
United States ...35
Europe 37
6. DESTINATION MANAGEMENT SYSTEM ..39
The Nature of a National Tourism Office ....39
Comprehensive Study of a DMS ..40
Definition 40
Historic Background ....41
DMS Fundamental Objectives .42
Destination Stakeholders' Objectives ...43
DMS's Success Criteria 44
Existing DMSs 47
TIScover, Austria .47
Gulliver, Ireland ...48
7. DMS FAISABILITY FOR MOROCCO DESTINATION ...50
MNTO Marketing Challenge ...50
Major Issues 50
Strategic Environment .50
Marketing Objectives ...52
Overall Objectives ...52
Tourism Businesses 52
The Consumer .53
Building the Web Based DMS .54
Database Characteristics .. 54
Business Model and Financial Feasibility ..62
Constraints ..62
Financial Analysis 64
MNTO's Organizational Challenge ...70
Operational Environment 70
Managements Objectives 72
SWOT Analysis ..74
Vision and Mission ..75
Changing MNTO's Organization .76
8. CONCLUSION .79
INDEX OF TABLES
Number Page
Table 1. Top Destination in Africa and Middle East . 6
Table 2. Top Destinations in the Americas .. 7
Table 3. Top Destinations in East Asia . 8
Table 4. Top Destinations in Europe 9
Table 5. Pre Internet Tourism 19
Table 6. Tourism Competitive Drivers in ITs Environment ..28
Table 7. Internet Enabled Tourism . 33
Table 8. Destination Marketing System Characteristics 56
Table 9. Interactive Marketing Framework 59
Table 10. Financial Inputs ... 66
Table 11. Projected Revenues . 67
Table 12. Loan Amortization . 68
Table 13. Financial Outputs 69
Table 14. Financial Scenario Summary . 70
LIST OF FIGURES
Number Page
Figure 1. Stylized View of the Tourism and Travel Market 17
Figure 2. The Deployment of IT in Tourism 27
Figure 3. Current and Future Position of Online Services . 30
Figure 4. Number of Worldwide Online Households 35
Figure 5. Types of Internet Sites used for Travel Planning 36
Figure 6. Online Buying in the United States 37
Figure 7. Success Criteria for DMS .. 46
Figure 8. Morocco Destination Marketing SWOT Analysis... 51
Figure 9. Outline of a Web Based Destination Marketing System
57
Figure 10. A Framework for Web Design 61
Figure 11. MNTO's Operational Strategic Environment 72
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
The author wishes to express special thanks to the project
advisor, Dr. Easwar Nyshadham, whose constant encouragement, helpful counsel
and practical suggestions were crucial to the successful outcome of this
Graduate Research Project. Appreciation is also due to Drs. Petree and
Waguespack, Project Review Committee Members, for their assistance in preparing
this manuscript.
This statement of acknowledgement would be incomplete without a
formal expression of sincere appreciation and gratitude to both Dr. Saad
Laraqui and the author's family for providing the assistance and encouragement
needed to complete the task.
Chapter 1
INTRODUCTION
Tourism clearly counts as one of the social and economic
phenomena of the last century. According to WTO, the number of international
tourists traveling in the world reached 698 millions in 2000. International
tourism receipts for the same year have been estimated at US$ 476 billion.
Today, Tourism is perceived as an eminently global industry with a worldwide
network of producers, suppliers and intermediaries. This industry is also
characterized by its fragmentation and heterogeneity, thus a complex product
with different components. Moreover, Tourism is information intensive industry,
with worldwide heterogeneous consumers communities with constant changing
needs.
Recognizing the benefits of tourism, many countries have created
coordinating agencies at national level, to address tourism related services.
Often, these agencies, such as Tourist Boards tend to be state organizations in
charge of marketing their country as a «brand». Historically, Tourist
Boards have marketed their destinations by communicating their countries'
tourism offer to the international markets through various media, including
direct contact with the consumers through physical offices in the world's major
cities. They also
promote their destinations by distributing printed and video
materials and taking part in tourism trade shows or «similar live
activities». However, in recent years, tremendous changes that have
occurred in the travel industry have driven Tourist Boards all over the world
to adapt their missions, and sharpen their marketing strategies. Probably, the
single most significant change driving this redefinition of corporate mission
is the revolutions in information technology. Information and Communication
Technologies (ICT) available today make it possible to radically reengineer
activities between an organization, its customers, suppliers and
stakeholders.
The role of such national institutions in creating a general
enabling environment for the tourism industry is crucial especially for
developing countries. Morocco is one of those developing countries that are
relying on Tourism to jumpstart a tourism driven economy. The State owned
Tourism Board for Morocco, called the Moroccan National Tourism Office (MNTO),
is naturally also confronted with those changes and that is a strong
reinforcing factor to its obligation to become the leveraging instrument of
Morocco Destination's global image and tourism product positioning in
international consumers' mind. Therefore, MNTO should reevaluate its approach
towards marketing Morocco as a destination to tourists worldwide.
The purpose of this project is to evaluate the technical,
managerial and organizational feasibility of a destination marketing system for
the Moroccan
National Tourism Office. The project is organized as follows:
Section 1 contains an overview of the world tourism travel; Section 2 reviews
the tourism industry characteristics and business constraints; Section 3
introduce the strategic implications of Information Technology on the tourism
industry; Section 4 describe today's Internet travel; Section 5 introduce to
Destination Management System and highlights its success criteria; Section 6
propose the Destination Management System conception and implementation for the
MNTO.
Chapter 2
WORLD TOURISM: AN OVERVIEW
HISTORICAL TREND
International Tourism in past half-century has been marked
foremost by its tremendous expansion. Between 1950 and 2000 the number of
arrivals has shown an evolution from a mere 25 million international arrivals
to 698 million in 2000, corresponding to an average growth rate of 7 %. This
strong overall expansion is also characterized by its geographical spread among
Asian, North African, South American and Caribbean destinations. Numerous
countries in those regions has turned tourism as a primarily source of wealth.
More than 70 countries receive over one million international visitors a
year.
INTERNATIONAL TOURISM IN 2000
World Tourism statistics has traditionally used measurement such
Tourist Arrivals and International Tourist Receipts. According to the World
Tourism Organization (WTO), world tourism grew by an estimated 7.4% in 2000
spurred on by a strong global economy and special events held to commemorate
the new millennium. Nearly 50 million more international trips were made in
2000, the
same number of new tourists as major destinations such Spain or
the United States receive in one year. The number of international arrivals in
2000 totaled 698 million, according to preliminary results released in January
2001 by the WTO. Receipts from international tourism also climbed to US$476
Billion, an increase of 4.5% over the previous year, translating into receipts
per arrival of US$681. All regions of the world hosted more tourists in 2000,
although the fastest developing areas continued to be East Asia and the
Pacific. Countries in Western Mediterranean performed well in 2000 as tourists
shunned away from destinations in East Mediterranean Sea, perceived as to close
to the conflict in Kosovo. Turkey made a great come back with 39.6 %increase in
visitor despite political problems and the 1998 earthquake disaster.
International arrivals to Morocco, for example rose by 7. 4 % in 2000, totaling
4.1 million tourist arrivals, following an excellent 21.6 % increase in 1999
over the previous year.
REGIONAL HIGHLIGHTS
Africa and Middle East: Africa is still left out
of tourism boom despite an enormous potential. While Kenya, Egypt and Morocco
enjoyed strong growth, two of Africa's biggest destinations, (South Africa and
Zimbabwe) suffered setbacks.
Table 1
Top Destination in Africa and the Middle East
Top Destinations
|
Arrivals in 2000
|
% Of change
|
1. South Africa
|
6,108,000
|
+ 1.4%
|
2. Egypt
|
5,150,000
|
+14.7%
|
3. Tunisia
|
5,057,000
|
+4.7%
|
4. Morocco
|
4,100,000
|
+7.4%
|
|
5.Israel
|
2,400,000
|
+3.8%
|
6.Jordan
|
1,256,000
|
-7.5%
|
7.Kenya
|
1,226,000
|
+ 30.0%
|
8.Zimbabwe
|
840,000
|
-60.0%
|
Source: With reference to WTO
Americas: Central America continued to record
the biggest growth in the American continent (+8.8%), while the United States
showed a solid 8.7% increase despite the strength of the US dollar.
Table 2
Top Destinations in the Americas
Top Destinations
|
Arrivals in 2000
|
% Of change
|
1. United States
|
52,690,000
|
+8.7%
|
2. Canada
|
20,423,000
|
+4.9%
|
3. Mexico
|
20,000,000
|
+5.0%
|
4. Brazil
|
5,190,000
|
+1.6%
|
5. Puerto Rico
|
3,094,000
|
+2.3%
|
6. Argentina
|
2,988,000
|
+3.1%
|
7. Dominican Republic
|
2,977,000
|
+ 12.4%
|
8. Uruguay
|
1,968,000
|
-5.1%
|
9. Chile
|
1,71 9,000
|
+6.0%
|
|
10.Cuba
|
1,700,000
|
+8.9%
|
Source: With reference to WTO
East Asia and Pacific: This part of the world
saw important growth driven by China and Honk-Kong. South East Asia especially
Thailand, Cambodia and Vietnam is becoming one of the world's favorite
destination in the world.
Table 3
Top Destinations in East Asia
Top Destinations
|
Arrivals in 2000
|
% Of change
|
1. China
|
31,236,000
|
+15.5%
|
2. Hong Kong
|
13,059,000
|
+ 15.3%
|
3. Malaysia
|
10,000,000
|
+26.1%
|
4. Thailand
|
9,574,000
|
+ 10.5%
|
5. Singapore
|
7,000,000
|
+11.9%
|
6. Macao
|
6,682,000
|
+32.3%
|
7. South Korea
|
5,336,000
|
+ 14.5%
|
8. Indonesia
|
5,012,000
|
+6.0%
|
9. Australia
|
4,882,000
|
+ 9.5%
|
10. Japan
|
4,758,000
|
+7.2%
|
|
Source: With reference to WTO
Europe: The star performer remains Europe with
some 300 million international visitors fueled by Expo 2000 in Germany and the
Vatican Jubilee in Italy. However East Europe is making a come back after the
Kosovo war and Turkey made a strong come back after the natural disaster in
1998.
