Abstract
To help people to take well-founded decisions, it is necessary
to have a free press. Not only the media must be free, but they must be serious
and trustworthy. They must be free to express different viewpoints.
Whatever the place, journalists have established principles
and criteria enabling them to provide credible information. Unfortunately,
there still exist journalists who are forced to work under duress imposed by
governments or by powerful interests that interfere with professionalism.
Generally, media that ensure the campaign coverage, whether
private or state should be impartial in their presentation of candidates,
political parties and campaign themes and the validity of elections and the
consequences in case of bad choice of leaders at all levels.
The main objective of this study was to analyze the work of a
public media during elections. The principles of a good mediator it must play
to give access to all has credible information and well treated, took no part
and independently as recommended by the journalist profession.
We have also listed some principles of art can help all
journalists in the exercise of their work.
None scientific research, no thesis has never been
scientifically full, that is why we like to clarify that this study known the
shortcomings which others researchers will continued in the same direction to
complete what we have not said. We have done our best to be clear and precise
finally allow those who will read to us understand and understand how good
election coverage by the media may be held.
Acknowledgements
Our thanks to Creator God who gives us his breath of life to
reach the stage of life are.
We extend our thanks to all the most distinguished teachings
of the School of Journalism and communication of Hebe University and
particularly to Professor Han Xin Li and Dr.
Deng for their input and support for the development of this thesis,
people good and full of paternal emotion to help African youth in what they do.
A good testimony about shall be made of generation to generation for the two
people mentioned and that of the whole school filled Journalism of people
concerned about the future of youth.
Thanks to all my family that despite the social difficulties
she knows keeps us encouraged continued this laborious way of scientific
research. I remain convinced that this is the best way to be happy. All parents
who have always been with us to various boards, cousins, snowfields, nieces,
everyone has played an important and special role in our life, thank you very
much.
A man of efficiency and noble commitments in the service of his
children Anthony WEMBANGOMO Lokombe to whom we once again say
thank you very much for fatherly love always and God bless you more. To my
lovely mother Henriette MOMBE KAWOYA, a good mother who is my
pride, I love you very much mom.
To friends and acquaintances, those ones who believed in the
virtue of brotherhood and friendship, we say thank you and their i can assure
all of our continued friendship expensive in cohesion. (Alpha Cissé,
Kaelo Sabrona, Mathieu Kanu, Victor Aruwimi, Maria Effiyana, Terry Jocky and
Annie). We say thanks to all of our classmates, we established a good
family, that unity between brothers and sisters will always remain even
remotely or we will live. Thanks to all members of the national televisions
that have agreed to help us and collaborated to enable us to properly conduct
this study.
To people who have contributed in one way or another in the
preparation of this thesis, we their say a big thank you.
Chapter One
1.1 Introduction
The 2011 elections were constituted for the Congolese
population which was branded as a historic moment after 46 years of accession
of our country to international and national sovereignty. This is the second
time that the DRC is organizing pluralistic elections after the 2006 elections.
Attracted by the value and importance of the choice of
leaders through free elections, democratic and transparent processes , many
researchers in political sociology, political science, law, political
communication, journalism and linguists set their scientific look at this
subject. The interest that has led them to devote time to conduct studies on
the 2011 elections was more general than to examine how the elections were
conducted, how politicians fought to run for positions, how they communicated
with their respective constituencies, what role the media played during this
specific time or frequency.1(*)
However, it should be noted that all of these studies have
addressed each aspect related to his field of research.
1.2 Background
Many authors and media scholars emphasized that the media play
different roles in society. For instance Derville reiterated
that the media do not always fulfill the same functions as required under the
circumstances in which they are used. It turns out that each function of the
media corresponds a social need.
Due to the evolution of communication throughout the world,
news disseminated by journalists acquires an importance aspect to the public
which they are intended to serve. Even if the press is still not able to
account for all the events that occur around the world, it nevertheless has a
paramount consideration in community life which Mermet calls
«time of "the media age ". For him, "most attitudes of men and behaviors
are influenced, modified or even caused by the accumulation of information of
all kinds."
From this angle, Roland Cayrol certifies that
despite the fact that we have multiple sources of information, it is the media
that are undoubtedly the main channel in the world by which we managed most
of the new policies.
Democracy is still based on the possibility to freely express
diverse views and the vote of informed citizens. The media and journalists
therefore play a key role in the electoral process by providing the circulation
of information and opinions and confrontation. They allow a better
understanding of candidates, parties and programs.
They contribute to the effective participation of citizens in
the democratic debate, particularly by placing at the heart of the campaign of
general interest. Guarantors of democracy, journalists also have a critical
role in legitimizing and acceptance of election results, especially in
countries of democratic transition or crisis as in the case of the Democratic
Republic of Congo. 2(*)
For his part Francis Balle says, elections
can be a factor of affirmation and consolidation of the democratic process, as
they can turn into a threat against the peace and stability of States. The path
taken by each country depends especially on the degree of involvement of
stakeholders, the media, political authorities, institutions, political
parties, public, civil society in the electoral process.
A free and fair election is not just the fact to file a ballot
in adequate conditions, but also to have access to sufficient information about
political parties, candidates and the electoral process to allow voters to make
informed and responsible choices.
An election campaign is a period particularly sensitive to
political life, in which journalists are subject to intimidation and
manipulation, to deviate their attention. There are many examples of electoral
contexts in which journalists have been subjected to pressure and harassment.
In other cases, they are engines of partisan communication and propaganda.
1.3 Problem statement
The pre-election period, election and post-election are
crucial times of public information. During these periods and especially to the
elections, it is very important for the voters that the information concerning
the conduct of the campaign and are media reports are complete and impartial.
To help people to take complete decisions, it is necessary to
have a free press. Not only the media must be free, but they must be serious
and trustworthy. They must be free to express different points of view.
Regardless of the location, journalists have established principles and
criteria that allowed them to provide credible information. Unfortunately,
there are still journalists who are forced to work under constraint imposed by
governments or powerful interests that interfere with professionalism. 3(*)
This is how the campaign documents advertising, radio,
television and print media, the internet, debates and interviews that give
candidates the opportunity to present their programs to the public, voters must
be covered by journalists filling a recommended profile profession. Media
reporting take the form of information, including the importance of electoral
participation by explaining with honesty and responsibility to the public, how,
where and when to place the vote.
In general, covering political campaign, whether state or
private should be impartial in their presentation and profiling of candidates,
political parties , campaign themes , merits of elections and the consequences
in the case of bad choice of leaders at all levels.
To this end, the work of the media, specifically in
audiovisual, multitude of candidates acquires for most cases character check
which is more difficult especially in elections or voting that involves a
struggle for interests' divergence between the need of power and expectations
of the population. A situation that most academicians defined as a clash of
democratic values, actions and procedures that eliminate the opponent. In this
case the only mediator is the journalist.
However, during elections media coverage other fact finding
reports could provide clarification on the voting procedures, contact with
sources of electoral information and the candidates.
As proven by professionalism in the harvesting and processing
of information and as required by professional ethics, responsibility on the
part of the journalist and the media in general has not been the case of the
work of the DRC National television during 2011 elections.
It is admittedly true that the search for electoral
information by the knights of the pen, presupposes respect for the right to
freedom of expression and the principle of the free movement of opinion and
ideas.
What made the journalists of the DRC National Television
implicitly becoming secondary players, occupying, and unfortunately, complicit
in position of good or bad conduct of the 2011 elections which will expand our
research on the quality of staff employed by the Kinshasa Congolese National TV
station during the period covered in this research.. 4(*)
Faced with his accomplice position to the success or failure
of electoral activities and electoral wherefores, media interference had
sometimes led some journalists of national television to affect the integrity
of the profession, and even hamper the smooth functioning of the media for the
sole purpose of preventing the dissemination of certain information that may
reveal the electoral truths and especially in the case of fraud by the ruling
power in place.
These professional requirements have pushed us to ask
ourselves the following principal question:
ü How Kinshasa Congolese National TV station journalists
maintained professional media coverage of the 2011 elections?
This principal question led us to the supplementary question
below:
ü How to cope with electoral competition of the Congolese
National Television in the area of mobilizing human and material resources in
order to ensure good media coverage and maintained neutrality? These
questions constitute the major concerns that we will try to answer in this
study.5(*)
1.4 Hypothesis
The fundamental question we asked ourselves allows us to
assume that in a situation where election period exist, the media have a
tendency to view and ensue effective coverage of political campaign operations
that occur to instruct the best in scientifically and technically informed
electoral decisions and issues surrounded by ethical journalism.
In this hypothesis in the following we issued main hypothesis:
v For coverage of the 2011 elections, the National Congolese
television Kinshasa station has not mobilized suitable and adequate logistics
likely to facilitate the pursuit of excellence reporting that research through
the dissemination of quality information, that is to say, truthfulness,
objectivity and timeliness remained the key principle of modern das journalism.
This will enable TV journalists to primarily serve all Congolese citizens
regardless of their political color, origin and religion.
1.5 Justification
In fact, many scholars and researchers will ask the question:
"Why talk about the media coverage during the 2011 elections»? Are there
researchers who have worked on this reality in the Congo? The answer is simple
and motivated by two poles:
v In Standpoint theoretical or scientific, this study will
allow us to accumulate new knowledge in matters of practicing of the
journalism profession during elections and identify requirements to be taken
into account in media coverage of not only the events of the election coverage,
but also other possible events like disaster and war.
On this subject, theories and information that will be
developed in this work will be as our contribution to the world of science.
This information whose complexity recommends a high sense of professionalism
and knowledge that would make the related disciplines of journalism use it to
understand the tricks of the journalism profession;
v On the personal level, this work will equip me more on the
elements that can enrich my knowledge as a journalist and colleague journalists
particularly on the roles and principles of TV journalism during the
pre-election period, election, and post-election in the DRC. 6(*)
1.6 Aims and objectives
In conducting this study, I am pursuing a fundamental objective,
namely to assist any journalist to understand the meaning of "social
responsibility" in his/her profession. I want to make available to media
professionals a practical tool that can help well-conducted election coverage
regardless of the continent or country where it is located.
Our desire in this rate is largely due to the fact that conflict
always exists in elections period but through the work of journalists these
conflict can significantly decrease in Africa and particularly in the DRC after
the publication of this research. That journalists becoming more
professional in their duties to inform the citizens by upholding the principle
of neutrality.
1.7 Scope and Limitation
The Democratic Republic of Congo has 10 national television
stations, and many radio stations , added therefore is the great city of
Kinshasa TV station which is the capital relayed by the provincial stations for
major events. National TV Headquarter is base in Kinshasa with more than 1,200
officials and reporters in five departments. To conduct this research, I will
narrow the field of study with the great national television station in
Kinshasa. This research only covers the 2011 elections which take into
consideration the pre-election period, the election period and the
post-election period from January 2011 to the November in the same year.
1.8 Significance of the Study
The study will critically analyse the 2011 DRC national
elections and the election converge of the Congolese national TV Station in
Kinshasa. The study will also unearth the many challenges and succeeses made by
the National TV journalists or reporters. The study will also make some
sgnificant fact on election reporting code of conduct in DRC and maintaining
impartiality in all National TV coverage of the élections
1.9. Research Methodology
To the realization of this study, we use the quantitative
method. The latter allowed us to identify airtime on national television that
granted the 11 candidates for the presidency of the republic in 2011 elections
As for the data collection tools, we used the technical literature and the
internet and the data provided to us from our sources in Kinshasa..7(*)
This is for the documentary technique of harvesting information:
definitions, theories and other information relating to the object of the
study, as learned from books, dictionaries, previous scientific work of the
Internet, etc.
We have also included some political broadcasts of animated
propaganda on national television; the goal was to see whether or not she gave
interest to the smooth running of the electoral operations in his work.
1.10 Organization of the study
This work constitutes of five chapters.
This work is divided into five chapters, the first talk of
the introduction, the second chapter focuses on the literature Review, the
third chapter deals with the role of the media during the election period, the
fourth is spent contenet Analysis of Congolese National TV Coverage, and the
fifth was based on chapter Summary, Conclusion and Recommendation.
Chapter Two: LITERATURE REVIEW
2.1 MEDIA AND ELECTIONS
The behavior of the media during an election campaign is
actually very important. Independence editorial, integrity and professionalism
are the cornerstones of a healthy media coverage of the elections. The absence
of autonomy or journalistic responsibility may, where it is combined with a too
homogenous media landscape, distort the results of the elections.
Yasha Lange in the vademecum on media and elections Council of
Europe F-67075 Strasbourg Cedex publishing explains why it is necessary that
there is a diversity of media accessible to the various interest groups and
supported by various structures. However, this also creates a spirit of
competition and could worry, in particular, the proliferation of channels of
television and the rise of competition in the broadcasting market. The battle
for appropriating the public has a negative effect on the coverage of
elections?
Legislation concerning the coverage of the elections by the
media is not necessarily restricted to a debate without issue between those who
preach for a freedom of speech without brake and those seeking to promote
fairness. Pluralism, the editorial independence and journalistic
professionalism are indispensable prerequisites recognized by all.8(*)
At the same time, there is a broad consensus on the limits of
the freedom of the press. This is not only to General limitations such as the
transgression of civil and criminal legislation in the racist publications,
defamation, etc., but also other limitations on coverage of the elections; for
example, reports out of the polling stations, before the opening of the polls,
would be considered as undesirable by most of the prophets of the first
amendment.
The legislation can certainly guarantee it only fair
treatment. The experience of many countries and of many media shows the value
of self-regulation, internal guidelines and statutes editorials (separating the
responsibilities of management and editorial activity).
In several countries, the (public) broadcast media have
certain (statutory) obligations. Even if it has no justi?cation philosophical
to treat electronic media in a manner different from the written press, the
examples show that this dual approach is accepted and meeting a broad
consensus.
2.1.1 THE PRINT
An overview of the European press to note a remarkable
diversity. Some countries have a national press vigorous (United Kingdom,
Netherlands). In other countries, the national securities market is relatively
low while the regional press is particularly strong (France, Germany).
Some countries have not tabloids rowdy national dailies
(Netherlands, France, Italy), while in others this press has the strongest
prints (Sweden, United Kingdom, Germany). The number of newspapers sold per
1,000 inhabitants also differs significantly: from 472 in Sweden and 320 in the
United Kingdom and Germany to 156 in France and 113 in Italy. Some countries
have a long tradition of self-regulation systems (Sweden), while in others;
this type of organization is relatively new or missing.
The press of Western Europe markets has been relatively stable
over the past ten years. The changes were obviously huge in the countries of
Central and Eastern Europe. In this region, the traditional strong circulation
dailies have disappeared or changed their editorial line and hundreds of new
newspapers have been created.
Should keep in mind these differences to explore options in
the regulatory field. Countries have often chosen to enact legislation
specifically because it was suited to the national media.
2.1.2 LEGAL FRAMEWORK
The regulation concerning the coverage of the elections by the
written press is not speci?c. The general freedoms and restrictions on these
freedoms apply. Where they exist, the rules concerning the elections concern
only newspapers owned by the State.
"Fundamental freedoms" are valid for the press. Freedom of
speech is enshrined in national constitutions and conventions International
(Universal Declaration of human rights, international pact of the United
Nations relating to civil and political rights, European Convention on human
rights or ECHR). Freedom of the press is generally enshrined in national
legislation on the press.
Finally, the freedom of information allows the dissemination
of information but also implies that citizens have the right to be informed.
Some countries have a law on the information and access to information.
These rights are not unlimited. All countries have legislation
to protect the rights of the individual and prohibit abuse of freedom of
speech. These restrictions are usually on defamation, intrusion into private
life, racial discrimination, national security, etc.
The relevant provisions can be found in the law on the press,
in special laws on defamation and respect for private life or be provided by
other laws, for example the penal code or the civil code. But international
conventions also bring restrictions to freedom of speech. For example the ECHR
stipulates that the freedom of expression must be guaranteed in any level in a
democracy.
Seymour-Ure in The British press and broadcasting since 1945,
Oxford, Blackwell and his colleague Manasian, d. in The 1997 British election
campaign and the media indicate that the decline of the party press is neither
ideological nor the result of a government edict, but imposed by the market.
A newspaper can no longer produce pure for a party propaganda
if he wants to have a significant circulation as readers seem to prefer media
that clearly take their distance from political parties. In the current
competitive market of print media, it is essential to address a wide audience
reflecting across the political spectrum and not to alienate the moderate
electorate.
Another reason is also that affiliation to a political party
is not a real problem. The press is generally quite multifaceted and voters
have the opportunity to have another point of view by simply buying another
newspaper. Therefore, there is no great need that newspapers fully conform to
the balance. It is only when no other voice is heard or that it has that
limited distribution outside the capital that some print media policy trend can
be seen as a problem.
2.1.3 REGULATION OF THE PRESS
The same authors continue by saying that countries have become
aware of the forces market and the plurality and independence of the press and
have however not adopted regulatory speci?c for the coverage of elections by
newspapers.