Table 4
Top Destinations in Europe
Top Destinations
|
Arrivals in 2000
|
% Of change
|
1. France
|
74,000,000
|
+2%
|
2. Spain
|
53,600,000
|
+3.7%
|
3. Italy
|
41,182,000
|
+12.8%
|
4. United Kingdom
|
24,900,000
|
-1.9%
|
5. Russian Federation
|
22,783,000
|
+23.2%
|
6. Germany
|
18,916,000
|
+10.5%
|
7. Poland
|
18,183,000
|
+1.3%
|
8. Austria
|
17,81 8,000
|
+2.0%
|
9. Hungary
|
15,571,000
|
+8.1%
|
10. Greece
|
12,500,000
|
+2.8%
|
11. Portugal
|
12,000,000
|
+3.2%
|
|
14. Turkey
|
9,623,000
|
+39.6%
|
Source: With reference to WTO
All those figures shows that South East Asia is undoubtedly the
fastest growing tourism region in the world and it is likely to keep this trend
for years to come. As West European destinations are becoming more saturated,
and with
WTO's projections of 1 billion International Tourism Arrivals in
2010, regional competition is likely to accentuate, particularly between
Mediterranean and South East Asia tourist destinations.
INTERNATIONAL TOURISM EXPENDITURES
In 1999, 45 countries recorded each more than US$ 1 billion in
international tourism expenditure (WTO, 2000) with the big industrial powers
clearly in the lead. The United States, Germany, the United Kingdom and Japan
toping the list with spending ranging from US$ 29 billion to US$ 56 billion per
year. Those countries represent over one-third of total international tourism
expenditure.
According to a study by the World Travel and Tourism Council
(WTTC), travel and tourism is the world's largest industry directly or
indirectly driving more than 10% of global jobs, GDP, and investment.
In an increasingly global society, the economic and social
contribution of this industry to the world is highly significant and continues
to grow.
International aviation is the prime engine of travel and
tourism, which presently contributes more than USD 3,500 billion to the world
economy, or nearly 12 percent of the total. More than 192 million jobs are
generated, 8% of the world total. Capital investment for travel and tourism is
at present US$ 733
billion a year. This represents more than 11 percent of the world
total (IATA, 2000).
MOROCCO DESTINATION OVERVIEW
Destination Positioning
Morocco is roughly comparable in size, geography and climate to
California, with a population of 35 millions. Morocco is a unique country. The
destination holds an unquestionable differentiating advantage with a product
that has a strong cultural content and incomparable geographical diversity,
which brings big potential to seaside Atlantic coast beaches, mountains and
inland Sahara desert adventure tourism that is enjoyable all year long. Given
the product attributes of Morocco as a destination and the characteristics and
trends of International Tourism that is leaning toward cultural discovery and
adventure, the destination holds a potentially promising future.
Market Share
Morocco repre sent a very small portion of this huge business
with less than 0.6% of the International tourism flow or 4.1 millions
international visitors annually generating $2.8 billions total revenue (Source:
WTO 2001). European Union members (France, Spain, Germany, Italy, Benelux and
Great Britain generate nearly 70% of inbound travel to Morocco. North America
outbound
tourism to Morocco reaches a mere 5%. The Middle East and North
East Asia also generate almost 5% of total arrivals. Total airborne
International arrivals represent 66%. According to the Ministry of Tourism,
tourism sector contributed in 1999, to 8% of the Gross Domestic Product (GDP),
generating 600,000 (direct and indirect) jobs.
Competition and Potential Development
Direct competitive destinations to Morocco are those with similar
tourism products content with strong cultural and adventures attributes in the
perimeter of the Mediterranean Sea. Such Destinations are Turkey, Egypt,
Israel, Tunisia, Portugal, Spain and South Africa that is part of the African
continent. However new entrants from South East Asia region are more and more
direct competitors despite their distances from the European world biggest
outbound market. Those countries are represented by Thailand, Malaysia and most
recently aggressive destinations such as Vietnam and Cambodia.
Traditional competitors such as Egypt and Turkey have
accomplished tremendous progress by developing a strong tourism industry in the
last decade. Morocco despite being an earlier entrant in new developing
countries destinations lagged behind because of lack of strategic vision and
planning. The country slipped from a 25th position in International
Arrivals in 1990 to 37th
rank in 1999. The tourism industry suffered a structural crisis
leading to insufficient lodging capacity and deteriorating infrastructure and
quality product. In 1999 effective lodging capacity was reaching a mere 70,000
beds in total. At the same time Egypt and Tunisia lodging capacity were set to
140,000 and 180,000 respectively. However Morocco destination is recovering
from the structural crisis and a jointly public-private sector initiative
identified major red tapes that have to be eliminated as well as fiscal
incentives to apply for a successful tourism development policy. Actions have
already been taken to attract foreign investment, while numerous major
infrastructure projects are being launched. Morocco destination should be able
to attract 10 million international tourists by 2010, thus becoming one of the
major Mediterranean tourism destinations.
Chapter 3
TOURISM INDUSTRY
The Tourism industry is by definition a global industry with a
worldwide network of producers, suppliers, and intermediaries. There are a few
large multinational airlines, tour operators, hotel chain and theme parks. The
tourism enterprise-overwhelming majority is small or medium size business. This
is particularly true in the case of Morocco destination.
GLOBAL CHARACTERISTICS
> Global industry (Tourists= 698 millions, Expenditures = $476
billions) > Air Transport liberalization =New entrants
> Highly competitive
> Capital-intensive industry
> Information based industry
> 9 dominants players: Developed countries (USA, France,
Italy, Spain, United Kingdom, Germany, etc.) with 51% of worldwide total
receipts.
> Less Developed Countries with 12.3 % of total receipts
with China leading with 23 millions arrivals and 2.3 % of total world
receipts.
CORE CHARACTERISTICS
The industry is by essence an information intensive service
industry that has historically struggled under the weight of fragmented supply
chains, which results in complex and often-inefficient business processing.
Firstly it is heterogeneous and hence relies most exclusively upon
representations and descriptions (information in printed and audiovisual
format) by the travel trade and other intermediaries for its ability to attract
consumers. Unlike durable goods, intangible tourism services cannot be
physically displayed or inspected at the point of sale before purchasing.
Hence, they are normally bought before the time of use and away from the place
of their consumption (Buhalis, 1996). Tourism products are particularly
difficult to describe due to their multi-national and cultural character.
Different cultures, cuisine, customs, constitute the context, whereas the
content is represented by geographical locality, lodging amenities and
attractions/activities. So the information provided through images portrayed by
media, promotional materials and word of mouth is highly critical for provision
and distribution of tourism products. Tourism products require a great degree
of commitment and cannot be replaced, should consumers being not satisfied with
their attributes. Therefore timely and accurate information is the key success
to successful satisfaction of the demand (Buhalis, 1994). Furthermore success
will depend on the quick identification of the consumer needs and the
interaction with prospective clients, by using comprehensive, personalized and
up to date
media to convey this information and to design that specific
product that will satisfy today's more experienced consumer.
MARKET CHARACTERISTICS
Until today's new ITs' driven competitive environment, few
players in the various sectors of the tourist industry understood the
importance of cooperation and networking because of the fragmented nature of
the travel market. In particular DMOs and the travel trade still do not
collaborate adequately to represent their destination globally to foreign
markets. The public sector and private sector are in fact addressing tourists'
needs separately without a system that can enable the creation of a value chain
that strengthens the performance of the destination in a synergic manner. On
the contrary conflicts are created by the dissimilar objectives and interest of
various stakeholders, thus hurting the destination in general.
DMOs Intermediaries
Suppliers
GOV. BODIES
NTO
RTO
Primary Supplier
T.O CRS/
GDS
Travel Agent
Hotel Chain
Airlines
Figure 1. Stylized View of the Tourism and Travel Market
(Werthner 1993)
Figure 1 represents a functional and structural view of the
tourism and travel market. It differentiates between the supply and the demand
side and the different intermediaries. Links mark the relationship as well as
the flow of information. On the supply side, primary suppliers are hotels,
restaurants, cultural or sport event organizers, etc, which are mostly Small
and Medium Tourism Enterprises (SMTEs). Tour Operators (TOs) can be seen as
product aggregators whereas Travel Agents, act as information brokers,
providing the consumer with relevant information and booking facilities.
Computerized Reservation Systems (CRSs) and Global Distribution Systems (GDSs)
cover airlines offering as well as other products such as packages holidays.
They provide the main links to TOs and to travel agents. Whereas the
intermediaries on the right side are the commercial link between supplier and
consumer, the left side is relevant for destination management and planning
entities such as DMOs (National Tourist Offices (NTOs) and Regional Tourist
Offices (RTO)) that are not involved in the booking process.
Table 5
Pre Internet Tourism
Countries
|
Producers
|
Intermediaries
|
Consumers
|
D
E
S
T
I
N
A
T
I
O
N
|
Hotels
Restaurants
Airlines
Provisions
Entertainment Recreations
|
Hotel Chain
Tour Operator
Travel Agent
GDS/CRS
Tourism associations
|
Tourists
|
DMO
|
|
Source: UNCTAD, 2000
COMPETITIVE CONSTRAINTS FOR DESTINATIONS
Developing countries have often used their natural and
geographical endowments to achieve remarkable growth in their tourism sector.