There is an exception. State-owned newspapers were asked to
observe the principle of equality in their way to account for the campaign.
When funding comes from public funds, the corresponding obligation to represent
the views of the entire public is justi?able.
This obligation should, however, not be made too strictly,
because it could have the counterproductive effect of the newspapers concerned
stop purely and simply interested in the subject. In fact, the stories and
analyses of campaign may not always be reported purely impartially. Therefore,
this obligation must stress the need for an overall fair and balanced approach
rather than requiring each article to be "objective".
However, this is not so simple. In Western Europe, the logs of
which the State owns have disappeared or have been marginalized. In Central and
Eastern Europe and the former Soviet Union, on the other hand, some still have
a major release (not because they are relatively cheap). But far from complete
one any "public service" and be "fair and balanced", they often do the
opposite. State-owned newspapers are door-word of the Government.
There are many examples of biased Government newspapers. In
Russia, for example, State-owned newspapers Rossiiskaya Gazeta and Rossiiskie
vesti (respectively organs of the Government and the Presidency Russian)
strongly supported President Boris Eltsine during the 1996 campaign. This has
not only damaged the credibility two newspapers, but this has also raised
questions about the effectiveness of the regulations, because they were subject
to requirements promulgated by the Central Election Commission "to abstain from
any preferential treatment.
Even if they were more balanced, these logs should still
overcome the scepticism of the public regarding their editorial
independence.
In Central and Eastern Europe and the former USSR, several
countries gave a free political advertising space to the various parties in
newspapers owned by the State, quite similar to the free advertising time given
in most countries on public radio and television channels.
When countries choose this route, you can recommend that
political parties may not use this space at their leisure, but in the form of a
summary standardized their election manifesto. This right could be granted
equally (given that newspapers can increase their volume and that voters who
are not interested can easily turn the pages, which are not possible in the
case of the broadcast media) and obviously applies to newspapers owned by the
State.
However, it should be take care not to overload the newspapers
free advertisements, as has been the case of Rossiiskaya Gazeta in December
1995 (parliamentary elections in Russia). The newspaper had published free
electoral texts for all parties or blocks.
Because he had only a limited space, this obligation has
faced a formal obligation: the publication of the lists of the electoral blocs.
Ultimately, the conflict was resolved in favour of the lists. These have filled
the pages of the newspaper during the campaign and had however always not been
all published the day of the elections.
Paid political advertising in the written press is generally
allowed, unlike paid advertising on the broadcast media (see corresponding
paragraph). In principle, there is perhaps no valid reason that we make this
distinction between the press and the broadcast media (radio and television),
yet it is.
There may be to this several reasons: the written press is
generally much less regulated. Television advertising has can - be seen as
having more influence and it was perhaps feared that the substantial ?nancial
resources required by television advertising destroy equality of
opportunities.
In countries where paid advertising on television is not
allowed, the established parties currently provide large budgets to intervene
in the press when the campaign is in full swing. Is it in the interest of the
public to curb this practice? The debate is open. However, could consider
reducing this practice at a lower level for reasons similar to those that are
highlighted in the section on the broadcast media. Editors will oppose is
probably arguing that this violates their freedom of speech.
However, this is not entirely true, because this incursion
would not editorial. If advertising on television is not permitted or campaign
expenses are limited, there is no principled reason to not also limit
advertising in newspapers.
2.2. THE MEDIA BROADCAST
The monolithic approach of broadcasting is perhaps a bit
obsolete. Laitela, T (1995), and Juusela, P (1991) in Journalistic codes of
ethics in the CSCE countries, University note that electronic media are
increasingly diversi?ed and competitive, the public can become fragmented.
Public television in Europe has over the dominant (or monopoly) position that
it once held, and it is often exceeded by commercial broadcasters. In addition,
generalist terrestrial broadcasters face competition from more specialized
presenters: strings (encrypted and pay) to public targeted and limited,
distributed via satellite or cable.
The parties and candidates running a mandate consider
television as their preferred campaign media. They organize events specially
designed to get airtime: opportunities for photographs, walks, press
conferences, tours election (Mr Blair in a factory, Mr Blair in the crowd, Mr
Blair talking to people on the street, Mr Blair giving a speech setting the
agenda).
Policies also use more of soundbites that pass to the evening
newscast and they devote more time and resources looking for the hearing, the
marketing techniques and their presentation and television training.
These two developments proliferation of channels and
increasing professionalism with which parties and candidates lead and manage
their campaign change the face of the coverage of the elections by television
in Western Europe today.9(*)
In articles published in the journal of electoral knowledge
(ACE) some authors we demonstrate the media, especially television, are
considered more and more important for the electoral campaign and parties and
candidates try to appear on television as much as possible. Television is
widely regarded as the most important means for the campaign and reaches voters
in countries where there is a wide coverage and a large audience.
Any regulation of media activity during elections normally
applies to a specified campaign period. There would be an official campaign
period during which these regulations apply, otherwise the activity of media
will be governed by the usual practice.
The campaign period is the period prior to the election.
Nevertheless, pre-election activities generally occur for a longer period than
that of the official campaign in the electoral calendar.
In some countries, there are also regulations specifying a
period of silence. It's a period or a number of days following before the
elections, during which no campaign activity is permitted and there are strict
restrictions on what the media can write or broadcast.
During the pre-election period of recent electoral cycles,
technology has become more and more dominant. This includes text/SMS by the
widespread use of mobile phones, even in rural areas, the use of Smartphones,
mainly in urban areas and access to online (such as Facebook or Twitter)
platforms via private computers or in Internet cafes.
The media are essential to democracy, ("world day of freedom
of the press 2005; Dakar
Declaration»,UNESCO,accessedJuly8,2015,http://www.unesco.org/new/en/unesco/events/prizes-and-celebrations/celebrations/international-days/world-press-freedom-day/previous-celebrations/worldpressfreedomday200900000/dakar-declaration/')
and it is impossible to hold democratic elections without the media.
Elections are free and fair, require not only that the vote
can be held in good conditions, but also that voters have access to adequate
information on political parties and the electoral process itself in order to
make an informed choice.
An election cannot be democratic without the media, which play
a role of monitoring and guarantee the transparency of the process. Indeed, a
democratic election without freedom of the press, or with a restricted freedom,
would be inherently contradictory. ("Media Play a Key Role in Senegal's
Election", International Center for Journalists, may 7, 2012,
http://www.icfj.org/news/media-play-key-role-senegals-election)
The declaration issued at the end of the annual international
conference of the world day of freedom of the press 2005 notes that
"independent and pluralistic media are essential to ensure transparency,
accountability and participation, fundamental aspects of good governance and
human rights-based development".
In addition, the declaration urges Member States "to respect
the function of the media, which are an essential factor in good governance and
have a key role to play to make decision-making processes more transparent and
accountable and communicate the principles of good governance to the
citizens".
In order to fulfill their roles, the media must maintain a
high level of professionalism, accuracy and impartiality in their coverage.
Regulatory frameworks can help ensure high standards. Laws and regulations
should ensure fundamental freedoms indispensable to democracy, including
freedom of expression, information and participation.
Certain provisions, including requiring the Government media,
funded by the State, to provide coverage just elections and equitable access to
the opposition parties, allowing to ensure appropriate behavior of the media
during elections.
Media usually means the written press, radio and television.
Recently, this definition is however expanded to include new media, such as
online journalism and social media. Citizen journalism has the wind in its
sails, including in countries where traditional media are controlled or
strictly regulated.
The right of voters to complete and accurate information, and
their right to participate in debates and dialogue on issues of policy and with
the men and women in politics, is a major concern for the media coverage of the
elections. At the same time, parties and candidates have the right to use the
media as a platform to interact with the public.
In addition, the electoral management body (EMB) needs to
communicate information to the electorate and various other groups, including
political parties and candidates. The media themselves have the right to
exercise freely and to examine the whole of the electoral process. This review
is a necessary protection against interference or corruption in the management
or conduct of the electoral process.
3. NO DEMOCRATIC ELECTIONS WITHOUT FREE AND
PLURALISTIC MEDIA
Lisa Kammerud in An Integrated Approach to Elections and
Conflict April 2012 indicates the elections that have marked the African news
of 2011 (see benchmark contemporary Africa, n°239, 2011/3, p. 135) have
highlighted the role played by the media in these elections. State media
accused of massive support to the head of the outgoing State, regulators of
communication suspected of being partisan, significant violations of the rights
of journalists, in particular those belonging to the opposition close press...
Grievances are often redundant.
And yet, so that elections can be classified as free and
democratic, not only they must unfold in political and administrative
conditions adequate, but it is important that citizens have sufficient access
to information relating to parties, candidates and the conduct of voting, in
order to ensure that their choice is informed.
So elections are described as fair and transparent all
stakeholders should have the opportunity to express themselves and journalists
to travel and investigate as part of their work. In short, democratic elections
are simply impossible without freedom of the press (Howard, 2005).
3.1 THE CHALLENGE OF ACCESS TO INFORMATION
Finally, to enable citizens to make an informed choice, access
to information must be guaranteed. However, three obstacles hinder the movement
of complete and rigorous information to all citizens. On the one hand,
journalists face significant constraints on access to public information, even
when it comes to essential data, such as the constitution of the electoral
file, cutting of the exchanges, or the mapping of the polling stations.
In countries that have experienced a State monopoly on the
media for decades, the retention of public information remains ubiquitous. Free
elections require transparency, where the opacity, deliberate lies and
propaganda have been the rule.
This is a radical change in the political and administrative
culture that requires improvements both on the side of the agents of the State,
which must now communicate, and on the side of journalists who must learn to
locate and request the information.
The lack of access to the data can lead the media to relay
rumors, fanciful surveys or to unfounded speculation that can have damaging
consequences. In the DRC in 20011, as in Kenya next year, media, share and
other, presented as confirmed the victory of 'their' candidate, preparing
activists to reject and challenge the results then published by the electoral
commission. Part and another, the final publication of non-compliance with the
expectations generated an explosion of violence.
In addition, the large number of violations of the freedom of
the press barrier also research information and led many African journalists to
practice self-censorship, particularly in contexts where attacks against their
colleagues give rise to no procedure in justice or punishment to officials or
sponsors. In countries such as Burkina Faso, Rwanda and Togo, self-censorship
of journalists became probably the first obstacle to the right of citizens to
access information.
Finally, the entire population access to pluralist information
in election period is also hampered by the unequal distribution of media and,
often, their low area broadcast. In the francophone African countries in
particular, the written press is limited to the capital and the prints are very
low, not exceeding a few thousand copies. Even if newspapers go from hand to
hand and reach many more readers than there are buyers, dissemination is
limited by the high cost of publications.
Only small urban elite settled and francophone can be
accessed. Television, which involves a significant investment because of the
high cost of TVs and access to electricity, is also reserved for urban and
affluent populations.
Central African Republic, Burundi, Congo Brazzaville, Tchad,
national television, almost in a situation of monopoly, is barely captured
outside the capital. As many private radio stations, they play a great role of
information at the local level, but they broadcast in FM, with a range from 50
to 100 km.
In some parts of Chad and the Central African Republic, some
voters do not have access to complete information on electoral competition, if
sometimes because they receive only radio national or international radio
emitting shortwave in languages they do not understand.
3.2 COMMUNICATIVE THEORY OF ACTING IN THE ELECTORAL
CONTEXT
Present on all fronts bioethics, Europe or revisionism,
Jürgen Habermas is arguably one of the great intellectual figures of our
time. Former assistant to Theodor Adorno, considered as the heir of the
Frankfurt School. As such, he was deeply influenced by Marxism and criticism of
the technical and scientific rationality which instrumentaliserait the nature
but also human for the interests of the dominant class.
The publication of theory of action communication constitutes
a turning point in the thought of Habermas since it will deviate from the
critical theory advocated by the Frankfurt School to be closer to the spirit of
the enlightenment by valuing the "communication", which would be only able to
produce a democratic agreement. It then includes its desire to respond in
public space, which occupies an essential place in his opinion in the
functioning of our societies.
Habermas is a particularly difficult author and theory of
action communication is no exception to this rule. To do this, the German
philosopher built a history of modern theories of Max Weber in Max Horkheimer
and Adorno passing by George H. Mead, Emile Durkheim, but also by the
achievements of the pragmatics of language with John L. Austin and John Searle
to sit his concept of a "communicative reason. Where of course a great
abstraction of the book which was the rest well often alleged.
3.2.1 ACCURACY, FAIRNESS AND SINCERITY
But do not stop at this because the theses of the German
philosopher are not less strong and have a decisive influence on contemporary
thought. If, in his early works, he did criticism of Western reason as the
expression of techno science dominating and alienating, it shows in theory of
acting communicational reason also has a communicational function which is
spontaneously rooted in language and speech, even in its more everyday
forms.
The statements issued by anyone who seeks to understand others
have a triple the validity claim: claim to accuracy, claim to accuracy compared
to the social context and its standards, and finally claim to sincerity.
This is why it is possible, even in having taken note of the
failure of great metaphysical systems, to reach consensus on ethical or
political standards by discussing in a reasoned manner. It includes therefore
the debate will Habermas with postmodernism.
Postmodern thought no longer believe in the reason: any speech
can be that relative because our time has shown that could hardly establish
universal norms. Theory of acting communicational shows on the contrary that
the communicative reason allows us to break the deadlock and "without
dramatizing take leave of the concept of absolute.
4. JURISDICTION MEDIA ANALYTICS
According to DEVILLE, G, in his book the power of the media
stresses that the facilitation of human social relationships between the
candidates of the opposition and the majority, has paved the way for media
coverage. And retain the opinion poll represents much of the media coverage of
the election campaign.
Polls are a sophisticated way to quantify public opinion on
elections and to know the percentage of voters who share the same views.
Political parties make use of polls to find out what voters think of their
leader and their electoral program.
Following the results of the polls, the parties sometimes
alter their manifestos and the words of their leaders. Generally, by claiming
that their leaders are popular, parties are trying to encourage voters to vote
for them. Polls can influence on the vote because voters, generally, allow
themselves to be influenced by the general trend.
Polls are a source of exciting information in the elections
because the political leaders are presented as being in a race in the election.
However, the polls are representative only of a brief vision of public opinion
at a given time. It could very well change a few days after the poll following
new information. Polls attract too much attention and could easily influence
elections.
It also other persons who wish to present their views on the
elections. There are specific communities of united people not only
geographically, but also by common interests, such as, for example, farmers,
fishermen, merchants, teachers, etc. These communities might be also the
elderly, victims of anti-personnel mines, the relatives of the victims of
recent wars, or people belonging to the same caste or tribe, etc.
These communities often express real problems, but they are
unable to make themselves heard enough because they are poor, live in remote
areas or are victims of discrimination. For media, there is nothing easier than
to follow politicians and repeat what they say in their speeches. However, it
is imperative that they communicate the voice of minority voters and
politicians so political candidates address their problems.10(*)
There are also experts who provide opinions reflected on the
problems and manifestos. It can be teachers universities, or specialists in
specific areas such as women's rights, human rights or the rights of employees,
or former elected or former elections officials. Experts bring new ideas and
offer new perspectives to the voters and the media during the campaign.
Walking shoes voters help the journalist to produce stories.
This creates questions to be put to politicians. For example: what is the first
thing to which the voter believes? Certainly the security. The voter wants to
be reassured that acts of violence will not occur at polling stations and the
vote will remain secret. He also wants to know where to head to complaints of
threats against him. It is easy to raise these issues in stories collected in
local communities or across the country.
Media must inform the electors of the electoral laws. They
also interview the police, the electoral commission or the voters who have been
victims of violence in the previous elections. The media must know what
measures had been taken to deal with such acts in the current election. How do
react officials and politicians in the event of outbreak of new violence? Open
an investigation? Are they able to put an end to these acts? Are they trying to
stop? Voters also want to know the choices about the vote on candidates put at
their disposal during the polling day.
What are the names on the list of electors? Voters have the
right to obtain information regarding the candidates and political parties.
They need to compare different parties' election promises. An objective
reportage showing the different promises of parties over a specific problem of
the community will give choice more thoughtful voters.
When it starts instead of an elector, it must be remembered a
thing it is that the voter wants to know the opinions of its region. The
journalist can ask the same questions to members of the same community voter.
This method gives an idea about the main concerns of the community voter. For
example, the journalist can ask the question to voters: "what is the problem
most important you would like that the Government deals with priority?", or
"what do you think of the acts of violence that have marked these elections?
''
These questions can be posed to people in a restaurant or
people crossing a bridge at a time any day or women who are waiting for the bus
at a station. This method is to know the concerns of the citizens in their
daily lives. If their responses are similar, this could reflect the opinion of
a greater number of voters and therefore, this could be a hot topic. Even if
the answers are conflicting, this could be the subject of a report. However,
this is only the beginning of a long process.
The journalist must first collect information by asking
candidates what their parties will do to meet the needs and concerns of voters.