However, a number of circumstances common, but not exclusive, to developing
countries such as Morocco militate against their efforts to develop a strong
tourism export sector (UNCTAD, 2000):
> A generally weaker bargaining position towards international
tour operators;
> Long distances and less than acute or no competition result
in high air fares;
> Global distribution systems (GDSs) and computer reservation
systems (CRSs) owned by large international airlines;
> An increasingly competitive global tourism sector, where
natural competitive advantages are becoming less significant;
INDUSTRY'S DRIVING FORCES
> The tourism sector is profiting from the processes of
globalization and liberalization.
> Tourism producers and intermediaries are increasingly
competing on the confidence inspired in the customer directly through the
quality of the information they provide.
> The tourism industry is learning fast that the Internet can
satisfy this need far better than any other existing technology.
> The use of the Internet in developed countries for
purchasing tourism products is increasing dramatically.
> National tourism boards and tourism business associations
will exercise the leadership in embracing the digital age.
MARKETING CONSTRAINTS FOR TOURISM BOARDS
The marketing of a destination is a very difficult task because
the Tourism and Travel product is complex, consisting of a set of very
different products that are perishable in a highly information based
industry
environment. As keepers of the destination «brand»,
Tourists Boards are responsible for positioning the destination in the mind of
the consumer. This usually involves expensive print or broadcast media
campaigns, often with no call to action or sometimes with a number to call for
brochures fulfillment. The main objective is to raise awareness and create the
destination positioning in the tourist's mind. Today the effectiveness of
Destination Marketing Organization's traditional promotional actions are to be
questioned giving the new overall economic, social and technical back round,
which has to be considered, that shows the following trends according to the
International Federation of Information Tourism and Technology (IFITT,
Innsbruck, Austria).
> A further increase in tourism can be expected; the future
development of the industry will result in further differentiation and mass
customization as well as consolidation and globalisation. (Regional
competition).
> A common infrastructure, including software and hardware
tools and enabling e-commerce is emerging.
> Technology is becoming transparent and invisible to the
consumer. (DMO's that are not embracing technology will disappear).
> Information is already available at home, the work place and
during travel enabled by mobile computing and WAP technology.
> Destination branding will become more important, leading
probably to virtual organization branding with different products integrated
into e- commerce architectures.
These changes in the worldwide travel industry are having
tremendous impact on DMO s' traditional marketing models. Nowhere are the
changes mentioned above more evident than in the use of information to
position, market and sell destinations. Therefore major issues are to be
addressed, in this new strategic environment. DMOs are condemned to adapt their
mission, marketing and organizations to new models in order to create a
platform of development of the tourist demand at the level of the nation as a
destination in our modern information society.
Chapter 4
TOURISM AND INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY
DEMAND TRENDS AND INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY
ITs are not new to tourism industry. Computerized networks, and
particularly airline Computer Reservation Systems (CRSs) have been leading
dramatic changes since the early 1 970's. Airlines realized that their presence
through interfaces on travel agencies desktop was critical to attract booking
and manage their inventory and capacity distribution. The evolution of CRSs to
Global Distribution Systems (GDSs) in the early 1980's developed the first
electronic marketplace by integrating other airlines' reservation systems as
well as providing booking access to a range of tourism products from hotel to
car rentals. However the traditional CRS/GDS had only improved the information
communications between tourism businesses such as airlines and travel agents,
as they do not interact directly with the consumer. The systems are also
expensive to both the tourism producer and the retailer. Moreover these systems
are flawed with incompatibilities between each other, especially in the lodging
sector where «switch» companies such as THISCO (The Hotel Industry
Switching Company) was needed to connect hotels with majors GDSs, to facilitate
room reservations
for travel agents worldwide (Liu, 2000). But one should keep in
mind that GDSs are the backbone of the electronic distribution system of the
travel industry.
Information Technologies' (ITs) rapid developments in the 1990s
are now having profound impacts and implications for the whole tourism
industry. Beside the macroeconomic level where ITs are regarded as instrumental
in regional development, long term pro sperity, new information society and
knowledge-based economic powers (Buhalis, 1996), tourism is inevitably
influenced by the business re-engineering experience that this revolution had
provide (WTO, 1998). As information is the life-blood of the travel industry
(Sheldon, 1997), effective use of technology is fundamental to the tourism
sector. The most pro found impact of ITs on tourism management is efficiency in
cooperation among the industry's actors and the availability of tools for a
real globalization of the industry. It changes the best operation practices and
provides opportunities for business expansion in the geographical, marketing
and operational sense (Buhalis, 2000). As a result ITs facilitate the
integration of the industry in both geographical and operational terms.
(expansion to new productdestinations and vertical integration). Consequently,
tourism destinations must compete in a fiercely competitive marketplace; thus,
ITs have become a critical factor in determining future success or failure, as
well as tourism impacts at destinations. In fact ITs can empower promotion's
management and distributions of product-destination through the development of
Destination Marketing Systems (Buhalis, 1997).
Destinations increasingly attract international tourism from
distant and long haul markets, making information dissemination more imperative
than ever. Outbound markets are characterized by short gateways breaks with
trip decisions made on impulse from previous trips shortly before departures.
Therefore, the international tourist put emphasis on speed and information's
availability and accuracy as well as efficient reservation facilities. He is
increasingly more sophisticated and «wired». Consequently the rapid
development of both tourism supply and demand makes ITs an imperative partners
of the industry and thus ITs ever more play an important role in tourism
marketing, distribution, promotion and co-ordination (Buhalis and Spada, 2000).
Efficiency, speed and flexibility in responding to consumer requirements and
needs are now becoming a core competency in tourism marketing. ITs tools now
facilitate mass customization of tourism products. Complex and flexible bundles
of tourism offering can be configured. Furthermore ITs' based knowledge
management tools enable individualized marketing to customers (Werthner and
Klein, 1999).
Hence tourism organizations should develop partnerships aimed to
improve business processes using ITs, which will enhance the quality of their
interactions with their stakeholders from the producer to the supplier to the
consumer. The challenge for the industry is to provide a seamless integration
of information and physical service, with flexible configurations of the
physical and the information parts. Destinations that provide timely,
appropriate and accurate information, using ITs tools, to consumers and the
travel trade, have a better
chance of being selected and of strengthening their
competitiveness (Buhalis, Spada, 2000).
Today the development of the Internet revolutionized the usage of
ITs by providing the infrastructure of intra and inter-organization networking
between all computer users. The problem of GDSs incompatibility can now be
addressed effectively and cheaply. In addition a web base GDS has improved the
quality of information delivery (window based computer screen) and is
accessible instantly worldwide at a cheaper cost. The Internet tool enabled
instant distribution of rich media colorful content, booking capabilities and
e-commerce platforms to conduct online business. It offers substantial
advantages in communications, market research, market targeting, costumer
services, product development, cost savings and product delivering. Today, the
Internet is widely recognized as an extremely valuable marketing tool.
Inside organization
Between organizations
Between organization and clients
LAN Org.
MIS
C RS/GDS
Web page
W W W
System
I T
Coop. System
Figure 2. The deployment of IT in Tourism (With ref. to Shertler
W., 1990).
ICT STRATEGIC IMPLICATIONS FOR TOURISM
The most significant strategic implication of ITs is the
development of competitive advantages by product differentiation, seamless
product packaging for niche markets, cost reduction in the business processing
and travel distribution as well as increased speed of information retrieval and
exchange.
Table 6
Tourism Competitive Drivers in ITs Environment
Globalisation of Tourism Supply
Fierce Global Competition
Efficiency in Communication and Operation
Development of Yield Management systems
New Distribution Channels and Cost Control
Competitive advantages through Differentiation
Flexible and Customized Tourism Products
Product Innovation
Creating Seamless Tourist Experience
Close Interaction with Consumers
Building relationship and one-to-one Marketing
Source: WTO, 1998
The emerging globalization and tremendous competition between
tourism destinations require great degree of efficiency in communications and
operations. Adoption of ITs provides new ways of collecting, analyzing,
transmitting and delivering information and new ways to facilitate the creation
and transmission of knowledge throughout the tourism industry. The tourism
product being a «confidence good» (Werthner, Klein, 1999), an
assessment on the product quality before a buying action is practically
impossible. Information of high content and knowledge is therefore needed.
Organizations that offer that
degree of efficiency in information delivery, both externally and
internally will be able to succeed in the marketplace. The use of ITs' tools to
achieve that goal by providing instantaneous, flexible and customized products
to customers constitute a certain competitive advantage in a technological
driven competitive environment.
The dramatic grow of Internet has begun to fundamentally change
the relationship between consumers and suppliers. The way that buyers and
sellers share information and transactions has dramatically improved. Many if
not most, commerce relationships are very inefficient in the travel space.
(Bear, Stearns & CO, 2000). Because buyers and sellers are dispersed over
wide geographic areas and the transactions execution in the travel business is
by essence very complex, it almost appear as if the Internet were specifically
designed to correct the inefficiencies in research and transactions that are
inherent to the travel industry.
DMO
Consumer
Destin. System
Tourist
Routing Server
T.O
Hotel
T.A
GDS
|
|
|
|
Airlines
|
Supplier
|
|
Primarily Supplier
|
|
|
|
|
|
Figure 3. Current and Future Position of Online Services
(Werthner and Klein, 1999)
The new marketplace is now a set of players (GDS, TOs, hotel
chain,
airlines, travel agents) that pursue an online strategy. The
above figure shows that technology, not only, enables direct access to the
consumer, but also improves
the internal information flow and cooperation processes
(Intranet, Extranet). The Internet serves as a centralized source for
information on many related travel
topics (i.e., air, hotel, car, attractions, activities). Internet
applications are now the electronic interface to the world's suppliers and
consumers. In electronic
marketplace, marketing push is replaced by marketing pull
(Fingar, Kumar & Sharma, 1999).
The Internet since its inception created a world of communities
of interest where peoples share ideas, information and opinions. Services are
defined now from a supplier and a consumer perspective (Werthner, Klein, 1999).
The consumer pool is now a very powerful agent in the suppliers marketing
strategy. Existing channels of distribution are giving way to global
communities-of-interest that eliminate channel components that they do not
perceive as adding value. For example, American Airlines' Travelocity was
originally designed so that travel agents would still add value by being the
means of delivering the ticket. Consumers who represent the travel community
saw little value in this arrangement and the travel agent was disintermediated
from the process (Fingar, Kumar & Sharma, 1999).
Those new intermediaries or online booking servers such as
Travelocity, Expedia, Preview Travel that are potentially dangerous for travel
agents act as virtual travel agents or travel supermarkets providing booking
facilities for air, hotel, car rentals as well as many information retrieval
services. They are new players often called «Infomediaries». They had
come with innovative business models that combine consumer advocacy (being well
aware of communities-ofinterest power) and flexible pricing. The infomediaries
have strategically positioned their applications in order to generate benefits
for customers and
suppliers such as reducing transaction's costs and generating
volume for suppliers witch are not feasible in direct sales mode.
Although it is recognized that the Internet medium is chaotic,
mainly because a lack of standardization and immaturity, it is evident that the
World Wide Web provide inexpensive delivery of information concerning every
single enterprise and destination. Thus the Internet empowers the marketing and
communication functions of remote, peripheral and insular destinations as well
as Small and Medium sized Tourism Enterprises (SMTEs). They are now able to
communicate directly to their prospective customers and differentiate their
product offering. Competitiveness and prosperity of both tourism enterprises
and destination in the new millennium will depend on the degree of innovation
by using the new strategic tools provided by the revolutionary information
technology.
In any case failure to take advantages of Information Technology
will undoubtedly lead to competitive disadvantage for organizations that fail
to adapt to those sweeping changes. Hence the pervasive ITs tools especially
Internet require re-engineering of business processes, as well as the
development of a strategic vision and commitment. Tourism destinations and
enterprises will therefore be able to embrace change and develop their
competitiveness in this new digital age.
Table 7
Internet Enabled Tourism
Countries
|
Producers
|
Intermediaries
|
Infomediaries
|
Consumers
|
D
|
|
|
Web based
|
|
E
|
Hotels
|
Hotel Chain
|
travel and
|
|
|
|
|
Tourism
|
|
S
|
|
|
|
|
|
Restaurants
|
Tour Operator
|
Hotel
|
|
T
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Chain.com
|
Tourists
|
I
|
Airlines
|
Travel Agent
|
Tour
|
|
N
|
Provisions
|
GDS/CRS
|
Operator.com
|
|
A
|
Entertainment
|
Tourism
|
Travel
|
|
T
|
Recreations
|
associations
|
Agent.com
|
|
I
|
|
DMO
|
Tourism
associations.com
|
|
O
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
DMO.com
|
|
N
|
|
|
|
|
Source: With reference to UNCTAD, 2000
Chapter 5
INTERNET TRAVEL
THE GLOBAL NET
The Internet continues to grow at a phenomenal pace. Internet
users have soared from 171 million in 1999 to 354 millions as of today (NUA
Internet Survey, 2001). North America remains ahead with 135 million of the
world total. Europe and Asia Pacific follow with 113 million and 105 million
Internet users respectively. Current predictions indicate that Internet users
could exceed the 1 billion mark by 2005, with the explosion of Internet access
wireless devices. According to the International Technology and Trade Associate
(ITTA, 2000), adoption of Internet and IT sector is at the heart of the decade
long economic expansion. The adoption of IT and Internet tools has driven
growth in almost every sector including travel and tourism by practically
doubling productivity. The Web contains 2.1 billion indexable pages (7 million
pages added daily) distributed over 17.7 million sites. «Dot-Com»
domain names dominate the Internet with 9.4 million sites.
|
Number of Worldwide Online Households
(in millions)
200
|
150 100 50
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
0
YEARS
|
|
Figure 4. Number of Worldwide Online Households (Bear, Stearns
& CO, 2000).
INTERNET BUSINESS TRAVEL
United States
Approximately 90 million online travelers or about 44 percent of
the U.S. adult population are online travelers (past-year travelers who
currently use the Internet). Two-thirds (66%) of online travelers or 59.4
million U.S. adults have used the Internet to make travel plans in the last
year (PhoCusWright, 2001). Travel planning consists of activities such as
getting information on destinations or checking prices and schedules. This is
up 23 percent from 48.1 million adults in 1999. Among them 21.9 millions adults
or 36 percent of current Internet users have used the Internet to make travel
reservations in the past year. Travel reservations include actual booking or
paying an airline ticket,
hotel room, rental car, and package tour. The number of online
travel buyers is projected to reach 72 million in 2003. (Forrester Research,
2000)
Search engine websites are the most popular for online travel
planning (62%). Company-run websites and destination sites are also popular at
51 and 48 percent each. Online travel agency sites are used by over half (36%)
of online travel planners (Travel Industry Association of America, 2000).
Figure 5. Types of Internet sites used for Travel Planning.
(Travel Industry Association of America, 2000)
Travel is the most important business on the web in term of the
volume of e-commerce (eMarketer, 1999). By 2003, US$29 billion in travel will
be sold online, almost four times 1 999's level (Forrester Research, 2000).
Despite this immense growth most Internet travel research companies' estimates,
only put
online travel booking at 10% of total travel booking in 2003.
Today airline booking represents 60% of total Internet travel buying.
Figure 6. Online Buying in United States (With reference to Bear,
Stearns & CO, 2000)
Europe
The European online travel market is gaining prominence as the
economic signs for this e-commerce segment continue to grow stronger. The
European online travel market will soar from US$2.9 billion in 2000 to US$10.9
billion in 2002 - nearly a 300% two-year gain (PhoCusWright, 2001).
Factors contributing to this growth were continuing rapid
expansion in Internet and wireless usage; the breakdown of e-commerce barriers
such as bill payment, security and privacy concerns; improved
telecommunications; and the
influx of new and improved online travel services. Increasingly,
Europeans are able to access the Internet using flat-rate payment plans instead
of having to pay for Internet access by the minute, which had been a major
constraint. At the same time, several online players have begun to build
significant market share - and are raising public awareness of travel
e-commerce in the process. Airline Web sites and tour operators control 28% and
27%, respectively, of the European online travel market in 2000. Online travel
agencies have a 26% market share; railways, 9%; hotels, 7%; and car rental
companies, 3%. Unlike in the U.S., supplier Web sites dominate the online
travel market in Europe. Airlines, tour operators, hotels, railways and car
rental companies represent
74% of the European online travel market in 2000, while online
agencies' share is 26%.
Airline Web site sales will total $810 million in 2000, while
$382 million of airline tickets will be sold through online travel agencies.
The two airlines with the largest online bookings, Easy Jet and Ryan air book
100% of their Internet sales on their own Web sites.
Chapter 6
DESTINATION MANAGEMENT SYSTEM
NATURE OF A NATIONAL TOURISM OFFICE
One of the main tasks of National Tourist Offices (NTOs) that are
called often Destination Marketing Organizations (DMOs) is to create a platform
for the development of tourism demand at the level of the nation as a
destination, while promoting vertical cooperation with Tour Operators in the
outbound markets and domestic regional tourism Associations, in the area of
marketing. Until recently and still for the vast majority of DMOs, the main
concern is market communication for the purpose of positioning the destination
in relation to worldwide competitors, making use of conventional media.
Generally the DMOs do not attempt or take very little advantage of other
marketing mix tools such as product development, pricing policy or
distribution. With some exceptions, they are among the less developed players
in the online tourism industry.
Tourism Destinations emerge as umbrella brands and they need
to be promoted in the global marketplace as one entity for each target market
they want to attract (Paulo Rita, 1999). Tourism is a networked and
information- intensive industry. The success of DMOs depends therefore on the
quality of the
infrastructure (e.g. road, highway system) of the destination
they represent (Gartrell, 1988). The Internet is part of the infrastructure.
Thus, the mission of National Tourism Offices in contributing to the domestic
economy by maintaining destination attractiveness and by increasing the
awareness of prospective visitors is challenged by a whole new environment. It
is difficult for most of NTOs to keep pace with the emergence of innovative
marketing strategies based on ITs. In these new conditions set by the ITs'
revolution, DMOs need to determine to what extent they wish to make use of the
possibilities offered by information technology, and with what systems. The
question of how to move from the current way of doing business to one that is
responsive to these changes becomes a vital concern (Gretzel, et. al.,
2000).
COMPREHENSIVE STUDY OF A DMS
Definition
A Destination Management System is a web based integrated
information, destination marketing and reservation systems. They
may be referred elsewhere as Destination Databases or Destination Marketing
Systems. It is a combination of technological enablers and demand drivers that
has propelled the realization of destination management systems (Buhalis &
Spada, 2000). Buhalis and Pringle described it as:» a collection of
computerized information, interactively accessible, about a
destination».
DMSs are usually managed by destination management organizations
witch may be public such as state tourism offices or private organizations or a
combination of both (Pollock, 1998). They must provide timely, appropriate and
accurate information for tourism stakeholders:
u On the demand side they cater for multiple forms of access by
potential visitors, directly or through travel agents and tour operators,
through call
centers, visitor information centers, airlines' GDS, Internet and
interactive Web television. Potential visitors can be logged into a client
database and tracked through their purchase life cycle.
u On the supply side DMSs provide a comprehensive database of
products and services that the destination has to offer. Destinations
Management Systems are attractive to the consumer as well as the travel trade
as they provide a one-stop marketplace.
Historic background
More than 200 DMSs have been conceptualized and developed around
the world the last decade. However few systems have reached the major goal as
global distributors of all products of tourism destinations. The grand majority
of these systems have been implemented in local level and operate on a limited
basis, thus many of them had collapsed few years after their initial
development. (Buhalis, Spada, 2000).