This journalism reflects the voice of the voters.
Journalists should also ask candidates what they think the
most important concerns of the voters and also compare their statements with
those of the other candidates.
5. THE CONGOLESE MEDIA LANDSCAPE
The Congolese media landscape underwent extraordinary
development in recent years, passing in less than twenty years, monopoly a
handful Government media to offer abundant, but unevenly distributed. The
country has, in October 2008, 341 broadcasting stations (whose one, Radio
Okapi, emits on the whole of the territory) and over 600 titles press reported,
mostly irregular market. There were also 82 television channels, whose three
radio-television national du Congo (RTNC), Digital Congo and radio-television
of the future group (RTG @) can transmit via satellite from Kinshasa and be
rebroadcast in some provinces of the country.
It is in the city of Kinshasa that focuses the media activity
since the capital hosted 51 of these TV channels, issuing clear, as well as 41
stations radio-FM broadcast, the 10 regular dailies in the country, 15
periodicals and about 20 newspapers appearing suddenly (over 125 newspapers
reported for this city alone).
Major publications (including the draw capped at 1,500 copies)
are therefore published in Kinshasa, while the press of province is periodic
and often random publication. Dissemination poses a critical problem given the
absence of transport networks and the weakness of the weakness of purchasing
power of the potential readership. Newspapers expressed exclusively in French
and are generally private belonging to one individual initiative.
In the audio-visual sector, the typology is more diversified.
The community and voluntary sector is dominant in the radio field (with 133
radios, whose three only located in Kinshasa), but little present in the
television niche (with three initiatives). Commercial private operators (which
there were 91 for the whole country) are usually mixed, combining radio and
television.
They are encountering 104 denominational operators, related to
the Catholic, Protestant, Kimbanguist churches, but also, especially in
Kinshasa, the so-called churches "to wake up. Add to this panorama public media
(the Congo national radio and television and its local branches), UN radio
(Radio Okapi, related to the United Nations Mission in Congo (MONUC)) and
international radios available in FM or through stall on the local radio.
Some providers of stories written (four news agencies) and
radio - telephone or television programs also play an important role of
information, disseminating their own productions or putting them at the
disposal of the local media who relay them.
If the offer grows considerably, the statistical study also
shows that the Congolese media consumption increases. Equipment rates are very
high, especially for the audiovisual sector and urban centers. Radio remains
the most common media in DRC with an equipment rate that varies, for urban
areas, 97% 92% (Kinshasa) (Goma). In rural communities, equipment rates are
sometimes much lower (in the town of Bundu, in Orientale Province, it does only
64%), but the radio still widely ranks compared to other media.
Television talonne radio in major cities: 97% in Kinshasa, 90%
in Lubumbashi, 92% in Matadi, 82% in Mbuji-Mayi, 69% in Bukavu, 65% in Goma and
61% in Kisangani. It is much less present in rural communities (between 27% and
60% for the surveyed localities) and ranks in general after the mobile
phone.
This last is important in the whole of the country
penetration: the equipment rate of 72%, 68% in Kinshasa, 70% in Mbuji-Mayi, 68%
in Matadi, 53% in Bukavu, 54% to 45% in Kisangani and Goma. In rural
communities, it reaches between 10 and 45%. With respect to Internet users,
they are also more numerous: with growth of more than 35% between 2002 and
2007, the Web is frequented by over 230,000 users, in urban essentially.
Consumption practices analyzed by media type and according to
age groups, by gender and level of study of surveyed public reveal that the
print media and Internet recruiting their hearing from more educated
individuals (and), while consumption of radio is widespread in all age and
gender groups.
In the audio-visual sector, the duration of daily consumption
is large enough. Kinshasa, Lubumbashi and Matadi, it is television that wins
(196 minutes per day in women and 158 minutes for males in Kinshasa), far in
front of the radio (86 minutes of daily consumption among women and 105
men).
In other cities, it is radio that comes to mind. Women spend
more time than men on television and less time than them on the radio. This
last is its peaks of hearing in the morning slices around 0700, while
television is especially watched the evening, particularly from 8 pm. In rural
communities, television and mobile phone are, systematically, more used by men
than by women, which is not the case of the radio.11(*)
Radios, and most televisions vary between cities and the times
of the day - born, but it is possible to identify a few stations and successful
programs. In the radio landscape, Radio Okapi and Radio France International
(RFI) are leading in Kinshasa and Lubumbashi; their morning information slices
are particularly popular. In other towns and rural localities, Radio Okapi is
often head or preceded by a local radio station.
In television, the public seems more attracted to the
entertainment and information: soap operas (issued by Mirador TV or Digital
Congo) and sports won a great success, while RTNC, once monopoly, is little
more than necessary through his newscast.
The Congolese media pluralism is therefore undeniable, in
terms of both the number and diversity of the media, their status (commercial,
community, and public), their affiliation or belonging political, religious,
ideological, and their implantation and diffusion RADIUS. However, monitoring
of the content in these media to measure gaps in terms of quality of the
information made available to the Congolese public and the real possibilities
of expression of the various components of the population through the media.
Since the liberalization of the sector, announced in 1990, the
Congolese media have proliferated in meteoric way and the media landscape is
today marked by pluralism faith-sounding. There are thus:
· For the city of Kinshasa
51 TV channels broadcasting in clear, 41 stations of radio
broadcasting in FM, 10 regular newspapers, 15 magazines and 20 newspapers
appearing out of the blue (on a collection of over 125 newspapers reported);
· On the whole of the national territory
82 television channels including 3 radio and television
national du Congo (RTNC), Digital Congo, and radio-television of the future
group (RTG @) broadcast by satellite from Kinshasa and are repeated in some
provinces of the country; 341 stations broadcasting (whose one, Radio Okapi,
emits on the whole of the territory) and more than 600 titles press reported,
mostly irregular on the market.
5.1. THE WRITTEN PRESS
After a period of strong State control (the President Mobutu
had authorized the publication of two national bodies, Elima and Salongo, and
one newspaper by province), the beginning of the 1990s was marked by the
explosion of the private press in Kinshasa and, to a lesser extent, in the
province. From 1990 to 1995, more than six hundred (600) publications were
registered with the Ministry, but most have hardly exceeded the first numbers.
The press, which is essentially political, then shared in 'red' press (radical
opposition) and press "blue" or "green" (favorable to the Mobutu regime).
After eighteen years of tumultuous Congolese political
history, only a few of these titles have survived; some remaining faithful to
their editorial line, other operating sometimes spectacular reversals.
In August 2008, if there are 638 publications registered
throughout the Congolese territory, 228 titles just seem the most irregular
way. The legal regime under the 1996 press law is that of the prior statement:
before launching his title on the market, a Publisher must simply submit to the
appropriate service of the Ministry in charge Information, a declaration
containing the title of the newspaper, its periodicity and the full identity of
the owner and the Director of publication. Some tracks recorded have never
experienced their first edition, while others appear on the market before
making the slightest administrative approach.
The publications are mainly concentrated in the city of
Kinshasa where, on 125 titles currently identified, a small score is published
regularly, either daily (potential, the lighthouse, La Référence
Plus, Uhuru, the storm from the tropics, Le Palmarès, the observer, the
future, the Forum des As, to which is added the daily newsletter of the
Congolese press agency) 9, either periodically (The Post, the developer,
Numerica The prosperity, tomorrow the Congo, Africa News, the Soft, the Manager
Grognon, the alert, potpourri...).
There is no daily outside the capital. There are 65 newspapers
reported in Katanga, 19 in the Eastern Province, 17 in Kasai Oriental, 12 in
North Kivu, 8 in South Kivu, 11 in Bas-Congo, 5 in Ecuador, 4 in Kasai
Occidental and 1 in Bandundu. There is none in the Maniema.
The main private newspapers often appear randomly in the
provincial capitals:
· Lubumbashi: Mukuba, misunderstanding, brotherhood, and
the Lushois;
· Bukavu: The banner and the sovereign (only forthcoming
actually), Karibu, Kasuku and Kivu Safari;
· In Goma: Info Plus, the primary sovereign, the
peacemaker, junction and the scenes (published in blessed);
Print media companies are struggling to ensure their financial
survival. With low draws 1,500 maximum copies for the Kinshasa dailies, some
newspapers is limited to 150 or 200, a selling price high, inaccessible to the
common of the Congolese people (nearly 2 US$ for a Kinshasa newspaper), and an
advertising market limited, many newspapers survive occult financing, which
seriously compromising their perceived credibility. Often, the press of
province appears when she found a "sponsor".
There is the belief that the money is in the policy and that
it is through policies, inter alia, by the press that can enrich them. "This is
a congenital feature of print Khan in particular: its strong politicization,
many titles being born in the lap of a party or a politician. »A Minister,
a newspaper", was wont to say in Kinshasa where new titles appear when formed a
Government, to disappear when the sponsor Minister loses his wallet.
Except for a few daily newspapers and weekly regular capital,
most Congolese newspapers work widely informally and respond little to the
appellation of 'undertaking' of press. Many titles are animated by a single
person, here and there seeking the collaboration of freelancers when met the
means necessary for the publication of an issue. Fifteen newspapers only have a
seat; others are made at home or in the workplace of their owner.
Outside the circuit of the "commercial" private press, several
thematic publications circulate in the DRC, edited by NGOs or religious
communities. Some are derived from cooperation projects that have the ambition
the General information of the citizen; they can therefore be considered as
actors of the media landscape in its own right.
The Journal of the citizen (JDC) is a weekly supplement of
(election of first citizen then) information inserted in eight major newspapers
in Kinshasa and sent in the form of photocopies in the province.
Launched in September 2005, jointly by the Panos Institute in
Paris and the Association for the Promotion of Education and training abroad
(APEFE), under the aegis of the high authority of the media (HAM), it was
directed by a team of 7 to 10 freelancers from newspapers partners, placed at
disposal of the JDC by their employer one day a week, for a period of three
months. Their portion at the JDC allowed these journalists to train for various
journalistic genres just usual press Khan and practice information.
Freelance was paid 50 US$ and the editor was paid for the
insert of the newspaper in its publication. In August 2008, JDC drew more than
18,000 copies, making it the first draw of the DRC. Distributed in over 35
locations, it was the only title of the Congolese press to have national
coverage.
Since September 2008, JDC is transformed into a 'log-school',
integrated with the Institute faculty of Sciences Information and Communication
(IFASIC). It is now produced by students in the terminal year of the degree
course "print media", framed by two permanent. Several newspapers continue to
encarter it, now without financial compensation, and its circulation has been
reduced to 9000 copies.
The Syfia Great Lakes newspaper is, for its part, a regional
project on the DRC, Rwanda and Burundi, led by agency Syfia International (a
network of nine news agencies located in Europe and francophone Africa). The
Congolese branch of Syfia, called Inter Congo Media (ICM), publishes this
publication bimonthly 12-page with the support of French branches (here Labas
media) and Belgian (Info South Belgium). The newspaper published a part of the
reports and investigations produced by correspondents Syfia lakes in the three
countries concerned.
He is fired 4,000 copies and distributed free of charge to
organizations that can make it available to their public (schools, parishes,
libraries, NGOs, local bodies and local authorities), in ten of the eleven
provinces of Congo. It is sold to consumers at points of sale at a price of 200
f.c. (Congolese francs), an amount significantly lower than that of private
newspapers.
5.2 BROADCASTING
The radio landscape has experienced an extraordinary
development for ten years. For the city of Kinshasa alone, there are 40
stations that broadcast in FM. A census conducted in 2008, with the support of
UNICEF, FAO and UNESCO, in the context of the implementation of the development
strategy (RDS) broadcasting of Government, identifies more than 378 radio
stations (of which about 280 emit actually). Our own census in counted 34111,
four years after the first survey conducted by the Institute Panos Paris, which
identified 106 stations12.
The Congolese radio landscape thus
consists:
· a public broadcaster, the RTNC (radio-television
national du Congo), which has two channels in Kinshasa and (theoretically);
· 133 radio community, associative, academic and
educational (non-commercial); · 104 denominational radio stations
(most of which are radio stations say "Evangelical" or "messianic" churches of
awakening-related);
· 91 commercial private radio stations;
· A radio of the Mission of the Organization of the
United Nations in the Congo (MONUC), called Radio Okapi.
In addition the international radio stations in FM: Radio
France International (RFI, pre - feel in six cities), Africa n ° 1,
British Broadcasting Corporation (BBC) and radio television Belgium Francophone
(RTBF) - available on FM in Kinshasa only.
The Press Act of 1996 sets the conditions for the
establishment of an audio - visual business, but the latter are hardly
regard13. In Kinshasa, the licenses are granted by the Ministry of post,
telephone and Telecommunications (PTT), and then the permissions issue is
issued by the Ministry in charge the council14. In the province, the modalities
for registration of radio range. The majority of radio stations that broadcast
feature a ...
2.2.1 THE VIABILITY AND INDEPENDENCE OF MEDIA
COMPANIES
Beyond the limitations to the exercise of freedom of
expression, the Congolese media face permanently with problems of survival.
The viability of the media is hindered by two factors for the
local market: on the one hand, the economic environment is not conducive to the
development of the information sector; on the other hand, the internal
structure of the media is often an obstacle to greater profitability.
a) The parameters of the market
To survive, the Congolese media must reach balance their costs
and profits. Costs consist mainly by the cost of investment (equipment and
inputs), costs (rent, electricity and wage costs) operation and taxes and
taxes. Revenues mainly reside in the proceeds of the sale (for print),
advertising and announcements, as well as any subsidies.
In the current context, the loads are numerous and reduced
revenue, which hinders the development of media and their ability to provide
quality productions.
b) Elements on the budgets of the Congolese media
It is difficult to present a budget type, because companies
work with very differentiated economic models on which they are, for the most
part, reluctant to communicate. A newspaper as the potential requires a monthly
budget of about 40,000 US$ to ensure its daily publication, while radio and
television which belong to the same group (Radio 7 and TV 7) work with 10,000
US$ per month. Radio Maendeleo needs, meanwhile, an annual budget of nearly of
400,000 US$, is 33 000 US$ per month.
The Mwangaza RT in Lubumbashi has a monthly budget of
approximately 25,000 US$, while a great chain Khan as RTG @ or Digital Congo
spend about 120 000 US$ per month. At the other extreme, some newspapers just
200 US$ which cover their bills printing to appear on the market and the small
community radio can survive with 10 000 US$ per year! Some figures are provided
here for information only.
3. Consequences of the elections in 2011 in the
DRC
In their advocacy Document on the election issues in the DRC
of the Mission of the MEP published dated from 9 to June 13, 2014, Mariya
Gabriel (head of the election observation mission of the European Union in the
DRC in 2011), stressed in his report that the presidential elections of
November 28, 2011 were marked by significant gaps in terms of preparation and
numerous irregularities during the collection and compilation of results.
As a consequence, the credibility of the election results has
been seriously questioned. Congolese and international observers have clearly
pointed to the harmful role of the independent National Electoral Commission
(CENI).
The 2011 elections have led to a crisis of legitimacy now
exacerbated by the blow given to decentralization, as well as by the
postponement of provincial elections in 2012 and the local elections, expected
since 2006.12(*)
In its general report on the elections of 2011 in the DRC the
European Union's electoral observation mission stresses that the absence of the
Constitutional Court has also created serious problems of electoral disputes
anti-press even the results of the elections.
So therefore, the electoral law stipulates that the
Constitutional Court is responsible for judging the electoral disputes but this
has still not been installed. The organic law on the Organization and
functioning of the Constitutional Court, voted in his time to February - March
2011 by the Senate and the National Assembly, had been forwarded to the head of
State for promulgation.
However, in making use of the powers specifically conferred by
the constitution, the President of the Republic declared it non-conforming to
the constitution and he returned it for amendment. At the request of the
President, this Act was amended by the Parliament and the Act was again sent to
the President for promulgation; what has not been the case so far.
Observers are unanimous: coupled elections, presidential and
legislative, November 2011 in the DRC have been calamitous. Worse than 2006.
The Congolese Carter, the European Commission, the United States, France,
Belgium, the Episcopal conference, NGOs from all walks of life join in
deploring the failures of the first consultation organized by the Congolese
themselves to the difference in the election of 2006, supervised by the
international community, MONUC (the UN Congo Mission) and CIAT (International
Committee for support to the Transition).
Their footsteps, the Western press in unison denounced the
electoral fiasco, the opacity of the operations of counting involving the
credibility of the results. Naturally, the losers cried fraud.
Border province
Limit of territory
Percentage by territory
Electoral map of the DRC
Disputes under the terms of the law ought to be brought before
a Constitutional Court under the Constitution of 2006, but it was not created
and this is the Supreme Court of Justice, which was only competent to electoral
disputes. Gold members of this Court have been mostly appointed by the
President that bold by appointing new members during the election campaign,
which calls into question his impartiality.
In an article written following a visit in Kinshasa at the
time of the elections, Jean-Claude Willame reports a Vital Kamehre remarks: '
in Congo it is always 'you win, or you win', but never ' you win or you lose.
The thought of losing is itself inconceivable for the holder of the power. This
is not specific to the DRC, the example of Côte d'Ivoire and the refusal
of Laurent Gbagbo to accept his defeat is in the memories.
The power is not in this case merely material benefits to
which it gives access: deeper "belly policy" is a policy of being it. I
dominate so I'm. The arena of power excites endless impulses of the dominant
male. If the ruse is not enough, ultimate arbitration returns to the force.
Such attitudes seem particularly entrenched in the representations and
political practices in Central Africa forest.
Chapter Three: THE ROLE OF MEDIA DURING THE
ELECTORAL PERIOD
INTRODUCTION
It is the key of our research chapter, this in this part we
will demonstrate the rules, conduct, and the elements that any journalist said
professional must observe during the election period. Applicable to all bases
for responsible journalism will be the bulk of this third chapter.
I. ELECTIONS
The word election comes from the Latin word, derived from the
verb eligere who wants to choose. Commonly, it is said that an election is a
choice, a designation of one or several persons through suffrage. The elections
are therefore a means by which citizens choose freely the rulers between
political trends that are expressed without restriction.
According to MULUMBATI NGASHA, the election is also defined as
a mode by which the rulers or power-holders are chosen by the governed.
As Georges BURDEAU, the election is a means through which the
elect are invested with a function.
For Pierre DEQUIRINI, elections are the designation of
politicians by the vote of the citizens.
William EPENGE sets the election as an important and commonly
available to citizens to make known their views and to participate in the
development of national policy by designating among them, a small number of
representatives who undertake on their behalf and in their place to decide on
public affairs.
For ROBERT, the election is also defined as a choice, a
designation of one or more persons by a vote. Thus, about the free and
democratic elections, we say with Irung TSHITAMBALA that "the election is
essence, the Act by which the people chooses its representatives to exercise
power in its name.
Therefore, it is a decisive means of expression of the will of
the people, of political participation; a peaceful technique by which we become
rulers, a process whereby the governed themselves in democratic management
today.
It is also an essential element of modern democracy, which is
basically representative and which defines itself as a momentum of
appropriating the right of the people to designate (by the elections) and to
actually exercise this right in its name, for the more and more for
all.13(*)
As for us, the election is a medium that allows people to
translate their willingness to participate in the management of the national
policy freely designating their leaders or their representatives through the
ballot box.
There are several types of elections according to the various
levels of administrative districts and according to the different functions
that the candidates are called upon to perform, including:
1. Presidential Election: vote to designate the president of
the Republic or the head of State. The presidential election is a choice of the
supreme authority of the nation passing through the ballot box.
2. Legislative Election: voting for deputies to the National
Assembly or the representatives of the people.
3. Municipal Election: vote for Councilors.
Thus, we can enumerate a few guiding principles for a good
election: good elections are those that are free, democratic and
transparent.
1.1 FREE ELECTION
Election, free means:
· Respect for fundamental freedoms and human rights;
· The right to freedom of expression and opinions;
· The right to freedom of association and of
demonstration;
· The right to engage in his political party recognized
legally;
· The right to equality and fairness for all.
1.2 DEMOCRATIC ELECTIONS
By democratic elections, the people has a Word to say about
the decisions that affect the lives of the entire company, therefore govern by
institutions and practices of fair rules for all, equal treatment of women
compared to men and taking account of vulnerable groups, people living with
disabilities, and the challenge of illiteracy , the banishment of any
discrimination based on race, tribe or ethnicity, social class, sex, religion
and all other characteristics not comply with democratic rules. The only
acceptable limit to deprive a citizen of his right to vote remains the law that
is impersonal and general.
1.3 TRANSPARENT ELECTIONS
They are characterized by the following elements:
· Transparent mechanisms for consultation, representation
and decision-making;
· Respect of the rules of procedure previously
established and clearly defined;
· Communication open through consultation frameworks;
recruitment of qualified staff and moral probity recognized;
· The acquisition of reliable material (transparent urns
for example, indelible ink, reliable data, ballot information, etc.);
· The establishment of the reliable electoral lists, of
partisan observers (political party) and independent (Observer, neutral) of the
elections;
· The financing of political parties and the regulation
of election campaigns;
· The display of the lists of electors;
· The announcement of the provisional results based on
the ballot (sealed) box to audits by the Court of appeal or the Supreme Court
of Justice, depending on the nature of the vote, in case of dispute.
1.4 OTHER DEFINITIONS
The election is a procedure by which the members of a group
(regardless of the main purpose) would be able to appoint their leaders and to
make collective choices about the conduct of their common Affairs.
Lulli LIPSON sets the election as being "decisive event
whereby the people expresses its will. It is at this time and according to this
method that the citizens who are subject to the laws assert themselves the
masters of those who make the laws.
Maurice DUVERGER, for its part, sets the election as "the most
important and most common means. Available to citizens to make their views and
participate in the development of the national policy It is for all citizens,
to designate a small number of representatives who undertake on their behalf
among them and their place of deciding public affairs»
These two authors, it emerges that the election is the way by
which the people expresses its readiness to participate in the life of the
nation by choosing representatives whose programs are consistent with its
concerns.
The election is one of the features of modern regimes
organized with degrees of efficiency and of varying sincerity, throughout the
contemporary world. A respecter of Ferdinand Kapanga became very common,
considers the concept 'election' as a means by which the people shall appoint
representatives who undertake, on its behalf and in its place, deciding public
affairs.
In other words, it is a serious act by which electors are
called not only to make their views known, but also to participate indirectly
in the development of national policy or a policy choice, he says.
In order to avoid falling into controversies without issues
and as these definitions complement each other, we are the definition of
Ngoma-BINDA that elections are a mode of arbitration of ambitions, of access to
power, a mode legitimate insofar as it is peaceful.
On the other hand, the vote is a vote using the signs or
bulletins posed in a container (URN) where removed then to count. This
electoral operation then includes the filing of ballots in the ballot box,
counting and the announcement of the results.
There are several modes of voting, also known as electoral
systems. The most cited are the plurality (first past the post, nominal multi,
a tower, and two towers), proportional representation and mixed systems.
For the presidential election of 2006, the electoral law spent
by direct universal suffrage and an absolute plurality in two rounds while
national and provincial legislative elections have seen direct universal
suffrage to the parallel poll. In short, there were a combination of two
electoral majority and proportional depending on the size of the electoral
district.
II. ELECTORAL SYSTEMS
Is called electoral systems arrested and charged recognized
polling modes to democratically appoint candidates for their posts.14(*)
Currently, there are two classic types of electoral systems
who are opposed in this regard:
· Majority voting;
· Proportional representation.
2.1. THE PLURALITY
This electoral system translates as elected the candidate who
arrives at the top of the list. One that gets the number superior voice over
the other candidates. There are two forms of majoritarian systems: it may be
majority outright in one round or two rounds majority system.
In the majority system, the candidate who obtains the largest
number of votes is declared elected, regardless of the total of the votes
obtained by opponents. It is the system practiced in the case of the elections
in single seat in the Congo.
On the other hand, the election in two rounds, it is the form
of majoritarian system where is elected who obtain half votes more one vote in
the first round. In the case of non-realization of the absolute majority in the
first round, a second is organized where the candidate will be elected. It is
nominal multi when several candidates are elected in each electoral
district.
2.2. THE PROPORTIONAL REPRESENTATION
It is a system in which the seats are divided between the
lists in the presence proportionally with the number of votes obtained. The
latter system promotes the representativeness of small political trends.
2.3 ELECTION ISSUE
By definition, a challenge is what can win or lose in a
competition, a company. For the people, the major issue of the election is to
make it free and truly independent, that is master of his own fate. This is the
issue of self-determination. Unfortunately for some politicians and political
groups, the elections are an opportunity to climb to power or control to
acquire or save some benefits.
According to our understanding, the electoral challenge is the
focal point around which the elections are held alternatively, expectations and
aspirations of the people around the elections.
A democracy is always based on the possibility to express
freely varying opinions and well-informed citizens vote. Media and journalists
play therefore a key role in the electoral process in ensuring the flow of
information and opinions, and their confrontation. They allow a better
knowledge of the candidates, parties and programs.
They contribute to the effective participation of citizens in
the democratic debate, particularly by placing at the heart of the campaign
themes of general interest. Guarantors of democracy, journalists were also
instrumental in the legitimation and acceptance of the results of the
elections, in particular in the countries in democratic transition or
crisis.
These responsibilities give journalists rights and duties. The
right to inform freely, without being subject to pressure or intimidation, a
corollary duty to issue to voters responsible, i.e. objective, informative and
constructive information. It is a complex work, with challenges and pitfalls to
avoid. Many are indeed examples of journalists who allowed them to be diverted
from their neutral and impartial fact-finding in favor of partisan,
violence-generating positions taken.
III. MEDIA AND COVERAGE OF THE ELECTIONS
III.1 RULES FOR JOURNALISTS.
During an election period, the journalist may be subject to
pressure from many quarters. They can be the result of a Government,
particularly in countries where the democratization process is still fragile,
political parties, which means various and varied to get favorable media
coverage, but also sometimes of an employer, shareholder or owner of a media,
close a candidate, who wants to impose a certain editorial line.
The journalist must also withstand the pressures of his own
opinion that he can express as any other citizen in the secrecy of the voting
booth. The public expects of him that he placed "above the fray" parties and
that he treats them with the same impartiality, whatever sympathy or antipathy
that can inspire him the candidate.
To resist such pressure and be up to the task, the journalist
must rely on the basic principle of his profession: ethics. It is composed of a
set of moral rules his ethics that manage the dedication of a journalist. No
universal Charter does legally exist. There are nevertheless similar codes of
ethics in many countries.
All say that journalism is a discipline in permanent quest of
truth and objectivity. To be considered 'professional', information must be
accurate, verified, balanced, neutral and respectful of human dignity. This
implies a great moral probity, a keen sense of responsibility and an ability to
understand the different points of view, including those that the journalist
does not share. In any case, and regardless of the socio-political context in
the presence, the journalist should give priority to the best interests of the
citizens.
The 'fourth power' attributed to the media must be exercised
for Government or for a political party or to a person in particular. Loyalty
shall be exercised only to the citizens, taken together, that the journalist
has a duty to inform and exercise, largely through him, their right to freedom
of expression.
III.2 THE RIGHT TO FREEDOM OF OPINION AND
EXPRESSION
Journalists benefit from certain rights guaranteed by article
19 of the Universal Declaration of human rights of 1948 and by article 19 of
the international Covenant on the civil and political rights of 1966, signed
and ratified by 154 States. These rights are also protected by the three major
Conventions regional Africa, Americas, Europe relating to human rights.
They recognize journalists the right to seek, receive and
freely convey information without interference from the Government. The
authorities may not harass them or intimidate them or hamper their work in any
way whatsoever, nor cannot they censor or attempt to influence benefits
whatsoever.
A right and a duty during the election period, the journalist
therefore has the right to speak of all the parties and candidates, including
most hostile to the Government in place, and all the campaign themes that it
considers important for the citizens and the future of his country. The 1966
Pact recognizes freedom of expression to everyone. It must also guarantee the
possibility to all parties and candidates, but also to all citizens, to express
themselves freely during the election campaign:
· Giving them access to the media so that they present
their program or express their opinions.
· Denouncing barriers posed to the exercise of their
freedom of expression. Examples: a candidate is prevented by the authorities to
hold an election rally or a citizen under pressure of a party about electoral
cheating which he has established.
Legality and legitimacy of restrictions the Covenant of 1966
recognizes that there are a number limited by legitimate reasons that may
justify certain restrictions on freedom of expression, particularly when are
questioned in the respect of the rights or reputations of others, and the
safeguarding of national security, public order, health or morals public.
However, these restrictions must be explicitly set by the law
of the country held elections and their contents defined very precisely. A
vague formulation can indeed give a very large margin of maneuver to a
Government or a candidate already power to censor journalists whom it deems
unfavorable to its coverage.
The Act itself may also include illegitimate restrictions. It
happens, for example, that repressive laws inherited from the old regimes are
still in force in a country in transition to democracy. If an obstacle is posed
to its work due to a legal restriction, the journalist must therefore check
that it is legitimate under international law:
· lawful restriction example: be censored for incitement
to racial hatred;
· Illegitimate restriction example: ban all forms of
information and debate on themes involving fix the candidate for his own
succession, or block access to public information under the pretext of
safeguarding national security.
In General, the legal provisions relating to information and
communication should interfere with the ability of the press to present the
plurality of ideas and opinions of an election campaign.
Protection of information sources it is universally accepted
that the journalist has the right to not to disclose the source of information
to the public (or authorities), when this source does not want to be identified
publicly.
It must nevertheless guard against the risks of manipulation
that would lead to the dissemination of inaccurate information. Therefore, to
ensure the reliability of this source corroborating information from other
sources. To cover, the journalist can also reveal, in a manager of his writing,
the identity of his source and guarantee its reliability.15(*)
(a) Safety of journalists.
The safety of the journalist is fundamental so that it can
work in good conditions and without pressure. Otherwise, it must inform,
insofar as possible, self-regulation and media regulatory bodies, organizations
of human rights and/or public authorities of all threats, assaults and attacks
on freedom of the press which himself or his colleagues are victims. In fragile
States, a journalist should not work and expose themselves only in the course
of an election campaign. National or international professional associative
networks can accompany him and be alerted in case of serious problems.
An example of illegitimate restriction on freedom of the
press
An army general who made a coup d'état is subjected to
strong international pressure to reinstate democracy in his country. He decides
to organize a presidential election at which it is him - same candidate as well
as a legislative election with a ballot guaranteeing the military a mode number
of seats. Media echoed the protests of certain political parties contesting
this system. The junta then adopted a decree banning the press any form of
discussion on the military forces under the pretext of safeguarding national
security.
Journalists decide to disregard this restriction stating that
it is illegitimate under international law. They are arrested and imprisoned
for endangering the security of the State. In the days that follow, the
regional organization to which the country belongs suspends all relations with
the junta and threatens its leaders of individual sanctions.
b) Co-management of the media space
Co-management of the media space is characterized, according
to country, by intervention in the management of the media sector of several
institutions: departments in charge of Communication and of Justice, the
communication regulation authorities which are State institutions and
self-regulatory bodies dealing with the status of non-governmental organization
(NGO), implemented by the corporation of media professionals. During normal,
electoral or crisis, a collaboration gateway can settle between regulatory and
self-regulatory bodies: whether for the management of assistance from the State
to the private press positions to denounce, condemn or punish breaches of
ethics or ethics rules.
III.3. THE DUTY TO INFORM THE VOTERS
Article 19 of the international Covenant on the civil and
political rights of 1966 guarantees all citizens the right to receive
information. During an election period, it means that the State is obliged to
ensure that voters are duly informed of the modalities of voting and ballot
issue.
The authorities perform in general this task by organizing
awareness-raising campaigns (leaflets, advertisements, etc.) and giving air
time to all parties and candidates in the public audio-visual media. But this
obligation to inform the voters does not concern only the journalists of the
public service. All journalists have a professional and moral duty to inform
citizens in election period.
Naturally, this duty to provide information is the major
political issues of the election. Citizens need the information provided by the
media to learn more about the candidates, the programs of the different parties
and issues that make debate. But the journalist also has a role to play in
electoral education of citizens.
Contribute to voter education journalist must provide citizens
with information on the modalities of the election:
· Who is entitled to vote and who has the right to
stand?
· Where, when and how to register on the electoral
lists?
· Where, when and how to vote?
· What is the type of the election? (Legislative,
presidential, municipal, etc.)
· What are the positions to be filled and what powers and
responsibilities will they give to the elect?
This information is important in all countries, but even more
essential in the countries where democracy has appeared very late or that are
home to large parts of low literate population. They can contribute to the
broad participation of the public in the polls by the awakening of the civic
consciousness of the citizens. For example, explain in detail the procedures to
ensure the secrecy of the ballot (which avoids the reprisal) may reassure some
voters.
This information can be transmitted via stories:
· On the work of governmental or civil society
organizations specialized in electoral education.
· Canadian citizens to verify that they have understood
the different aspects of the electoral process and/or to highlight the aspects
on which awareness is still necessary.
The transmission of this information assumes a serious work of
preparation beforehand by the journalist.
III.3.1 EFFECTIVELY INFORM
Convey information only makes sense if this information can be
understood by its recipient. The journalist must keep in mind that an electoral
process raises problems and the very complex issues. The presentation should
always be accessible to the greatest number. A journalist is not a University.
This is a person able to explain complex problems with the forms of the
simplest language, a kind of Ombudsman somehow:
· A good reporter can say much with few words while a
less good journalist needs to use a lot of words to say very little.
· Short sentences with one idea per sentence.