DMSs are often limited in their scope and ambition by a
non-supportive organizational structure or by their technology. As a result
many commercial structures emerged with the consequence of inaccurate
information range since they favor big suppliers that can afford membership
fees in detriment of SMTEs with weaker financial resources (Buhalis, Spada,
2000). Therefore, destinations with an economic tissue mostly constituted by
low tech and marginalized regional SMTEs will suffer setbacks that are likely
to disadvantage their regional tourism industry development.
DMS Fundamental Objectives
The overall objectives of a DMO are to increase the productivity
of public and private tourism professionals, and to improve the satisfaction of
the international tourists through the use of advanced information and
communication technology, in order to create economic wealth and jobs. In
particular, DMSs look after the followings:
· The availability of an Internet server offering
information and primarily dissemination of tourism marketing information and
execution of electronic bookings and payments
· A critical mass of users/beneficiaries sufficient for the
self-support of the system and its organization
· The promotion of STMEs in the global market with low
costs
· The exploration of new and niche markets.
· Forecasts and a better understanding of the
evolution of the market.
· Increase of knowledge and capacity of the DMOs and
SMTEs to answer to the market trends.
The DMS aims to provide with all the information that a
potential visitor might need to make the decision to become an actual visitor,
and to choose that destination out of all other alternatives. The DMS is
therefore a marketing tool for the whole destination in a virtual context.
Consequently a virtual destination must not be a repository of information from
a single source but rather from an entire community that is competing in the
international tourism market. It is an extremely interactive communication tool
that encourages communication between its visitors and the members of the
community it represents. It promotes communication beyond the realm of business
but favors and encourages ultimately online transactions.
Destination Stakeholders' objectives
From a product supplier perspective a DMS can
assist its enterprise to know more on what the existing and potential costumers
want, to reach them, satisfy their needs in order to operate its business
profitably. Moreover the global e-marketplace accessibility is provided to the
full range of tourism enterprises, from the five star resorts to the craft
shops. At the same time they are able to
benefit from NTOs promotional activities and trade under a
widely known umbrella brand of the national destination.
The National Tourism Offices' objectives are
more complicated, in view of their mission and responsibilities. They do not
market accommodations or transportation but provide physical data and data
mining. In fact they are in the business of shifting the market information
back and forward. Their main objective is to foster an environment in witch the
tourism sector can prosper through well-directed marketing operations,
information integration, training and regulations.
For the consumer, simplicity, quick access to
accurate information and booking facilities to speed up travel decision while
saving money are the most important objectives. Visitors traditionally are
interested in both natural beauty and cultural heritage; but in addition to
such attractions they like to be able to choose their own products and get an
emotional experience.
DMS s' Success Criteria
As «info-structures», DMSs must enable destinations
to disseminate comprehensive information about resources and services of a
destination and local tourism products as well as to facilitate the planning,
management and marketing of countries as tourism entities or brands. However
previous failures
have prompted for the need of a close examination on success
criteria that have to be taken into consideration before conceptualizing and
developing a DMS.
Recently, an exploratory research combining qualitative and
quantitative methodologies conducted by Dimitrios Buhalis, Senior Lecturer,
School of Management Studies, University of Surrey (U.K), demonstrated the
important necessity of public - private sector cooperation, as being the most
powerful enabler of a DMS development and implementation. However, lack of
commercial background and bureaucracy often diminish public agencies capability
to foster greater cooperation between industry's stakeholders and to exercise
influence over the direction of DMSs' success criteria.
Buhalis and Spada synthesized the research results by proposing
a «5'Cs»framework namely: Choice, Convenience, Consistency and
Competitive Pricing, that groups identified DMS's success criteria for six key
tourism stakeholders. The following figure present most important selected
criteria among stakeholders:
Tourism Supplier
Use of DMS as promotional tool Provisions of guaranteed
bookings
DMS's ability to distribute info globally
Reduction of IT cost
User-Friendly
Public sector
Use of DMS as promotional tool
|
Public sector
Marketing tool
Support of SMTEs Economic benefits Quality and accuracy Use
DMS as management tool
|
|
Consumer
Comprehensive info before, during, and after trip
Speedy transactions
Secure online payments
User-friendly system
Multi-channel access
Virtual tour
Wild range of choices
Help function
|
|
TOs
Reduction of distribution & communication costs
Market info
Inventory management
Minimum membership fees
|
Travel Agents
Info reliability & accuracy
Real time info
Use of DMS to compete with TOs Online bookings capability
|
|
Investors
Profit center ability
Private -Public partnership
System's operating efficiency
System's Ability of strategic alliances
System's ability to interface with other systems Profitability
of membership fees
|
|
Figure 8. Success Criteria for a DMS (With reference to Buhalis
& Spada, 2000)
The five values (5Cs), which synthesize the above success
criteria, are the guiding requirements of a successful conceptualization and
development of a DMS. Therefore, various stakeholders' cooperation is critical
to achieve this cooperative network, so all actors can enable the creation of
this value chain of: Awareness- Information-Booking-Consumer Relationship. On
one hand the public sector boasts considerable degree of influence through
planning and legislation. It represents a major tool for fostering cooperation
among different stakeholders. On the other hand the private sector involvement
is significant in contributing essential capital, know how and commercial drive
that determine the profitability and viability of a DMS.
EXISTING DMSs
TIScover, Austria
Tyrolean Information System (TIScover) has been operating for
five years. It is the most worthy of comparison. In 1997, which was its first
complete year of operation, over 23 000 transactions were made through the
Austrian DMS (TIScover), generating about $8million in revenue. In 1998
TIScover generated accommodation revenue of about $20 million, which was set to
increase to about $55 million in 1999. It was hoped that break-even for the
TIScover Internet investment will be reached in 1999. TIScover adopted a
clientserver intranet/internet model. From 1998 until the middle of 1999, in
Austria,
England, Scotland, Ireland, TIScover was the only or at least
the most comprehensive destination-based booking system, which offers online
bookings via the Internet, and certainly the one that generates most revenue.
TIScover has since been privatized in order to provide more freedom to attract
more private sector capital.
Gulliver, Ireland
In Ireland there is a system called Gulliver, which is Ireland's
most advanced and comprehensive tourism database. Gulliver is build on a
distributed client-server system based around Windows NT 4.0/SQL server with
static data being accessed locally on PCs. Originally it was an
information-only system without booking facilities, like one of its
forerunners, the Danish Dan data. It is now possible to make bookings via the
Internet through the Bord Failte (Irish Tourist Board) website, with instant
confirmation. In 1998 the amount of reservations and booking enquiries has been
estimated to almost 87 000, 75% of which are assumed to lead to actual stays,
each generating $307 in revenue. For 1999 about 200 000 reservations and
booking enquiries were expected, 75% of which are assumed to lead to actual
stays, each generating $364 in revenue. Gulliver has been sold to a private
operator in 1997. FEXCO a foreign exchange company secured a majority (74%)
stake in this new joint venture and took Gulliver forward as this acquisition
shows an obvious synergy with the company's core strength: the expertise in
provision telesales and technology-based retail
solutions (Frew & O'Connor, 1999). Today well over 1.5
million people worldwide have used Gulliver's site to access detailed
information on Ireland (Irish Tourist Board, 2001).
Chapter7
DMS FAISABILITY FOR MOROCCO DESTINATION
MNTO MARKETING CHALLENGE
Major issues
· Attract, retain high spending independent traveler
· Create a seamless marketing system with GDS/CRS
leverage
· Improve destination marketing
· Organizational barriers
Strategic Environment
(See next page)
Competitive environment
IT DRIVERS ECONOMIC CONSTRAINTS
· Competition based on quality of information
· Internet use increasing
dramatically
· National tourism boards
embracing the digital age
|
· Globalization and liberalization
· A generally weaker bargaining position towards TOs
· GDSs and CRSs owned by large airlines
· Natural competitive advantages less significant
· Open skies results in lower airfares
|
|
Destination Marketing SWOT Analysis
Strengths
|
Weaknesses
|
Opportunities
|
Treats
|
-Product brand
name
-Product attributes -Mild seasonality
|
-Capacity
-Air transportation -Inefficient MNTO -Lack of IT in tourism
|
-National awareness -Saturated North Mediterranean
destinations
|
-Competition - IT tools in competitive destination
|
Figure 8. Morocco Destination Marketing SWOT Analysis
MARKETING OBJECTIVES
Overall Objectives
Information constitute undoubtedly MNTO's raw material necessary
to accomplish and perform its core competency witch is Destination Marketing.
However, the industry's small and medium players have little know-how
concerning the use of information and communication technologies, lack of
digitized promotion material and absence of any kind of database. The MNTO
should therefore play a proactive role in the future development of national
tourism through the implementation of appropriate information, communication
and marketing tools. Information management should constitute MNTO's new
competitive advantage. MNTO should therefore seek the implementation of a
successful Destination Marketing System that will enable the Tourism Board to
store online information, market it to the private sector and use it to
streamline
its promotional strategy. It supposes the acquisition of the
necessary technology in order to be able to manage, structure, and integrate
the information. Implementation of a synergic platform, therefore, becomes a
prerequisite to a destination marketing system.
Tourism Businesses
The main strategic target for a DMS is undoubtedly the
independent traveler. However the tourist businesses (all range of domestic
suppliers and
foreign markets intermediaries) are the backbone of the system.
So the MNTO should define DMS objectives accordingly:
> Altering existing tourism distribution channels to increase
the autonomy of regional destinations and Small and Medium Tourism Enterprises
(SMTEs)
> Bridging the Distance between the SMTE of peripheral and
remote locations and travel agencies worldwide
> Reducing the SMTEs dependence upon intermediaries and big
tour operators.
> DMS is the answer to large commercial tourism
distribution and reservation systems and to the ongoing concentration and
mergers in Europe distribution system.
> Targeting smaller groups of holiday's makers (customization
and special packaging especially in the US).
> Building intra and inter regional cooperation with an
operational, and commercially viable information, communication and marketing
system at the disposal of regional tourism organizations and foreign based
bureaus (Intranet).