· Establish a plan before you start story writing. The
plan allows to define the logic of an event (or a problem) and the most dynamic
way to tell (or explained). It also allows identifying the most important
information (the hierarchy of information). Then ask the following question: in
what order use this information so that the narrative is the most logical and
the clearest possible?
III.4. THE ACCURACY AND VERIFICATION
Any information in a report must be verified and completely
accurate. It is a basic principle of journalism. This requires in all
circumstances, and particularly during an election period, a very large
professional rigor. The journalist must seek the truth and report more
comprehensively as possible in exercising his critical spirit which requires
checking everything orderly. To be considered reliable, information must meet
the following conditions:
a) This information can be transmitted via stories:
· On the work of governmental or civil society
organizations specialized in electoral education.
· Canadian citizens to verify that they have understood
the different aspects of the electoral process and/or to highlight the aspects
on which awareness is still necessary.
The transmission of this information assumes a serious work of
preparation beforehand by the journalist.
III.5. THE ACCURACY AND VERIFICATION
Any information in a report must be verified and completely
accurate. It is a basic principle of journalism. This requires in all
circumstances, and particularly during an election period, a very large
professional rigor. The journalist must seek the truth and report more
comprehensively as possible in exercising his critical spirit which requires
checking everything methodically. To be considered reliable, information must
meet the following conditions:
a) Information based on verified facts
· If ensure that information is not made, false or
misleading. Manipulation, misinformation and spreading rumors are common
practices in election period. Never assume that the information given is true.
It must always be checked cutting it with other sources.
If in doubt, preferably remain cautious and refrain. Never use
conditional which is the negation of a fact.
· The accuracy requirement applies to all the elements of
the story: the facts, dates, places, quotes, etc. A gross error on only basic
information may call into question the reliability of a story in the eyes of
the public.
· If the journalist travels account, or if it is informed
by the candidate concerned, that information he used is inaccurate, it must
correct it quickly and in the same conditions as those of its dissemination.
(b) information whose origin is known
· Mention sources as much as possible. Simply answer the
question: "Who speaks?" and indicate the name and title of the person
(candidate, party leader, militant associations' responsible for or ordinary
citizen) at the origin of the hearsay information.
· An electoral story built solely on anonymous sources is
considered as a suspect and unreliable. It is prohibited in all cases.
· Always ask the reasons for which a person seeks
anonymity, in particular whenever there is a new character delicate or likely
to affect the reputation of a person, a candidate or a party. With relevance to
evaluate his reasons. If they appear to be legitimate (example: the safety of
the informant may be endangered), it is necessary to take the in - training
into account. But the journalist must get confirmation from other independent
sources before using it. Protect a source must never lead to report rumors or
unfounded accusations.
b) accurate and relativized information
· Be specific. If the journalist covers a rally, should
describe the place, the Organization, topics covered in the speech and the
reactions of the public.
· The rule of thumb of any information should answer the
questions: who? What? When? Where to? Why?
· The approximation can be a source of distortion of the
facts. For example, if the journalist says or writes "candidate X's speech was
very applauded", this sentence has not the same meaning depending on whether
the public is composed of activists of the candidate or even ordinary citizens
come to learn.
In the first case, the applause was predictable while in the
second case, this may mean that the candidate has convinced of undecided
voters.
· Reliability can never be guaranteed 100%.
An error is still possible. It is therefore necessary, when
the journalist makes a report, to be always much nuanced and never making a
final judgment. Discuss his work with modesty and rigor is the best way not to
commit any errors.
· Maintain its sound or visual recordings including
providing evidence of what is reported.
III.6. THE BALANCE, NEUTRALITY AND HONESTY16(*)
The journalist is accountable programs and discussions between
the parties or candidates so that voters can compare their position. But the
professional reporting of a campaign should never tell voters what the best
choice is. The journalist must leave this task to the editorialists and
commentators.
a) Distinction between facts and comments
The commentary and editorial include obvious marks of
subjectivity, in which a reporter (often a pen recognized by the profession or
the public) offers an analysis or interpretation of the facts which commits
only him or his media. Its function is more to report the facts even though he
remains subject to the standards of accuracy and responsibility but to propose
a reading, sometimes oriented politically.
Any journalist is subject to a duty to search for objectivity.
It can ask questions, present the different points of view and add background
information and elements of context. It must always do so in a constant concern
for balance and neutrality. This implies that it deals with all parties and
candidates in a fair, impartial and neutral.
(c) equal treatment and fairness
The journalist must give the floor evenly to all parties and
candidates.
For example, if the construction of new roads is an issue
raised during the campaign and he decides to devote a story, it must mention
the proposals of all the main parties or candidates in this area. Impartiality
can be done by a search of equal volume given to candidates on campaign
subjects or themes in which every opinion is complemented by others.
Example 1: If the journalist makes the report a gathers - ment
during which a party has presented the outline of his pro-gram, it shall
mention the reactions of its main competitors, as soon as they are
formulated.
Example 2: If a candidate brings an accusation against another
candidate and journalist decides to use this information, should contact the
referred party and include his reaction in his report. If it refuses to any
statement, it should mention it.
b) integrity and neutrality
The journalist must refrain from leave reflected directly or
indirectly its opinions, as much in its reports in its behavior.
· It is important to faithfully observe the direction of
reported statements.
Extracts of remarks made by leaders of parties and candidates
must be reproduced fully in respecting the context in which they were spoken.
If the journalist is not sure of him, it must contact the person for
clarification.
· When a translation is necessary (the candidate
expressed himself in a local language), you have to be extremely rigorous and
careful to not to alter the meaning of the words.
· Information should never be used to make the apology of
a party or candidate.
· The tone of the articles must be neutral. Describe what
distinguishes parties from each other, but without judgment in any form
whatsoever.
· Information should never be used to present a personal
point of view. The journalist has a duty to reserve on the themes he reports
the facts. Its opinion on the subject should not be a part of history or be
mentioned in the report.
· Never carry publicly clothing, badges, stickers or any
other medium conveying acronyms and slogans of a party or a candidate.
· Refrain from expressing any opinion on a party or
candidate during a rally, a survey or an interview.
Not to express his political views in private, preferably in
the most intimate social circle.
Objectivity and honesty the journalist is a citizen whose
personality and consciousness have been forged by its past, its culture, its
beliefs and upbringing. However, it must demonstrate objectivity in its
technical approach and its professional practice. And absence be totally
objective, it must strive to be honest and rigorous.
· Journalist, in the collection, processing and
dissemination of information, must act with the greatest possible objectivity.
It must refuse any subjectivism compared treatments journalistic of the
different candidates and parties.
· The editorial style, layout, and in particular the
choice of photos should not be unfair or biased, which could favor one
candidate rather than another.
· Extracts of remarks, shooting angles, alignment, and
the conditions of release must be objectively, or any the less honest.
· The journalist must, in all circumstances, and
regardless of his own personal beliefs, acting in his soul and conscience with
honesty.
1.5. THE INDEPENDENCE AND PROBITY
The citizens expect from the media that therein accurate and
precise facts. To do this, the journalist must keep its editorial independence
and resist the pressures political, social or financial likely to influence its
rigor in the treatment of the information. It accepts other directives than
those responsible for its drafting, its moral or her personal ethics when
working alone.
c) independence
During an election period, the independence of the journalist
may be threatened in many ways: example 1: the owner of a media is close to a
certain candidate and request to journalists that he uses this
candidate-friendly coverage.
Example 2: the Government calls a public media journalist's
coverage favorable to the ruling party.
Example 3: a journalist working for a private media is subject
to pressures from the authorities for a highly critical inquiry into the
Government.
Journalist must resist as much as possible to these pressures
by invoking both his right to exercise his profession "in good conscience" as
his duty to truth and objectivity to the citizens. If necessary, he can turn to
the associations of national or international journalists with one of the main
responsibilities of this independence.
d) probity
The journalist must also know to stay independent of parties
and candidates in the election. Of course, it is important that he is close to
them. This will help him to better identify their personality and to understand
their program.
But too much collusion can put it in a legal dependency ratio.
Politicians can be clever and seductive. They can sometimes treat the
journalist in "friend" but it should be borne in mind that the reporter is,
ultimately, what a way to use to relay their message and their image favorably
in the opinion. We must therefore avoid any report of "cronyism" and strictly
professional reporting. That is why journalist must:
· Never accept any money, or gift of neither value, nor
privilege to influence his judgment, placing it in a conflict of interest or
undermine its credibility.
· Do not perceive any benefit whatsoever for the
publication or non-publication of information. For example, the journalist
becomes complicit in electoral cheating if he denounces not proven cases
committed by a party in Exchange for a favor.
It is common that political parties propose journalists to
carry them on their gathering places where they their also provide drinks and
food. It should be not to accept these offers if they are open to all. Best is,
resources permitting, to travel alone or to share with fellow transportation
costs. Similarly, it is the medium that employs the journalist who must cover
the costs of accommodation and meals when reporting. The transport arranged by
a party is acceptable only under strict conditions:
· It must be authorized by the Electoral Commission.
· The main parties should be used. If a single practice,
for example, because he is the one to have the financial means, should reject
the offer.
· It should never be alone to benefit from. All media,
all sensitivities, must have been invited under the same conditions. It is
necessary to consult his colleagues to be sure that a large number of them will
be present. If not, should reject the offer.
· The party or candidate must demand nothing in return.
The journalist, and alone, to decide whether to do a story on the event or
gathering to which it has been conveyed. He also is the one to decide the angle
and the contents of his report.17(*)
Whatever the status of its media, the journalist must refuse
categorically any financial proposal of a candidate or a party political.
One of the solutions can be expected in the general budget of
the independent electoral commissions a chapter concerning transport of the
news teams for media that cannot sup - wear their teams travel costs. Instances
regulation, along with the media and candidates touring programs, can then
support the movement.
e) other rules of probity
· The journalist agrees not to use unfair means to get
information (example: record an interview of a candidate without his
permission).
· The journalist shall not pay or does not receive money
in Exchange for information.
· Journalist informed those unfamiliar with the press
that their words may be disseminated, and thus brought to the attention of a
wide audience.
· The journalist shall refrain from any plagiarism and
quote the confreres which it resumed information.
· Journalist sign photos illustrating article, or clearly
refers to their source.
f) social responsibility
Freedom of the press cannot be exercised without liability.
The role of the journalist, who is first a citizen, perhaps, to preserve its
information capacity, to appease the political and institutional crises acute
or conflicts. The journalist is not one citizen like any other in the sense
that his word is expected and heard.
The journalist must always be aware of the consequences,
positive or negative, of information it disseminates. This implies that it uses
in all circumstances, and regardless of the news it covers forms of languages
(words and your) the more neutral and more sober as possible.
This also implies that he always deals with weighting and
essential rigor, topics likely to feed tensions within the population or cause,
to some people, some communities or groups, attitudes of rejection or stigma.
As such, the journalist must:
· Respect the dignity of the human person and the
presumption of innocence. It ensures not to put into question, without credible
and verified information, the reputation and honor of others.
· Respect the privacy and personal data and broadcast
information in this area only if they are necessary to the understanding of an
event or situation of public life.
· Refuse to feed and to amplify a rumor, even if other
media already are the echo.
· To refrain from any speech or incitement to hatred,
violence, destruction, theft, intolerance, racism, the xenophobia and
prejudice.
Journalists do not comply with these rules may be subject to
judicial sanctions. In the most serious cases, such as that of free radio
television des Mille Collines in Rwanda, a radio chain that has advocated
genocide, journalists were found guilty of crimes against humanity and
sentenced by an international tribunal.
What to do when a party or a candidate uses hateful or
defamatory language?
Often, during an election campaign, parties and candidates to
use against the other virulent language and sometimes even insulting. The
spread of rumors and inaccurate allegations is a process that is also commonly
used to weaken his political opponents.
Journalist doesn't often have any other choice but to
broadcast because they are elements of the campaign that can help voters
understand the personality of the candidates. The journalist cannot be held
responsible for hateful or defamatory statements issued by politicians he
resumed and cited in his reporting.
The journalist is nevertheless subject to strict
requirements:
· Transcribe the words ("Word for word") accurately and
clearly assign it to its author.
· Giving the floor to the person by the remarks in order
to balance the story.
· Not make any judgment, neither positive nor negative,
as much on the words men - even on the response of the person. However, the
journalist may involve independent personalities and/or organizations for the
defense of human rights to highlight the risk posed to the community of
politicians using hateful, abusive or defamatory language.
NB: However, the sense of social responsibility command that
the journalist takes into account all the parameters of the context in which it
is located. So in extremely explosive socio-political situations, if the relay
hate may incur unduly serious dangers to individuals, communities or the
Nation, it can, in an ethical option, refrain from amplify such remarks.
However, it can, in other forms of practices such as
editorials or comments, while taking to witness national opinion, draw the
attention of the players political and citizens about the dangers threatening
social peace and social and national divisions-generating derivatives
violent.
IV. THE COVERAGE OF THE ELECTORAL CAMPAIGN
The journalist must empower citizens to understand the
electoral issues. To do this, he must present all parties and candidates by
providing information on their programs (past and present) and their activities
during the election campaign. The journalist must also seek other sources of
information for not only those of the parties depend on.18(*)
Aware of the power of the media on the voters, they often seek
to influence through communication plans designed to restrict critical
journalists and allow a favorable of their messages and broad distribution.
News releases, press conferences and opinion polls are sources of information
that must be handled with prudence and discernment.
Being competent in electoral period cannot be improvised and
requires good preparation. Need to learn about the candidates well before the
start of the official campaign to be ready, when the time comes, ask relevant
questions. They will truly only if they reflect the concerns of voters.
The role of the journalist is therefore also to publicize the
problems citizens are confronted on a daily basis so that applicants are
interested and propose concrete solutions to solve. The journalist must go
every day on the ground but some land imposed to take special care in its
approach to handling information that for his own safety. This is especially
true when the election takes place in a country at war or fragile.
a. THE PREPARATION OF PLAN COVER
Media coverage of election campaigns should be carried out
before the start of the official campaign. The journalist is a vital link as it
will on the ground, covers public meetings, meeting candidates, and takes the
pulse of opinion and reports. His work also depends on its media managers who
have to design a program schedule and organization of drafting specific and
adapted to the electoral period.
To deal with the difficulty to follow only several candidates
during an election campaign, it is advisable, if the drafting includes several
journalists, to apportion their tasks. The preparation of a coverage plan is a
real work team which mobilizes many human ways photographers, cameramen, takers
of sound, editors, graphic editors - and material. The journalist must indeed
share its best practices with colleagues.
b. PROGRAMMING AND PAGING
· The Director of a radio or TV programs should develop
specific program: adversarial debate between candidates, round table including
candidates and a panel of experts or interactive programs allowing different
candidates to present their ideas and answering the questions of the citizens
live.
· In a body of written press, the Director of publication
must de - complete the location and the number of pages reserved for the stands
of free expression ('pages views') of the candidates, readers, experts or
journalists themselves (editorials and commentaries).
c. ORGANIZATION OF WRITING
· Writing conferences are essential during the election
period. This space of Exchange and decision-making consisting of as many
sensitivities as journalists, to maintain pluralism necessary to complete and
balanced coverage throughout the campaign.
· It is recommended to hold a conference of special
preparation before the start of the campaign to set the array of edge of the
cover.
The goal is to ensure complementarity and cohesion of the work
of any drafting. Who will be in charge of what? For example, a reporter can be
assigned to cover a region or a specific theme. Writing can also affect a
journalist to cover a single party or candidate. But in this case, it must do
so for each of the main parties and candidates for the sake of balance and
impartiality.
· All media do not have the same resources. When the
numbers are reduced, each must be versatile. But the consultation and dialogue
are essential and must be daily.
d. PREPARATION OF JOURNALIST
· Gather a maximum of information on parties and
candidates: structures, operation, sources of financing, geographical location,
political weight national and/or local, current alliances the and passed key
campaign themes, results in previous polls, etc.
· Identify and establish privileged relations with the
spokesperson of each party or a person occupying an important function in the
organization chart or the organization of their campaign.
· The objective is to be able to contact them to quickly
get information (example: date, time and place of a public meeting), to arrange
an interview with a candidate or to get reactions to hot on a particular event
of the campaign.
· A list of the major issues of the campaign and the
issues that voters want to see treated by candidates and parties.
· Establish a list of experts to consult to have comments
on the campaign. If you are a journalist in a national media, build up a
network of local informants.
· Check the validity of his press card and learn about
the accreditation or mission orders that eventually will be required to cover
the campaign.
· Check with the regulatory body that on any specific
rules to be applied by the media during the election period.
e. ELECTION DISCOURSE PROCESSING
Parties and candidates know that voters tend to believe what
they see and hear in the media. They therefore seek to influence the
journalists in order to receive a favorable media treatment.
Their most common communication tool is release. Sent directly
to editors or distributed at a press conference, he is drafted with the type of
phrases that media need: short and percussive sentences that summarize the
essence of the message and which are likely to be taken up fully. The goal is
to reduce the possibilities of criticism and contradictions and thus limit the
investigative journalists work.
With the advent of television, in as long as main mass media,
candidates have also more and more often use political marketing techniques
that teach them to play of seduction, to control their movements, to treat
their appearance and fabric events intended to soften the voters instead to
present in detail the content of their program.
The following recommendations can allow journalists to avoid
some pitfalls:
· Not just resume the information provided by a party or
candidate but trying to explain the issues.
· Do not transcribe, even paraphrasing them, news and
programs. Compare them with what the candidates did responsibilities and the
positions they have already occupied or with the commitments they have made
during previous campaigns. Involve experts to assess the adequacy of their
proposals to the needs of the country or of the community and to highlight any
contradictions and conflicts of interest.
· Always put quotation marks and/or always attributed to
their authors used a press release or a press conference phrases.19(*)
· Be proactive during press conferences. Not just to
listen. Ask for explanations, clarifications, examples, figures,
justification.
· Do not rely on the statistics provided by a party on
the number of people who participated in a rally. Compare them with other
sources: journalists, the inhabitants of the district, security forces or any
other person present on the premises.
· Learn to recognize the events produced by the
candidates to get into value. Attentive to the attitude of the people - must be
present during a visit of a candidate in a school, a hospital or a company. His
speech provoked reactions? Were always positive? Visited people asked
questions? They appeared to be spontaneous? Should remain on the premises after
the departure of the candidate to try to learn more.
· Check that the message conveyed well matches the
beliefs of the candidate. For example, if a candidate goes into a school to say
that it has always considered education as a priority, look if it has already
been on the initiative of projects in this area.
· Clearly distinguish the official activities of
officials - mental activities as a candidate or a party member.
V. THE CITIZEN JOURNALISM
During an election period, parties and candidates are still
trying to impose their agenda on media to highlight the strong points of their
program and ignore the aspects that are less. A campaign can thus Miss issues
the most important faced by a country. The journalist must therefore identify
and publicize these problems to force parties and candidates to discuss and
explain to voters the solutions that they rely to make.
The use of experts, academics and civil society officials can
help the journalist to identify the major issues which should be addressed
during the campaign in all areas: economy, governance, planning, health,
education, justice, foreign policy, human rights, etc.
But the journalist must also, and above all, interested in the
lives of the citizens to know, understand and relay their concerns. Some press
organs as well realize thematic surveys, indicating the issues that are most
interested the electorate. Others have panels involving citizens, district
heads and associative leaders - to better target the needs of individuals and
communities. One of the simplest ways still to go into the field to meet the
population.
Different techniques allow the journalist to place the
concerns of the citizens at the heart of the election debate:
· Telling individual stories to illustrate the importance
and magnitude of the major issues of the campaign or to focus on the
consequences of the solutions proposed by each candidate. In addition, the
journalist increases its chances of attracting the attention of parties on a
theme that has not yet been addressed during the campaign if he knows "humanize
it" the story alive and detailed the problems posed to a person or a
community.
· Make reports on the themes that citizens report
themselves and they are facing on a daily basis: load shedding of electricity,
access to drinking water, bad roads, increase of the fuel prices, lack of
teachers in schools, lack of hospitals in a region, etc. It is through the
stories of the journalist that these problems have a chance to be better taken
into account by the parties and candidates.
· Make every effort. Whether or not the journalist is
reporting, it is always useful to interview the people he meets on what is
happening in the streets, bars, cafes, markets, office, Garden, family, etc.,
which are public spaces discussing vital citizens problems. A conversation
heard for example in a grocery store or a mail queue, can help the reporter to
take the pulse of opinion and be the starting point of a story.
· Also give the floor to the representatives of
minorities, trade unions, and professional groups, associations of women or
human rights. They represent collective interests which the views and claims
must be relayed by the media.
VI. THE ELECTION INTERVIEW
The interview of candidates or party leaders is a key moment
of the coverage of the electoral campaign. It allows the journalist to go in
detail programs and better identify the personalities. In between - views of a
politician is a difficult art which requires a sense of human relationships, a
strong capacity for discernment and good preparation. Being well informed and
prepared allows the journalist to ask relevant questions and to stay much
focused during the interview.
a. PREPARE THE INTERVIEW TO DOCUMENT
· Gather large number of possible information about the
person encountered. Do some research on his route? Hence - it? She said,
written or done before? What are its sources of funding? How is it perceived by
the community? What do think of it his friends and his political opponents?
b. PREPARING QUESTIONS
· Prepare a list of questions with the order of the
topics and the approximate time to devote to each. It is possible of be in de -
stain during maintenance to bounce on a discourse of the interview but it is
safer to have a canvas of questions ready.
· Prioritizing its questions in descending order of
interest. If the time of the interview is shorter than initially expected,
essentially will be so touched.
· Prepare brief, simple and targeted questions. If a
question is too long, too complicated and too general, a skillful politician
will easily take control of the interview and will respond only to a part (the
one that fixes it) of the item.
· Types of question
· What concrete measures will be taken to solve the
country's problems? What measures will be applied as a priority? With what
means? What the party or candidate different from others? In the event of
victory, political alliances will be concluded? If so, with whom and why?
· If there is an elected outgoing and/or belonging to the
majority party, ask it on its balance sheet and/or pro-masses not held by his
party.20(*)
· For a candidate in a local election, the questionnaire
should take into account the specific problems of the communities of the
regions affected by the elections.
· Establish its questions on the basis of the concerns
expressed by the citizens during the reporting for specific answers to concrete
problems.
c. CONDUCT THE INTERVIEW RECORD THE
INTERVIEW
· Requested permission to record the maintenance with a
wizard or single. If the interlocutor has reservations, explain that this keeps
a faithful reproduction of his words (and thus not to distort his words). The
recording you can also focus on the responses of the interlocutor and think at
the same time at the turn of the maintenance.
· If the interview is not registered, the journalist
cannot rely on his memory and his notes. It is therefore important to quickly
write the major elements. To do this, it is best to use abbreviations and
re-read his notes immediately after the interview.
d. FOCUS THE SEMI-DIRECTIVE INTERVIEW
· Alternate issues open wide field (inducing detailed
answers and explanations), semi-open questions (requiring short and precise
responses) and closed-ended questions which cannot be answered by an
affirmation or negation.
· Pose additional questions or the same questions in
other forms for more information. Request for clarification and examples.
· Being very attentive to responses. Should be able to
resume a word or an idea to fly to evolve maintenance with spontaneous
questions.
e. MAINTAIN CONTROL OF THE INTERVIEW
· The journalist is in principle that directs the
interview. It must never lose control. A smart politician can initiate a start
to answering a question and then ask another question to which there want to
respond. Example: "Yes, actually... but there is a question to which it seems
to me important to answer...". ». We have to let it finish or interrupt
politely if he talks too much, then rest his question until you get a real
answer.
· Being opinionated but remain courteous and polite
regardless of the attitude of the interlocutor. Also be aware of his physical
attitude, it can have an impact on the conduct of the interview. How the
journalist is positioned relative to the caller (the ideal is to be facing
him)?
f. USE INTERVIEW RESPECT THE MEANING OF THE WORDS OF
THE INTERVIEW
· The problem does not arise if the interview is
published or broadcast in its entirety. It arises however if the journalist
published or only brings that excerpts, it's actually a guided interview or if
it uses some elements of the interview to feed a story.
In these cases, the journalist must, when rewriting or
editing, make a selection reflecting as faithfully as possible the comments
made during the interview. If in doubt, do not hesitate to contact the person
for him ask clarifications and details.
· If the interview is used to write an article, the
journalist must get down to work immediately after the talks, bringing together
ideas and drafting a plan or a draft of article. The notes taken during the
interview will be used also to complete the registration (if it exists), to
raise or check a citation.
VII. THE OPINION POLLS
There are two types of opinion polls in election period: the
thematic surveys, which measure the aspirations of citizens on election issues,
and popularity polls, which indicate voting intentions. Parties and candidates
can order themselves to measure the impact of their campaign; put their program
or their image in line with the wishes of the voters.21(*)
Polls are a source of information to not be disregarded but
they must be approached with caution. It is essential that the journalist
studied closely before deciding to use them. Indeed, polls are of very uneven
quality and some can be funded and designed to manipulate opinion and the
media.
Polls have limited informational value because they are based
on the study of a sample found 'representative '. However this technique poses
difficulties in some areas such as the rural areas of sub-Saharan Africa where
language and illiteracy can act as a barrier for pollsters.
Polls can influence, and even distort the democratic game:
doubts are regularly expressed about the impact that a survey can have on the
electoral behavior: the effect of 'follow-my-leader' (vote for the candidate at
the top) to the effect of "revolt" (vote for the loser announced candidate),
everything is possible.
A survey can be used for illegitimate purposes at the expense
of democracy. This risk is particularly high in the countries in democratic
transition where the practice of polls is rarely regulated by a legal
framework. Unscrupulous institutes can use a biased methodology (limited
sampling regions, questions to obtain certain types of responses, etc.) for
carrying out surveys with results consistent with the interests of their
client. Examples:
· A political party in power will order a survey measure
to show that the population is satisfied with its Government balance sheet.
· A candidate at the presidential election is going to
order an aggressive survey to damage the image of his opponents.
· A private interest group commands a thematic survey to
impose on parties and candidates a certain economic program.
· An opposition party denouncing electoral fraud controls
a survey to demonstrate that he had won the elections.
· It is therefore recommended to the journalist:
· Have only resorted to polls institutes working
according to strict and transparent procedures.
· Operate the polls with extreme caution.
· Never make the backbone of its coverage.
· Questions to ask about a survey
· The poll deserves to be brought to the attention of the
public?
· Are the results of the survey different from other
polls?
· Who paid for the poll and what Agency realized it?
· What is the sample of interviewees? How were they
selected?
· When and how was the survey conducted?
· What were the questions asked? Are the results based on
the answers or some only?
· Information to indicate when a survey is brought to the
attention of the public
· The name of the political party, the organization or
the person who commissioned the survey. The name of the organization conducting
the survey.
· The number of respondents and the margin of error for
the survey.
· The date or period during which the survey was
conducted.
VIII. THE ELECTIONS IN THE ZONE OF CONFLICT
COVERAGE
It happens in open crisis countries organize elections. If
there is a conflict between Government forces in rebellion movements, there are
generally three cases:
· The opposition movement wants to overthrow the
Government in place and calls the entire population of the country did not
participate in the poll so that the Government that he fought is not
legitimized by the ballot box.
· The movement seeks independence or autonomy from a part
of the territory and asked the inhabitants of this region to boycott the
election to support his cause.
· Government forces and opposition forces signed a
ceasefire but they have conditioned the signing of a final peace agreement for
the conduct of a free and fair election on the
whole of the territory or part of the territory which is the
cause of the conflict.
Media coverage of an election taking place in these contexts
is a very complex exercise and has many dangers for the journalist. This means
that it is particularly rigorous in the application of the standards of
professional ethics (accuracy, impartiality, responsibility, etc.) and that it
meets a number of safety rules when it is reporting on the ground.
a. PRUDENCE, NEUTRALITY AND BALANCE
· Be extremely careful in processing information and
sources because the risk of manipulation is very high: the 'art of
disinformation' part of the 'art of war '.
· Observe strict neutrality. Therefore, the journalist
can best fulfill its duty and to better ensure its own security.
· Be especially attentive to the balance of his
reporting. For example, if a report on the participation of the population in
elections in a region where the opposition has asked residents not to vote, can
build his narrative on the basis of four testimonies:
· A person who went to the polls by conviction.
· A person who is not gone for fear of reprisals from the
authorities.
· A person who has not voted to support the cause of
opponents.
· A person who remained her home for fear of violence
around polling stations.
· Safety rules
· Always carry his pieces of identity, press cards,
accreditations, passes and other necessary paperwork.
· Never carry weapons, objects or clothing that might
cause confusion (mesh, khaki-colored jacket, leather boots, sister, etc.).
· Never travel alone. Move with colleagues or members of
NGOs but not circulate with candidates or politicians.
· Study carefully its route to avoid combat zones and
regularly give its location to its editor, a friend or a member of his
family.
· Do not move the night and check the hours of
curfews.
· When the cover of a political meeting or an important
gathering, identify places and identify areas where shelter in case of
violence.
· If problems arise, do not run because this increases
the risk to be taken for target. Do not cross a confrontation directly from one
side to the other.
IX. THE ELECTION COVERAGE IN SENSITIVE
CONTEXTS
The media can be a true instrument for consolidating peace and
democracy or play a significant role in triggering conflict by fanning, by the
rumor and propaganda, the mistrust and hatred between people or communities. It
also happens that a less professionalized press derives without realizing it to
inappropriate language.
The election campaign is a timing of this kind of misbehavior
insofar as political debates can easily swerve in violent verbal jousts. The
risks are especially great when the election takes place in countries emerging
from conflict where the voting takes place in an atmosphere of tension or
latent crisis. A referendum can exacerbate divisions or transpose the
grievances of war from the battlefield to the political arena.
Learn and understand the context if the journalist is central
in the enlargement and the deepening of democratic processes and peace, its
role is crucial in sensitive contexts.
Indeed, the journalist must develop a keen sense of
observation, analysis that allows us to understand the complexity of the
socio-political situation and electoral ballot issues. It must do everything to
avoid feeding the crisis and to instead try to appease him.
Happening, there again, by a very scrupulous respect for the
rules of accuracy, verification, impartiality, neutrality and probity in the
collection and processing of information. It also implies a specific
preparation work and a very good knowledge of the possible tensions that could
arise during the electoral process.22(*)
It is essential to ask the following questions:
· What were the players, motivations, and issues of the
conflict or crisis? Why, what and who helped to put an end to? If an agreement
has been signed, the journalist must know the general structure and the main
points.
· In the case of a crisis or a conflict with a component
ethnic or community, the journalist must have substantial knowledge of the
sociological realities of each community and the way in which each of them has
been affected by crisis or conflict.
This documentation is essential because it will allow the
journalist to identify the facts and the speeches that can generate new
derivatives, and consequently a role monitoring and alert. It can do so, for
example, by involving independent personalities and organizations of civil
society to remind parties and candidates their commitments and the content of
the texts that they eventually signed.
9.1 ADVICE
· Reports focus on the major challenges of society out of
the issues fuelling the crisis or conflict. This can be the access to drinking
water, health, education, etc. The objective is to contribute to restore
national cohesion by demonstrating to citizens that they have common problems
apart from any ethnic, community or religious affiliation.
· Give voice to citizens through topics and appropriate
formats. This can be, for example, on-line discussions and interactive programs
in which listeners are invited to speak. Be careful, however, that these free
forums become not the «defouloirs» conveying aggressive and
inflammatory remarks.
· Be yourself especially attentive to the language used
in the reports. The language must be factual, balanced and neutral.
9.2 THAT MUST GUARANTEE A PROFESSIONAL
JOURNALISM?
9.2.1 PRECISION
The accuracy of the information is a principle fundamental of
professional journalism. Any information in a report must be completely
accurate as the names of the candidates, their declarations, the precise
numbers and descriptions of people, places and events. Candidates and voters
can sometimes become emotional during the election campaign; their words must
be reported with a lot of precaution in order to reveal the true content while
trying to explain the context without exaggeration of the partial truths.
In this business, every journalist is still trying to be the
first to get the information. But what is most important, it is the truth of
the latter. Voters declare nothing to journalists if they are likely to have
their distorted words or if things are not properly reported.
9.2.2 IMPARTIALITY
All journalism codes emphasize the importance of impartiality
and objectivity in the profession. To ensure impartiality, the journalist must
make balanced reports. To make it balanced, the report must include the views
of both sides. For example, when a candidate utters a charge or a promise in
his election speech, the professional journalist should introduce the reaction
of the other candidates to ensure the objectivity of his report.
To introduce other points of view removes any suspicion of
bias or favoritism. However, a balanced reporting must be fair. The report may
highlight one candidate instead of another from a current event any because of
what it says or does compared to this event.
In other events, it is important to highlight other candidates
to ensure balance and fairness. It is true that it is difficult to ensure
balance and fairness in every story, but it is an essential principle of
professionalism in journalism. There are always at least two points of view for
each topic.
Even if he works for a media that displays the support of a
political party, the professional journalist will always try to ensure the
objectivity and balance of his report. And even if he worked in the public
service, it is imperative that its reports introduce information on opposition
parties. This is called 'balance '. This balance must be fair as much as
possible. Further, private and public media must keep separate opinions and
political commentary news.
Many voters don't reveal their views to journalists that they
suspect to represent the ideas of a single political party. Voters who are wary
of journalists express only the views that the journalist would like to hear
without really revealing their opinions.
We can define "impartiality" otherwise.
Impartiality requires that the professional journalist is not
affiliated with a group or a political movement. If a journalist is known for
his political activism, his reporting will lose their credibility even if they
are fair and balanced. The journalist should never take part in an election
campaign for that matter and must never offer or receive money or gifts from
political parties.