The Consumer
Tourism destination marketing is based on intangibility and
perishability. Clearly the international tourist and mostly the independent
traveler is the main target for a DMS. The Moroccan National Tourism Office's
marketing objectives should focus on maintaining and improving the contact with
the tourist (at home or at the destination) through multimedia up to date
information and instant booking (Internet). Travel and Tourism
fit especially well with interactive media because of the industry's
information intensive characteristic. Interactive media
provided by a DMS call for interactive marketing. « The
essence of interactive marketing is the use of information from the customer
rather than about the customer» (Day, 1998). The MNTO markets intangible
experience. A DMS must then be able to deliver this intangibility by providing
pictures and chat rooms through its Web site. So information readiness and
availability, easy booking and expert advice are the most adding value factors
to the destination products and services.
BUILDING THE WEB BASED DMS
Database Characteristics
Accessible via Internet, Product information database will covers
a full range of accommodation from small «Riyadh» (traditional
houses) to five
star hotels and self-catering such as apartments and villas. It
should also covers Car Rental, Flights, Ferries, Rail. The product database
has, naturally, to be tailored according to the needs of the Morocco Tourism
Office. Its web
support should be professionally designed, reflecting Morocco
cultural richness with friendly user interface, bring technologically reliable
online booking system and secured End-to-End transactions. This database will
store information for the use of potential and actual visitors, suppliers, and
planners. It can contain information about both private and public sector
services. This includes accommodation and restaurants, attractions, weather
conditions, events, public transport and timetables museums, art
galleries, festivals and the like. Enquiries, by independent travelers, for
specific information can also be stored in the Marketing Database thus building
the client profile.
The real opportunity in databases is to build relationship with
customers, suppliers and other businesses. Building virtual communities with
«collaborative marketing» has a considerable economic potential as
well. Consumer virtual communities are focus groups that last 24 hours a day, 7
days a week and offer enormous learning opportunities for tourism organizations
(Gretzel et. al., 2000). This dynamic and valuable information will be
commercialized to Tourism Businesses within and outside Morocco, thus creating
a profit center to finance future DMS system maintenance and enhancement. This
is how the MNTO can create the complete marketing value chain
(Awareness-Information-Booking-CRM), and acquire a competitive advantage for
the Morocco destination in general with an efficient DMS.
Table 8
Destination Marketing System Characteristics
Efficient DMS Characteristics
|
Failing DMS Characteristics
|
Complete and detailed Data Base
|
Incomplete database
|
Information Quality and Reliability
|
Information obsolete and imprecise
|
Information targeted toward independent traveler
|
In competition with the travel trade
|
Operational and efficient booking /call center
|
Difficult online booking
|
Supported and promoted by MNTO
|
No support or promotion
|
Complementary to existents distribution channels
|
In competition with distribution channels
|
Managed by a Marketing oriented organization
|
Managed by a bureaucratic organization
|
Marketing Orientation supported by technology
|
Technology oriented
|
Products tailored to consumers' needs
|
List of products without packaging
|
Provide easy buying process
|
|
Enhance product quality
|
|
Source: With reference to (Tunnard, Haines, 1999)
Figure 8. Outline of a Web Based Destination Marketing System
57
Web Design
The web offers a powerful tool set that combine interactivity
between suppliers, consumers and intermediaries, seamless transactions,
adressability, availability and mass customization (Gretzel, et. al., 2000).
According to Parsons, Zeisser, and Waitman, the success factors for marketing
on the web are: Attract, Engage, Retain, Learn, Relate. The following table
explicit marketing interactivity success factors and different tactical ways to
fulfill them.
Table 9
Interactive Marketing Framework (Parsons, et. al., 1998)
Activity
|
What
|
How
|
Attract
|
Attract consumers to the application
|
Audience creation
Mnemonic Branding Piggy-back advertising
|
Engage
|
General interest and participation
|
Intuitive interface or navigation Interface content
User-generated content
|
Retain
|
Make sure customers come back
|
Dynamic content
Transaction capabilities Online communities
|
Learn
|
Learn about customers' preferences
|
Information capture Continuous preference learning
|
Relate
|
Customize interaction and value delivery
|
Personalized/customized communications and products/ services
Real time interactions
Linkage to core business
|
The DMS's Web site should reflect the characteristics of a
unifying platform, and a one-stop marketplace. It must be user friendly and
enjoyable, must hold good content (information and education), be creative,
interactive and support secure transactions. When looking at a Web site the
users go successive steps: 1) exposure, 2) attention, 3) comprehension and
perception, 4) acceptance, 5) retention (Gretzel et. al., 2000). Therefore the
design, (images, page copy, structure) must take account of these stages to
impact consumer behavior. The content is also extremely important for a DMO
since it is the image and perception of the destination that are portrayed.
Interactivity and vividness are important characteristics of the content too.
Thus community building features are extremely important, since they provide a
discussion forum that are likely to raise awareness, and give the destination a
valuable focus group evaluation on a 24/24 hour basis. The Web is a pull
medium, because consumers actively seek information, therefore simplicity must
provide in content, in order to avoid mental fatigue and «site
jumping». The Web design should reflect the characteristics of the medium,
the consumers and the competitive environment (Gretzel et. al., 2000).
All these factors are very important and should guide Web design.
Thus it is crucial that content is accurate, attractive and easily searchable.
Well-designed Web site ultimately succeed in transforming «lookers»
into «bookers».
Medium
Competition
Content
Design Technology
Features
Design parameters
Organization
Positioning Aligning
Strategy
Application domain
Consumer segment
Figure 10. A Framework for Web Design (Werthner and Klein,
1999)
BUSINESS MODEL AND FINANCIAL FAISABILITY
Constraints
Apart of the reliability and efficiency, funding and
profitability are decisive factors of success in the development and
implementation of a DMS. Commercial attributes and ability to generate profits
must therefore be taken into consideration, as future private investors will
mainly be looking at a successful revenue model that will ensure their return
on investment. Thus, the careful balance between private and public funding,
takes its importance in the representativeness and comprehensiveness'
objectives of the system as well as its commercial viability as describe in the
5Cs framework (Buhalis & Spada, 2000).
For the MNTO, a joint venture business model with private
investors is the prerequisite to fulfill fundamental requirements needed for a
DMS to attain its representativeness as well as to help foster its commercial
viability. The World Travel Organization (WTO) estimates that a major DMS may
cost between $500,000 and $8,000,000 to develop and $250,000 to operate (WTO,
1999). Fortunately tourism organizations do not have to develop these systems.
They can lease systems from leading Information System (IS) companies and
license the database software for few hundred thousand dollars.
MNTO joint venture should opt for a full range of DMS services or
suite of tools as described previously. High cost of developing such system is
to be expected. Therefore the future public/private joint venture should
consider both
options of developing/owning the system or leasing it from a
major leading IS Corporation.
In recent years, however declining revenues of Morocco's
government have led to more intense competition for budget resources with
result that funding must now be supported by rigorous justification. They are
expected to contain well-stated objectives, measurable results, and clear cost
effectiveness figures. Other than government subsidies MNTO's main source of
revenues, come from transient hotel occupancy taxes. The MNTO capital
investment in a DMS needs to show that its implementation will generate
visitation that wouldn't have occurred otherwise. MNTO needs to demonstrate the
marginal impact. There is no doubt however that a successful DMS will further
international tourist arrivals, especially the high spending independent,
sophisticated traveler and foster economic development and growth. But for MNTO
it must also produce yielded tax revenues from visitor incremental spending,
exceeding the promotional investment. But most significantly a DMS will reduce
traditional promotional material expenses and generate substantial economies in
business and work processing. That is a reinforcing factor for MNTO to seek a
private - public joint venture to ensure the DMS commercial viability.
Financial Analysis
The project financial analysis is an attempt to demonstrate the
financial viability of a DMS implementation for a MNTO/ private entity venture.
Assumptions are derived from different figures pertaining to different previous
DMSs. Revenues projections are solely author's game number based on
conservatives assumptions on Internet figures in travel buying in major tourism
outbound markets combined with online Morocco's lodging capacity offer
generated by the projected membership over five years.
Two different options have been considered for the purpose of the
financial feasibility:
1) A build/own option enabled by the ventured company.
2) A leasing option, involving a third party, the lessor of the
DMS. The results reveal a net disadvantage of the leasing option with actual
assumptions. However should revenues fall under the projections figures, it
will produce financial drawbacks, that will favor the safer leasing option. The
following tables provide a detailed analysis of the Net Present Values of
incremental cash flows (CFs), for both options, combined with different
scenarios involving corporate tax rate, projected numbers of reservations,
commissions rates from online reservations transactions and their effects on
Net Advantage Leasing (NAL). Revenues projections are undeniably the most
important aspect of a viable DMS's financial analysis. Thus, number of
reservations and average online transactions are the most
deterministic financial factors for it commercial success.