9.2.3 RESPONSIBILITY
Journalists have enormous responsibilities towards people for
which they make their reports and also people who they broadcast these reports.
Journalists are obliged to protect their sources when required by the
circumstances. People don't reveal any important information as for example
corruption policy, if they have reason to fear that their identity is
unveiled.
It is imperative that journalists are use only integrated
methods to obtain information. Their investigations should follow the
international standards of the profession.
9.2.4 THE MEDIA AS GUARDIANS OF THE
ELECTIONS
The electoral commission could come under pressure from the
Government or the parties with powerful interests in the country. Political
parties could try everything to win the elections. It is also virtually
impossible for the commission to uncover any abuse and average diverted during
the election campaign. However, to ensure that the elections are legitimized by
the people of the country who vote and the people of the world, they must be
necessarily fair and impartial.
For this reason, a reliable press is strictly necessary to
deal with corruption and illegal activities in elections. It is indeed the role
of the media to report problems, to denounce the violations of the laws and to
inform the electorate on the manifestos of the polite - ticks and candidates
parties.
The media are at the service neither of the electoral
commission nor in the service of political parties. They are there to ensure
the smooth running of the elections and to unmask corruption and abuse. The
election commission and parties' politics should be aware of the fact that they
will be strongly criticized by public opinion if they do not end the
violations.23(*)
Journalists are supposed to know the laws election as, for
example, the functioning of the electoral commission and the electoral
process.
Furthermore, it must be that media coverage of political
parties shall be based on the principles of fairness or justice. Does mean that
each party has the right to media coverage, but the scope of coverage should
vary from one party to another depending on the importance of the party in
previous elections and those which are ongoing.
The number of candidates could be a good criterion to give an
idea of the importance of the party. The most important political parties must
receive more media coverage. This practice must be conducted by the media as a
good example of responsible journalism. The electoral commission, moreover,
could require the media to comply with this practice during the election
campaign.
The commission could also ask the media to fairly allocate
free advertising space for each political party.
The public press must allocate advertising space to all
political parties. The press private, however, has a civic responsibility to
the citizens. It must provide equitable or fair reports on all the political
parties according to the rules defined by the electoral commission. It must
also address the election advertising in the same way for all political
parties.
The commission shall disseminate its information to voters in
all media.
Journalists must demonstrate objectivity. Their reports must
be accurate, impartial and reliable.
9.3 WHAT MUST MONITOR THE PRESS?
There are many ways to have elections held in poor conditions
or become corrupted. The following are very important elements to which the
press should pay attention and shall inform voters because its task is to
monitor the elections.
Are the rights of voters the names of the eligible citizens
all on the list of electors? Are all registered to vote? Can voters listen to
and discuss freely issues and election programs of political parties without
fear? Parties threaten voters and election officials and they are forcing the
voters to vote for certain candidates?
Political parties are trying to buy the votes of the voters
with money, gifts or promises of employment? Are voters aware of their role and
the importance of the vote? Are they aware of the choices available? Women and
minorities feel safe during the vote?
The rights of candidates and political parties the parties and
candidates are allowed to stand in the elections? Are candidates representing
minorities, various regions and political opinions allowed to stand in the
elections? Can political parties hold general meetings without difficulties?
The voting rules are applied fairly to all parties?
The police and the army ensure the protection of the parties
when they are campaigning, disseminate information or organize meetings? There
is powerful interests pouring large sums of money to a particular political
party? Are the Parties ready to reveal their sources of funding?
Are the Government officials neutral? They use money or public
resources such as for example cars to serve a political party any? The ruling
party announces new projects in beginning of election campaign? This is not
fair to the opposition parties who cannot use public money in this way.
The electoral process electoral lists are complete? Electors
who are not on the lists may - they take part in the voting simply on
production of a valid identity document?
Are the ballots easily understood by voters who cannot read?
Voters easily understand the voting procedures? Are there enough ballots, of
ballot boxes and officials to monitor the procedure of voting and the counting
of the votes? Are there enough security measures to protect the ballot box
fraud attempts?
Is the electoral commission evidence of impartiality,
independence and transparency? Are there international or independent observers
who observe elections? What do think of the activities of the electoral
commission?
The electoral commission responds quickly to complaints of
media, voters and political parties concerning the violations of the electoral
code? The commission investigates cases of violation of laws and it is trying
to limit? Are those who violate the law punished in one way or another?
Can the media, non-governmental organizations and
international observers ensure the observation of the elections and freely make
reports without fear? State media covered the activities of candidates and
parties in a fair manner? Is media coverage accurate, impartial, reliable and
equitable?
Private media newspapers, radio and television provide
reliable and equitable coverage on elections? Private media give fair
advertising space to all parties?
9.3.1 MEDIA STRATEGIES
Political parties generally use their leaders to give a good
public image. They want voters to react positively to the public image of the
leader. They often rely on specialists to improve public speaking leader, take
care of its appearance and its public behavior, for example, how to behave
kindly toward people and still maintain its quiet in public. Parties also
expose the most photogenic images of the leader in the spaces reserved for the
election campaign to attract the attention of voters.
The parties have understood that voters generally tend to
believe what they see and hear in the media.
For this reason, the parties create what might be called
'soulful events '. These events are intended to present the leader of the party
as a kind person showing it being to visit people in their homes or to embrace
children or engage in Walkabouts. Parties organize to press in which
conferences the leader presents its programs and electoral promises and attack
programs other parties and candidates.
Parties may not wish to see their leader return in a direct
debate with other leaders. Political leaders generally prefer giving interviews
to newspapers or radio stations and television channels that support their
election programs.24(*)
This manipulation of the media represents a real challenge for
journalists. Professional journalists wish leaders pronounce on issues raised
by the community, or well they explain to voters the difference between their
electoral programs and those of other political parties.
Nevertheless, journalists cannot ignore the press conferences
and the 'cutest events' political leaders because other media will broadcast in
a way or another. However, it is important that journalists pose questions to
political leaders rather than let them spread on subjects that adorn their
image.
Nevertheless, journalists must ensure the balance by
introducing in their reports the opinions and comments from political leaders
and voters on a press conference or a speech by a party leader any.
It is difficult to ask questions but the journalist must
always demonstrate courtesy and respect. Do an objective report requires a lot
of time and work but the professional journalist will never forget to introduce
in his report all facets of history.
9.3.2 THINKING AS AN ELECTOR
Walking shoes voters help the journalist to produce stories.
This creates questions to be put to politicians.
For example:
What is the first thing to which the voter believes? Certainly
the security. The voter wants to be reassured that acts of violence will not
occur at polling stations and the vote will remain secret. He also wants to
know where to head to complaints of threats against him.
It is easy to raise these issues in stories collected in local
communities or across the country. Media must inform the electors of the
electoral laws. They also interview the police, the electoral commission or the
voters who have been victims of violence in the previous elections.
The media must know what measures had been taken to deal with
such acts in the current election. How do react officials and politicians in
the event of outbreak of new violence?
Open an investigation? Are they able to put an end to these
acts?
Are they trying to stop?
Voters also want to know the choices about the vote on
candidates put at their disposal during the polling day. What are the names on
the list of electors? Voters have the right to obtain information regarding the
candidates and political parties. They need to compare different parties'
election promises.
An objective reportage showing the different promises of
parties over a specific problem of the community will give choice more
thoughtful voters.
When it starts instead of the elector, should remember one
thing is that the voter wants con - rise to the opinions of its region. The
journalist can ask the same questions to members of the same community. This
method gives an idea about the main concerns of the community.
For example, the journalist can ask the question to voters:
"what is the problem most important you would like that the Government deals
with priority?", or "what do you think of the acts of violence that have marked
these elections? '' These questions can be posed to people in a restaurant or
people crossing a bridge at a time any day or women who are waiting for the bus
at a station.
This method is to know the concerns of the citizens in their
daily lives.
If their responses are similar, this could reflect the opinion
of a greater number of voters and therefore, this could be a hot topic. Even if
the answers are conflicting, this could be the subject of a report. However,
this is only the beginning of a long process.
The journalist must first collect information by asking
candidates what their parties will do to meet the needs and concerns of voters.
This journalism reflects the voice of the voters.
Journalists must also ask candidates what they think of the
most important concerns of voters and must also compare their statements with
those of voters.
Voters must have a prominent place in the election news. It is
imperative that candidates respond to the issues raised by voters.
Is my report on the elections full?
1. Is. this report accurate? The facts and the names are all
correct? Am I convinced of the veracity of the information? I provided
sufficient efforts to confirm the accuracy of the information?
2. Is the report fair and objective? Include all the facts of
the story without giving a particular favor to a party or to a candidate?
3. Is my work responsible journalism? My information had -
they were obtained without corruption or illegal activities? The report
protects t - it its sources and comply with electoral and media laws?
4. The report reflects the voices of the voters? Contain
important information for electors? Communicate the concerns of the voters to
politicians?
5. The report addresses the event in its entirety? The words,
photos, audio-visual sequences reflect the true history of the event?25(*)
6. The report help voters to be better informed about the
elections and thus to make reasonable decisions which serve to best
interests.
7. Are the elections free and fair? There is more information
about the elections should publish?
Today, the media have an important influence on the elections
of a country and also participate in the perception of the regime by foreign
countries.
For the proper conduct of elections, they must be free and
fair.
Freedom of expression must be guaranteed to ensure that
citizens and all political parties express themselves without fear. The media
must be free to communicate to citizens everything that has been said in the
election campaign without being subjected to pressures that might contain the
truth.
Professional journalism is therefore to inform entirely
citizens on important topics and issues and alternatives proposed so that they
can vote consciously.
The elections must be fair. There must be legislation
guaranteeing a secret ballot for all citizens. All applicants must also have
the same rights and the same opportunities to conduct their election campaigns
without interference any. Laws must be applied in a fair manner and each must
respect the results of the poll.
The elections represent a huge challenge for the media. It is
imperative that journalists know - feel the electoral laws. So much more than
their reports devoted to the candidates, parties politics and important topics
must be objective. The media should be the voice of the voters.
The criteria of professional journalism such as accuracy,
objectivity and responsibility must be respected by all journalists. On the
other hand, journalists should be prepared to work for a limited period and
under strained conditions where pressures from Parties with important issues
are possible.
Chapter Four: CONTENET ANALYSIS OF CONGOLESE
NATIONAL TV COVERAGE
In this chapter it will basically analysis question the way in
which the national television to balanced, covered and diffuse the information
involved 11 candidates for the 2011 presidential election. The DRC to organized
elections in 2011 with 11 candidates in the race as follows:
1. Ndeka Abbasi;
2. Biyani intolerance;
3. Kabila Kabange.
4. K.r Madhani;
5. Kamerhe Vital;
6. Oscar Kashala.
7. Kengo wa Dondo;
8. Mbusa Nyamwisi;
9. Nzanga Mobutu.
10. Mukendi Kamana;
11. Tshisekedi Wa Mulumba
1. STUDY OF THE POPULATION
CHACHAT defines the population of study as a set of
individuals covered by the study. The boundaries of this population and its
characteristics are defined according to the objectives of the
investigation.
According to LESELBAU, N. The population covered by the survey
is considered to be "a human set characterized which sought to know opinions,
needs, reactions... It is characterized, -said that it had common
characteristics enabling identification psychological, social individuals of
this group.
As for MUCCHELLI, R, the study population is all persons on
the door investigation and which constitutes a community.
In this regard, our study population, it is composed of 34
national television journalists who have covered elections in 2011. Its
journalists are selected according to their variables.
2. THE STUDY SAMPLE
For YATES, quoted by KALRA ELWA, M. the essential aim of any
process of sample is obtaining a sample which, taking into account its
reproduced limited size, the characteristics of the population, particularly
those affecting the researcher as accurately as possible.
LUHAHI, defines 'sample' as 'a fixed finite population, which
can count the elements with the ability to produce this sample is capable of
representing the parent population in its own characteristics, means having the
nature of items to be treated, the degree of precision to which we want to
achieve.26(*)
As for DE LANDSHEERE, g., 'sample' is considered as "the
choice of a limited number of individuals or events whose observation makes it
possible to draw some general conclusions applicable to the entire population,
within which the choice was made.
From this last definition, our sample consisted of 34
journalists who responded to our survey protocol.
3. DATA COLLECTION AND INVESTIGATION
Because we do not have at our disposal the means to us moved
to field, we have sent our survey to the country, which allowed us to well done
this research. The questions were sent by email box and reproduced for 34
journalists constituting our sample.
The collection data realized on basis of a questionnaire for
34 national television journalists who covered the elections of 2011, compared
with our sample, and for the latter, we have asked oral questions and answers
that have been given to us were rated on a file of responses to interview that
we have selected.
The selection of answers were provided taking into account
people who have expressed their wishes for us to deliver information to our
study.
4. COUNTING OF THE QUESTIONNAIRE
It is worth noting that the counting of our questionnaire has
taken into account the gender variable. This variable we identified variables
such as the age group, level of study, socio-professional category, in
addition, the data of the survey is to-say replies to the questionnaires were
included in the tables, these tables are developed using the expressed
frequency calculations or percentages.
5. ANALYSIS OF DATA
5.1. ANALYSIS OF THE SAMPLE
Table N ° 01: Distribution of the sample
according to the gender variable.
Sex
|
Frequency
|
Percentage
|
Male
|
22
|
64,71
|
Female
|
12
|
36,29
|
Total
|
34
|
100
|
Source: Results of our surveys.
Comment T1: the reading of this table shows
that the 34 respondents, 22 subjects or 64,71% consist of men, while 12 issues,
or 36.29 per cent are female. This can be explained by the fact that women,
through their physical abilities could not withstand the jostling crowds at
meetings. This can also if explained by the fact that at that time, women
journalists from national television had not yet experienced to cover the
elections.
Table N ° 02: Distribution of the sample
according to the age variable.
Sex and age
|
Male
|
Female
|
Frequency
|
Percentage
Total
|
F
|
%
|
F
|
%
|
20 à 25 years
|
3
|
13,63
|
1
|
8,35
|
4
|
11,76
|
25 à 30 years
|
5
|
22,73
|
5
|
41,67
|
10
|
29,41
|
30 à 35 years
|
7
|
31,82
|
4
|
33,33
|
11
|
32,35
|
35 à 40 years
|
4
|
18,19
|
2
|
16,67
|
6
|
17,65
|
40 years or more
|
3
|
13,63
|
00
|
00
|
3
|
8,82
|
Total
|
22
|
100
|
12
|
100
|
34
|
100
|
Source: Results of our surveys.
Comment T2. It is clear that in this table on
34 respondents, 4 topics, or 11.77% were group of age ranging between 20 and 25
years, followed by 10 subjects, either 26,41% who have age ranging between 25
and 30 years of age; followed also by 11 subjects, either 32.35% who were the
age group ranging from 30 to 35 years, followed in 6 subjects continued, 17.65%
who have varying between 35 and 40 years old age group or finally 3 subjects,
8.82% who have varying between 40 years age group or more.
Table N ° 03: Distribution of the sample
according to the level of study.
Sex
Level of study
|
Male
|
Female
|
Total
|
F
|
%
|
F
|
%
|
Frequency
|
Percentage
|
Secondary
|
2
|
16,67
|
1
|
8,33
|
3
|
8,82
|
Colleges and/ universities
|
20
|
74,33
|
11
|
92,67
|
31
|
92,18
|
Total
|
22
|
100
|
12
|
100
|
34
|
100
|
Source: Results of our surveys
Comment T3: The above table shows that the
respondents 34, 31 respondents or 92, 67% have a University or higher level
while 3 issues or 8.33% have a secondary study. This brings us to infer that
media coverage of the presidential elections in 2011 have been ensured by
intellectual journalists.
5.2 ANALYSIS OF DATA.
Table N ° 04: Distribution of responses
to the question related to the jurisdiction.
Sex
|
Frequency
|
Percentage
|
yes
|
23
|
67,65
|
No
|
11
|
33,35
|
Total
|
34
|
100
|
Source: Results of our surveys.
Comment T4: Indicated in this table 23 topics, or 67.65% of
our respondents have asserted have covered elections in 2011 with good quality
material, while 11 subjects 33.35% says have not worked with materials of good
quality for the media coverage of elections in 2011.
With regard to these results, we say that national television
reporters lacked pretext to provide as regards media coverage of elections in
2011, because they had such devices that, digital and digital cameras,
Dictaphones, MP3, digital telephones, etc.
Table N ° 5: Attitude of journalists
from national television during coverage of the 2011 elections.
Answers
|
Frequency
|
Percentage
|
Men and women of media
|
0
|
00
|
Politicians
|
0
|
00
|
Made political
|
27
|
79,41
|
All citizen
|
4
|
11,77
|
Hesitant
|
3
|
10,82
|
Total
|
34
|
100
|
Source: given our investigations.