Table 10
Basic
assumptions inputs
OPTION BUILD
|
OPTION LEASING
|
|
Cost of Capital
|
8%
|
Cost of Capital
|
8%
|
Marginal Corporate
|
|
Marginal Corporate tax
|
|
tax rate
|
40%
|
rate
|
40%
|
Total Cost of DMS
|
|
|
|
Capital Investment
|
($8,000,000)
|
|
|
Loan term
|
5
|
|
|
Interest rate on loan
|
8%
|
|
|
Loan payment
|
($2,003,652)
|
Lease payment
|
($850,000)
|
Maintenance expense FC
|
($1 ,000,000)
|
Maintenance expense
|
$0
|
Call Center VC
|
($400,000)
|
Call Center
|
$0
|
Total Operating expenses
|
($1 ,400,000)
|
|
|
After tax rate on loan
|
5%
|
|
|
Average amount
|
|
|
|
RESA
|
$350
|
Average amount RESA
|
$350
|
% Commission
|
|
|
|
Charges
|
15%
|
% Commission Charges
|
7%
|
Table 11
Projected Revenues
Option
1
Build Own
|
Y1
|
Y2
|
Y3
|
Y4
|
Y5
|
|
|
|
|
|
Projected Res Revenues
|
|
|
|
|
|
RESA #
|
35,000
|
50,000
|
100,000
|
250,000
|
500,000
|
Tot Rev
|
$1 2,250,000
|
$1 7,500,000
|
$35,000,000
|
$87,500,000
|
$1 75,000,000
|
Tot Commission Rev
|
$1 ,837,500
|
$2,625,000
|
$5,250,000
|
$13,1 25,000
|
$26,250,000
|
Projected Membership Revenues
|
|
|
|
|
|
Membership
|
1500
|
2000
|
4000
|
7000
|
10000
|
Fees
|
$500
|
$500
|
$500
|
$500
|
$700
|
Total Rev
|
$750,000
|
$1 ,000,000
|
$2,000,000
|
$3,500,000
|
$7,000,000
|
Total Projected
|
|
|
|
|
|
Revenues
|
$2,587,500
|
$3,625,000
|
$7,250,000
|
$1 6,625,000
|
$33,250,000
|
Option
2
Lease
|
|
Y1
|
|
Y2
|
|
|
Y3
|
|
Y4
|
|
|
Y5
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Total Revenues
|
Projected
|
|
$857,500
|
$1
|
,225,000
|
$2,450,000
|
$6,1
|
25,000 $1
|
2,250,000
|
Table 12
Loan Amortization
Loan Amortization schedule
Periods Balance Payment Interest Principal Balance
1
|
$8,000,000 ($2,219,278)
|
$960,000
|
($1,259,278)
|
$6,740,722
|
2
|
$6,740,722 ($2,219,278)
|
$808,887
|
($1 ,41 0,391)
|
$5,330,331
|
3
|
$5,330,331 ($2,219,278)
|
$639,640
|
($1,579,638)
|
$3,750,693
|
4
|
$3,750,693 ($2,219,278)
|
$450,083
|
($1,769,195)
|
$1,981,498
|
5
|
$1,981,498 ($2,219,278)
|
$237,780
|
($1,981,498)
|
$0
|
Table 13
Financial Outputs
DEVELOP/OWN OPTION
|
Y0 Y1
|
Y2
|
Y3
|
Y4
|
Y5
|
DMS Cost
|
($8,000,000)
|
|
|
|
|
Borrowing CFs
|
($2,219,278)
|
($2,219,278)
|
($2,21 9,278)
|
($2,21 9,278)
|
($2,219,278)
|
Operating Costs (F+V)
|
($1,400,000)
|
($1,400,000)
|
($1,400,000)
|
($1,400,000)
|
($1,400,000)
|
Revenue CFs
|
$2,587,500
|
$3,625,000
|
$7,250,000
|
$1 6,625,000
|
$33,250,000
|
Interest tax shield
|
$384,000
|
$323,555
|
$255,856
|
$180,033
|
$95,112
|
EBT
|
($647,778)
|
$329,277
|
$3,886,578
|
$13,185,755
|
$29,725,834
|
Tax = 40%
|
$0
|
$131,711
|
$1 ,554,631
|
$5,274,302
|
$1 1,890,334
|
Net CF's
|
($647,778)
|
$197,566
|
$2,331 ,947
|
$7,91 1,453
|
$1 7,835,500
|
NPV Owning CFs
|
$1 0,531,905.14
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
LEASE OPTION
|
|
|
|
|
|
Leasing CF's
|
($850,000.00)
|
($850,000.00)
|
($850,000.00)
|
($850,000.00)
|
($850,000.00)
|
Pmt tax Savings
|
$340,000.00
|
$340,000.00
|
$340,000.00
|
$340,000.00
|
$340,000.00
|
Revenues
|
$857,500.00
|
$1,225,000.00
|
$2,450,000.00
|
$6,125,000.00
|
$12,250,000.00
|
EBT
|
$347,500.00
|
$715,000.00
|
$1,940,000.00
|
$5,615,000.00
|
$11,740,000.00
|
Tax = 40%
|
($139,000.00)
|
($286,000.00)
|
($776,000.00)
|
($2,246,000.00)
|
($4,696,000.00)
|
Net CF's
|
$208,500.00
|
$429,000.00
|
$1,164,000.00
|
$3,369,000.00
|
$7,044,000.00
|
NPV Leasing CFs
|
$8,755,218.25
|
|
|
|
|
NAL Net Advantage of Leasing ($1 ,776,686.88)
Table 14
Financial Scenarios Summary
Scenario Summary
Current Values: Scenario 1 Scenario 2 Scenario 3 scenario 4
($1,776,686.88) $1,208,675.02 $4,71 8,162.73 $2,91 1,544.55
$3,684,493.58
250,000 250,000 70,000 70,000 250,000
500,000 500,000 200,000 200,000 500,000
100,000 100,000 40,000 40,000 100,000
35,000 35,000 15,000 15,000 35,000
50,000 50,000 25,000 25,000 50,000
$350 $250 $350 $350 $350
40% 40% 40% 0% 0%
15% 15% 15% 15% 10%
Changing Cells:
Av Res ResaY1 ResaY2 ResaY3 ResaY4 ResaY5
Tax
Comm.
Result Cells:
NAL
Notes: Current values column represents values of changing
cells at time scenario summary report was created. Changing cells for each
scenario are highlighted in gray.
MNTO's ORGANIZATIONAL CHALLENGE
Operational Environment
The requirements of tourism based economic prosperity, combined
with new market trends, weak negotiating power of Morocco's small and
fragmented tourism industry, and the absence of ITs based marketing tools are
creating a very challenging environment for MNTO's organization to face, in a
country where the tourism industry is heavily depending on the European market
demand. For MNTO, the obvious strategic imperative of a DMS, do not implicate
technical and financial issues only, in the use of Web based technology, but
far more importantly it represents a management issue. In facts DMS should
contribute real benefits to the reconfiguration of MNTO as a national tourism
office. The web not only change organization's business processing but enhance
knowledge capital and social capital as well, through information sharing and
partnership with all stakeholders. It is therefore imperative that MNTO
prepares to answer the strategic challenge with an organization that possesses
strong capabilities and knowledge key resource to confront this very
competitive environment.
Morocco Tourism Industry
Environment
|
Socio-economic issues
Fragmentation SMTEs Position of Tour operators Lack of
cooperation
|
Requirements
Economic prosperity Service and product renovation
New work organization
|
Technical issues
No structure of information No integrated database
No customer profiles
Insufficient Marketing
Little use of IT tools
|
Market Trends
Short-term breaks Short-term decision Ongoing concentration
Figure 11. MNTO's Operational Strategic Environment
Management objectives: Generating the «Paradigm
Shift»
The duties of NTOs is to provide leadership by developing a
vision, identifying additional tourism sources, motivating communities, and
coaching partners. All of these tasks require skills, supporting knowledge and
competent leadership. MNTO's Organization and culture are not aligned with DMS
strategy implementation. Change in management practices and mindset must shift
dramatically. For NTOs, DMS generate this paradigm-shift (Frangialli, 1998),
which transforms management practices and improve information flow, work
organization, and business processes, forcing them to acquire
the needed skills and to boost their capacity for learning and adaptability.
Information technology enables NTO's to handle the growth of information, by
compressing time, allowing NTO's to respond faster to their respective markets
and partners than ever before. Quality service, efficiency, convenience are
radically enhanced, while types of services are expanded. But the real benefit
is the reconfiguration of the organization. This means that MNTO need to
embrace the trend of network organizations. It needs to shift its actual work
processes using the Web to enhance knowledge capital but also to enhance social
and human capital. Today, in order to build their competitive advantage,
organizations are gearing towards knowledge acquisition and learning, instead
of controlling (Gretzel, et. al., 2000).
The implementation of a DMS strategy for the MNTO to promote
and sell the destination in a new way, imply transforming an organization that
will constitute by itself a sustainable competitive advantage for Morocco's
tourism industry. However success comes from successfully implementing a
strategy, not just from having one. This implementation capability derives in
large measure from the organization's people, how they are treated, their
skills and competencies, and their efforts on behalf the organization (Jeffrey
Pfeiffer, 1998).
The biggest challenge facing the MNTO is therefore changing
peoples' culture and mind, in order to successfully understand and support the
core strategy necessary to enable the implementation of marketing oriented
and
technology based «Destination Management System». It is
therefore vital to address the cultural and mentality changes that are needed
in this organization.
In order to change its way for doing business, the MNTO should
define a new vision, mission, thus, developing and enhancing its core
competencies. It is clearly quite a change, but it is undoubtedly the
prerequisite to the aspiration of becoming a performing Destination Marketing
Organization.
SWOT Analysis
Strengths:
Strong Brand name: Morocco has been recognized since the
sixties as a Tourism Destination with strong potential. The MNTO is an 82 years
old institution and is present in 15 Markets around the world.
Weakness:
> Total discontinuity between the Organization and the present
> No clear strategic direction.
> Archaic and bureaucratic management system.
> Weak financial resources.
> Lack of technical resources.
> Lack of management and marketing skills to perform core
competency. > Overstaffed and limited skilled human resources.
Opportunities
> Government/Private sector led action plan to develop the
Tourism sector with 10 millions tourist objective in 2010
> New leadership with private sector background and committed
government support
Treats:
> Entry of new Mediterranean competitors.
> Strong resistance among management staff in the
organization
Vision and Mission
In order to change its way of doing business, the MNTO should
define a new vision and mission, in order to develop and enhance its core
competencies. The following definitions should strongly pertain to the Moroccan
National Tourist Office:
Vision
The vision of an industry that is internationally competitive,
sustainable and valued for the economic, social, and environmental benefits it
brings to Morocco. Mission Statement
Generating jobs and wealth through effective leadership in the
promotion and development of tourism.
Core competency
> Market Morocco as a destination
> Provide advice and market intelligence to tourism industry
stakeholders. > Identify opportunities to improve Morocco's tourism
competitiveness. > Support the local and regional marketing associations
network.
> Operate quality assurance schemes for accommodation and
visitor
attractions.
> Advise the government tourism department authority on
tourism strategic development and policy issues.
Changing MNTO's Organization
As explained previously, in order to provide leadership by
developing a vision, motivating the industry community and coaching partners,
the MNTO need not only different types of skills but also supporting knowledge
and effective leadership.
Adaptation to technological change cannot be realized without
changes in the organizational structure and culture. Thus it is a necessity for
the leadership, first to drag the MNTO out from the government bureaucracy and
autocracy. It must become an independent (and accountable) agency. That will
ensure its organizational structural change.
Transforming people mindset and culture inherited from a
bureaucratic and autocratic environment, is a very difficult task. Becoming
knowledge-based organization means that people should embrace the changes and
be willing to learn and acquire new skills and competencies. Technology based
promotion cannot be adopted in one night. It must gradually diffuse. The
question of recruiting, hence takes most of its importance. An organization
that wants to achieve skill in doing an activity and yet is unwilling to
recruit, select, compensate, evaluate, or measure will achieve its goal only
through some form of divine intervention (Jeffrey Pfeiffer, 1998). MNTO's
management practices must therefore be aligned with a DMS's business and
organization strategy. Training courses for middle management and lower
management should address priorities such as shared strategy understanding,
performance management, learning skills and ability, English language
proficiency, specific skills related to knowledge management, technology and
computer skills. Immersion training programs through innumerable bilateral
agreements with numerous European countries, especially those of Austria and
Ireland, that are the most advanced in term of technology based marketing,
should be taken advantages of. This will help to take a pro-active change
approach to help shift people mindset. Financial and human resources are
undoubtedly prerequisites to such actions, otherwise change will not happen.
Change efforts have to comprise all organizational levels and need to
take the concern of all stakeholders. The resistance that comes
from employees independently of their level in the organization is not the
emanation of refuting
change but from the fear from being changed (Gretzel, et., al.,
2000). Because successful change needs commitment not compliance, involving
people in the change process habitually reduce resistance. MNTO's leadership
must realize that this can be achieved only by creating an organizational
culture that embrace change and foster learning. It will require the
redesigning of organizational structure so that change can be actively sought.
Building a capacity for ongoing change is crucial for MNTO's business
environment and new blood need to be injected, having in mind that without
proper management, sufficient knowledge, good communications, technology
implementation will not see daylight.
Chapter 8
CONCLUSION
Tourism is a worldwide phenomenon and it is generally believed
that the global tourism industry might become the single largest industry in
terms of revenues. At the same time tourism is confronted with changes in
traditional distribution, marketing and working systems as well as the behavior
and requirements of the tourist. There are growing numbers of destinations and
products for consumer to choose from. Consumers need information more quickly
and they need to be able to book easily.
Tourism environment is in the process of a profound
reconfiguration, revolutionizing the context in which business is conducted.
The most significant factor contributing to this reconfiguration is the
technological developments that led to the emergence of innovative Web-based
technologies. The World Wide Web is profoundly changing the production,
distribution and consumption of tourism products, between firms and consumers,
between firms and among consumers as well. The net impact of the information
technologies is to enable a radical reconfiguration of the tourism industry
itself. Information technology provides the common platform to reach the market
more effectively, by
facilitating organizational responsiveness and learning as well
as customer relationship management. DMSs are exactly this common platform that
offer solutions to destinations. Destinations could take advantage of this
technological development to help them battle in the highly competitive tourism
industry. DMSs offer a needed solution to address the fragmentation and
information intensity that characterize the tourism industry. Nevertheless DMOs
in charge of promoting the destinations still have major problem in closing the
loop.
The objective of this executive project was indeed to develop a
cooperation model, namely a DMS for Morocco tourism destination. The proposed
DMS platform answers the need for developing knowledge-based tourism
information and booking system that is commercially viable and constitutes the
basis to build an effective advantage for Morocco's tourism destination in
today's highly competitive environment. The DMS cooperativecompetitive model
will permit the state owned MNTO to enforce its marketing efforts, and be able
to move in a quickly changing industry, finding the balance between cooperation
and competition among Morocco's tourism industry suppliers, by permanently
adopting and using technological tools.
The proposed framework is feasible because it emphasizes the
importance of partnership between the public and private sector and creates
opportunities to getting closer to the world's tourist. Most importantly it
will trigger the paradigm shift that will modernize the state owned MNTO, which
is crucial for the future of the organization. However, MNTO's organization has
to
understand that successful online marketing strategy is not just
about technology. It is about deconstructing traditional business models and
reinventing the organization. The integration of innovating technologies will
allow the MNTO to break away from obsolete and ineffective approaches to
differentiate Morocco tourism destination in a highly competitive, global, and
networked tourism industry and economy. What really matters is change.
To activate this «creative destruction», the
following perquisites may be required for the project to succeed. Communication
and organizational barriers have to be overcome in order for MNTO to create a
partnership. Regardless of how the project of a DMS joint venture stacks up
financially, key points of
project development feasibility have to be addressed by finding a
local champion to be the voice of the DMS project at all levels of the media,
public and private sectors. MNTO's leadership must act as a broker and lobbyist
to bridge the gap between the private and public sector cultures. Fortunately
the leadership is able to communicate easily with both sectors and have been
involved in negotiation, communication and politics at local and state level.
Furthermore the state owned organization has the power to build consensus
between all tourism industry's stakeholders and ensure that mutual
comprehension will prevail between public and private sectors.
REFERENCES
Bear Stearns (2000). Internet travel. Bear, Stearns
& Co. inc.
http://www.bearstearns.com
Buhalis, D. (1996). Information technology as a strategic tool
for tourism and hospitality management in the new millennium. Tourism
Review Magazine, No. 2, pp. 34-36.
Buhalis, D. (1997). Information technologies as a strategic tool
for economic, cultural and environmental benefits enhancement of tourism at
destination region. Progress in Tourism and Hospitality Research, Vol.
3 No.1, pp.71 -93.
Buhalis, D. (2000). Marketing the competitive destination of the
future. Tourism Management, Vol. 21, No.1.
Buhalis, D., Spada, A. (2000). Destination management systems:
Criteria for success- an exploratory research. Information Technology
&Tourism, Vol. 3,
pp.41 -58.
Day, G.S. (1998). Organizing for Interactivity, Journal of
Interactive Marketing, Vol. 12, No. 1, pp.47- 53.
EMarketer (1999). The e-travel report. EMarketer, Inc.
http://www.emarketer.com
Fingar, P., Kumar, H., Sharma, T. (2000). Enterprise
E-Commerce, pp33. Meghan-Kiffer Press.
Forrester Research (2000). Travel data overview report, March
2000.
Jeanniot, P. (2000). IATA International Air Transport
Association. State of the Industry. Address to 56th IATA AGM,
Sydney 2000.
http://www.iata.org/pr/speech3.
htm
Liu, Z. (2000). Internet Tourism Marketing: Potential and
Constraints. Fourth international conference «Tourism in southeast
Asia & Indochina: Development, Marketing and Sustainability», pp. 8.
http://hotel-online.com
Nua (2001). Internet Survey. Nua Ltd.
http://www.nua.ie/surveys/how
manyonline/index.html.
Pfeiffer, J. (1998). The human equation. Harvard
Business School Press
Forrester Research, Inc.
http://www.forrester.com
Frangialli, F. WTO (1998). A new era in Information
Technology for Tourism: Its implications for Tourism Policies. OECD
Conference, Seoul, pp.3-4.
Gretzel, U., Yuan, Y., Fesenmaier, D. (2000). Workshop on
advertising strategy and information technology in tourism. National
Laboratory for Tourism and eCommerce, UIUC.
http://www.tourism.uiuc.edu/adtec/
whitepaper.pdf
IFITT, (1998). IFITT White Paper, Result of IFITT workshop on
open issues and challenges in IT and Tourism. Edited by H Werthner and R.
Carter, pp.1-3.
ITTA International Technology Trade Associates. US Internet
Council (2000). State of the Internet, pp 1-18. ITTA inc.
PhoCusWright, (2001). News release. PhoCusWright, Inc.
http://www.phocuswright.com/press
Rita, P. (2000) Internet Marketing in the global tourism mark
etplace, pp. 1-5. Internet society (Inet) 2000 proceedings, Japan.
http://www.isoc.org/inet2000/cdpro
ceedings/index.htm
Sheldon, P. (1997). Tourism information technology.
Oxford: CAB International.
TIAA Travel Industry Association of America (2000). Annual
report. TIAA, Inc.
http://www.tia.org/Pubs/2000annua
lreport.pdf
Tunnard, R.C., Haines, P. (1999) Destination Marketing Systems-
a
new role for tourist board marketing in the information age.
Journal of Vacation Marketing, Vol. 1, No.4.
UNCTAD United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (2000).
Electronic commerce and tourism: New Perspectives and Challenges for
Developing countries. (TD/B/COM.3EM.9/2) pp.9-14
Werthner, H., Klein, S. (1999). ICT and the changing Landscape
of Global Tourism Distribution. Electronic Markets, Vol. 9, No. 4, pp.
256-262.
WTO (2000) Tourism highlights 1999. Second Edition,
August 2000.
http://www.world-tourism.org
WTO (2001b). Newsroom, News Release. Millennium Tourism Boom
in 2000.
http://www.worldtourism.org
WTO World Tourism Organization (2001a). Tourism Statistics
Database.
http://
www.world-tourism.org
WTTC World Travel and Tourism Council (2000). Travel and
Tourism's economic impact, March 1999.
http://www.wttc.org
Copyright (c) Inan Elmerini 2001
|
|