Comment T5: We read in this table that the majorities of
respondents surveyed journalists 79.41%, shows they had played during the media
coverage of the presidential elections in 2011, the role of men policy, however
4 subjects, 11.77% said that during the reports, they had adopted the attitude
of every citizen elector; then 3 journalists either 10.82% is these are not
pronounced. Aside from 79.41% to 11.77% extends delivered we believe that the
majority of the national television journalists had no summary jurisdiction
comply with the rules of ethics and journalistic ethics and had a position of
accomplice becoming them even to politicians.
Table 6: distribution of the answers to how
to cover the meetings and ceremonies during the campaign period.
Answers
|
Frequency
|
Percentage
|
Coverage on the place of meting
|
12
|
45,30
|
Monitoring
|
2
|
4,65
|
Reporting to the plateau
|
2
|
5,88
|
Emission débat
|
8
|
30,59
|
Interview vedette
|
1
|
2,94
|
micro Player
|
4
|
7,76
|
Tock-show
|
5
|
12,88
|
Total
|
34
|
100
|
Source: Results of our surveys
Comment T6: We read according to the results
in this table the most part journalists covered the companion elections 2011
instead of meeting with 12 subjects, 45.30%, 2 subjects either, 4.65% have made
the cover by monitoring, 2 issues, or 5.88 by reporting on the plateau, 8
subjects or 30, 59% by Emissions debates, 1 subject, or 2.94% by interviews
featured, 5 topics, 2.88% by Tock-show. This may mean that during coverage of
the 2011 presidential elections, many journalists have been reporting on the
place of meeting.
Table 7: Breakdown of answers in relation to
the professional qualities of the journalists who have covered elections in
2011.
Answers
|
Frequency
|
Percentage
|
Honesty
|
-
|
00,00
|
Functionality
|
2
|
4,20
|
exactness
|
1
|
2,94
|
Responsibility
|
2
|
4,35
|
truth
|
1
|
2,86
|
Sincerity
|
1
|
2,16
|
Credibility
|
-
|
-
|
None
|
28
|
86,10
|
Total
|
34
|
100
|
Source: Results of our surveys
Comment T7: this table reading 86.10% of our
respondents say no professional-grade explanation have put into practice in
front of multiple pressures to which they were victims.
Table 8: distribution of answers to the
question, have you been under political pressure to serve the interests of a
candidate?
Answers
|
Frequency
|
percentages
|
yes
|
30
|
90,10%
|
No
|
4
|
10,90%
|
Total
|
34
|
100
|
Source: results of our surveys
Comment T8: the reading of this table it
appears that many of our respondents either 90,10% received political pressure
and the employer to cover only the events of the party in power, and only
10.90% did not receive that kind of pressure. This is to say that the
journalists had their hands tied during this period.
Table 9: distribution of answers to the
question, how have you divided your reports for the 11 candidates:
N°
|
Candidats
|
Report
|
Frequency
|
Percentages
|
1
|
Andeka Djamba
|
-
|
-
|
00,00%
|
2
|
Bombole Intole
|
-
|
-
|
00,00%
|
3
|
Kabila Kabange
|
105
|
22
|
74,12%
|
4
|
Kasese Malela
|
-
|
-
|
00,00%
|
5
|
Kamerhe Vital
|
10
|
3
|
7,24%
|
6
|
Oscor Kashala
|
3
|
1
|
2,10%
|
7
|
Kengo wa Dondo
|
5
|
2
|
4,00%
|
8
|
Mbusa Nyamwisi
|
2
|
1
|
2,10%
|
9
|
Nzanga Mobutu
|
3
|
2
|
4,00%
|
10
|
Mukendi Kamana
|
-
|
-
|
00,00%
|
11
|
Tshisekedi Wa Mulumba
|
20
|
3
|
7,24%
|
Total
|
11
|
148
|
34
|
100
|
Source: results of our surveys
Comment T9: this table reading we note once again more than
the 3 candidate and current president has been the most privileged of the
reporters from the national television with 105 stories, or 74,12% thus making
a real difference to the other candidates yet with the same right of access to
television services national, with only 26% for the rest of the candidates.
Table No. 10: distribution of the answer
to the question was you satisfied with the work you produced during the
elections in 2011 as a professional journalist and serving on national
television?
Answers
|
Frequency
|
Percentage
|
Yes
|
10
|
35,14%
|
No
|
24
|
65,86%
|
Total
|
34
|
100
|
Source: results of our surveys
Comment T10: as you may have noticed in this survey 24 table
either 65.86% was not satisfied with their work during this period, they say
have been taken hostage by pressures of any kind, while 10 respondents, or 35,
14% were satisfied with their work.
Table N ° 11: distribution of the answers to the question
you physically threatened when travelling in places of the campaigns of the
candidates.
Answers
|
Frequency
|
Percentage
|
yes
|
19
|
54,25%
|
No
|
15
|
46,75%
|
Total
|
34
|
100
|
Source: results of our surveys
Comment 11: How can see from this chart, 19
respondents or 54.25% have been threatened physically by some supporters of
political parties, while 46.75 per cent, or 15 subjects claim to have not been
threatened during their travels.
2nd part of the results
Category B: the results according to the distribution
of airtime on national television of 11 candidates.
Figure 1: importance of coverage given to
each candidate on the air in %
Source: results of our surveys
Interpretation: In this figure on the importance given to each
candidate, it is clear that candidate 3 was the most protected by the
authorities of the national television; they explain that the fact that they
received them also orders.
1. Ndeka Abbasi;
2. Biyani intolerance;
3. Kabila Kabange.( actual president)
4. K.r Madhani;
5. Kamerhe Vital;
6. Oscar Kashala.
7. Kengo wa Dondo;
8. Mbusa Nyamwisi;
9. Nzanga Mobutu.
10. Mukendi Kamana;
11. Tshisekedi Wa Mulumba
Figure 2: Time's cover on land granted to
candidates during the election campaign
Source: results of our surveys
Interpretation: in this graphic of the
results of our investigations it is demonstrated that during the election
campaign from 2011 throughout the country with national television candidate
N°3
Airtime granted to candidates during the period from Friday 4 to
Friday, November 26, 2011 on the public channel
|
N°
|
Candidats
|
Times
|
01
|
Joseph kabila kabange
|
15h50'48''
|
02
|
Léon kengo wa Dondo
|
1h26'34''
|
03
|
Vital Kamerhe lwa Kanyingi
|
1h51'13''
|
04
|
Etienne Tshisekedi wa Mulumba
|
1h28'19''
|
05
|
François-Joseph Nzanga Mobutu
|
1h46'02''
|
06
|
François-Nicephore Kakese Malela
|
40'35''
|
07
|
Adam Bombole Intole
|
52''
|
08
|
Andeka Djamba
|
20'05''
|
Source: results of our surveys
Interpretation: it is in this table of time
allocated to each candidate in the presentation of its plans for the
development of the country on national television. As you notice only 8
candidates on the 11 had this time with a non-equitable sharing.
Figure 3: the time of the advertising spots
broadcast by candidate
Source: results of our surveys
Figure 4: distribution of airtime for the meetings and
gathering policy
Chapter Five: SUMMARY, CONCLUSIONS AND
RECOMMENDATION
5.1. SUMMARY
Searching for a good understanding on media coverage during
the presidential elections in 2011 by national television has been the
leitmotif of this work. We started from the idea that the Organization of the
second free democratic and transparent elections has left footprints in the
recent political history of the Democratic Republic of Congo.
Also, today it is important that all the skills related to the
provision by the national television have known more often as weak points. This
work of mass communication is obviously the work of journalists.
Today, the media have an important influence on the elections
of a country and also participate in the perception of the regime by foreign
countries.
For the proper conduct of elections, they must be free and
fair.
Freedom of expression must be guaranteed to ensure that
citizens and all political parties express themselves without fear. The media
must be free to communicate to citizens everything that has been said in the
election campaign without being subjected to pressures that might contain the
truth. Professional journalism has for mission to fully inform citizens about
the problems and issues and alternatives proposed so that they can vote
consciously.
The elections must be fair. There must be legislation
guaranteeing a secret ballot for all citizens. All applicants must also have
the same rights and the same opportunities to conduct their election campaigns
without interference any. Laws must be applied in a fair manner and each must
respect the results of the poll.
The elections represent a huge challenge for the media. It is
imperative that journalists are aware of the electoral laws. As their coverage
of the candidates, political parties and important topics must be objective.
The media should be the voice of the voters.
The criteria of professional journalism such as accuracy,
objectivity and responsibility must be respected by all journalists. On the
other hand, journalists should be prepared to work for a limited period and
under strained conditions where pressures from Parties with important issues
are possible.
The media play a crucial role in the construction of public
space and thus in the establishment of conditions conducive to democratic
expression, the proper functioning of public institutions and political bodies.
In all countries, but even in a country emerging from a civil crisis as
profound as that experienced by the Democratic Republic of Congo, media have a
direct responsibility and especially TV so-called national democratic
processes.
No democracy without public space, not public space without
reliable, pluralistic information, shared by all. This is the reason why it is
essential to raise awareness the media responsibilities, and the rules that it
imposes on them, on ethics, ethical and professional.
But this media accountability should be placed directly into
the hands of policy makers, who are, in all countries of the world, quick to
consider the media as tools in the service of their own partisan interests, not
as independent bodies for the expression of pluralism. Hence the need for
autonomous control over Government, but recognized structures in its legitimacy
by all the actors of public life.
From this point of view, it is important to emphasize to at
the outset the importance of the resolutions taken at Sun city by delegates to
the Inter Congolese Dialogue aimed at the establishment of an independent
institution responsible for regulating the media in the transitional
Constitution is fundamental for the congolese media it is indeed to create the
conditions that ensure both the freedom of the media the right of all citizens
to a pluralistic and reliable information the neutrality of public media, in
particular during an election period.
5.2 CONCLUSION
The 2011 elections have constituted for the Congolese
population, a historic moment because since 46 years of accession of our
country to international and national sovereignty, it is only the second time
that the DRC organized multiparty elections after 2006.
To help the population to take well-founded decisions, it is
necessary to have a free press. Not only the media must be free, but they must
be serious and trustworthy. They must be able to freely express different
points of view. Whatever the place, journalists have established principles and
criteria to provide credible information. Unfortunately, there are still
journalists who are obliged to work under duress imposed by Governments or
powerful interests that interfere in the professionalism.
Therefore, advertising materials of the campaign, radio,
Television and the print media, the internet, debates and interviews that give
applicants the opportunity to present their programs to public voters must be
covered by journalists filling profile recommended to the trade. Media
reporting will take the form of information, including the importance of
electoral participation by explaining with honesty and responsibility to the
public, how, where and when to place the vote.
To this end, the work of a media and more specifically in the
audio-visual sector in front of a multitude of candidates, acquires for most
cases, a more sensitive as the elections or vote assumes a struggle of interest
differ between the need of power and the expectations of the population, a
clash of democratic values, procedures and actions which tend to eliminate the
opponent and the only mediator remains the journalist.
However, during the election coverage, looking for the facts,
likely stories to provide clarification on the voting procedures, contact with
information sources electoral namely candidates requires a celebrity,
professionalism proved with respect to harvesting and treatment information as
well as, according to the ethics of the profession, a responsibility on the
part of the journalist and the media in general which was not the case of the
work of the national television of the DRC during the elections of 2011.
The fundamental question we are asked we to assume that in a
situation or election period, the media tend, to ensure effective coverage of
political campaign operations that occur, load the journalists the best
scientifically and technically informed on electoral issues.
This we brought confirmed our hypothesis for the cover of the
2011 elections, National Congolese television station of Kinshasa has not
mobilized means suitable and adequate professional to encourage the pursuit of
excellence that it searches through the dissemination of quality information,
that is true, objective, and timely. It more served power in place and
candidates at any level outgoing so its editorial line first serve every
Congolese citizen regardless of its political colors, its origins and
religion.
After our investigation it turns out that some political
pressures did not on national television to be in the center of the elections.
These journalists have worked hands tied not practical allowing them a
professional journalist respecting ethics and professional ethics.
By conducting this study, concern major and objective
fundamental, was the one to help any journalist to understand what we mean by
the 'social responsibility' in his profession.
We have desired contributed through this research by putting
at the disposal of the men of the media a tool that can serve them in the
coverage of elections.
Our concern this from or even the rate of conflicts related to
the elections through the work of journalists can significantly decrease in
Africa and particularly in the DRC after the publication of this research.
We recognize that everything was said in this research and
scientific study is not perfect and complete, but at least we have sought the
truth and we recognize provided considerable efforts to make us understand.
This study was divided into five chapters, the first spoke of
the introduction, the second chapter on the literature review, the third on the
role of the media during the election period, the fourth on the analysis of
given and interpretation of results, and the fifth on the conclusion.
5.3 RECOMMADATION
(a) A National television
The Act organic No. 11/001 of January 10, 2011, on the
composition, powers and functions of the Superior Council of audiovisual and
Communication also establishes the powers of public bodies. This reference has
these powers we suggest the following:
· National television must remain neutral, impartial and
non-discriminatory,.
· national television must give access to any Congolese
citizen has its services without discrimination of races, or religions, or even
political colors,
· For the next elections the right to broadcast on the
antennae of the events of the various candidates must be fair.
(b) to journalists
· Those journalist reporters are responsible and can be
ethics and ethics when it comes to media coverage.
· journalists to be impartial when it comes to organize
broadcasts debate or they must question the different candidates of political
parties,
· do not fall into political manipulation to ultimately
divert the value information;
· Do not fall into the pressure from the authorities'
policy to not disseminate the true information and demonstrate honesty.
(c) political men
· Journalism is a liberal profession, it must be
practiced without any political interference,
· Politicians must not manage the work of journalists to
meet their interests.
References
1. BOOKS
CAYROL, R., The media, print, radio and
television, Paris, PUF, 1973, p 75
BALLE, F, media corporations, radio and
television, telecommunications
BERTRAND, CJ. Matias, introduction to the
press, radio and television, 2nd edition ellipse, 1999.
CAYROL, R., the media, print, radio
television, Paris, PUF, 1973
CAMMACK, DIANA, Election Reporting: a
Practical Guide to media monitoring, London: Article 19, 1988. CARVE, RICHARD.
Media and Election Index, Administration and Cost of Elections (ACE) Project.
http://www.aceproject.org, 2001.
Chirambo, Kondwani and Mccullum, Hugh,
Reporting Elections in Southern Africa: A Media Handbook. Windhoek, Namibie :
le programme de démocratie durable SARDC. Université de Namibie,
Département d'études d'information et de communication, 2000.
Clark, Roy Peter and Cole C. Campbell. The
Values and Craft of American Journalism: Essays from the Poynter Institute.
Gainesville, FL: University Press of Florida, 2005.
DERVILLE, G., the power of media, Paris, PUF,
1997
Kim Kierano, Voters queue in front of a
polling station in Phnom Penh, Cambodia, on day national vote on July 27
NGOMA BINDA, political
participation, ethical, for a culture of peace, democracy and good governance,
Kinshasa, ITEP, 2005
POTER, IAN, elections training curriculum,
Impacts media, and election program, Cambotra, 2003.
RENARD, Y, practice of journalism in a
conflict zone, condensed course of Journalism Radio Okapi 2003.
HABERMAS, J., Theory and Practice 2, the
collection policy, Paris, payol 1975
HOWARD, ROSS, Report on the Proceedings:
Media and Elections Roundtable. Vancouver: IMPACS Institute for Media, Policy
and Civil Society, Vancouver, 2001.
MARTHOZ, JEAN PAUL. Election Reporting, A
Media for Democracy Handbook. London: international Federation of Journalists,
2000. POTER, IAN. Elections
POTER, IAN. Elections Training Curriculum:
IMPACS Media and Elections Program Cambodia 2003. Phnom Penh : Institute for
Media, Policy, and Civil Society, 2003.
SCHNELLINGER, LISA. Free & Fair: A
Journalist's Guide to Improved Election Reporting in Emerging Democracies.
Washington, DC: International Centre for Journalists, Washington, 2001
Hachten, William A. Troubles of Journalism: A
Critical Look at What's Right and Wrong with the Press. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence
Erlbaum Associates, 3ed edition, 2004.
Hamilton, James T. All the News That's Fit to
Sell: How the Market Transforms Information into News. Princeton, NJ: Princeton
University Press, 2003.
Overholser, Geneva and Kathleen Hall
Jamieson. The Press. New York, NY: Oxford University Press, 2005.
Sloan, W. David et Lisa Mullikin Parcell .
American Journalism: History, Principles, Practices. Je? erson, NC : McFarland
& Company, 2002.
KABONGO KALALA KANDA Isidore. Transforming
the radio and state television into of interest services public, Audit of the
RTNC, January 6, 2006
2. Press articles
BBC Producer's Guidelines.
http://www.bbc.co.uk/info/editorial/prodgl/contents.htm
Journalism Ethics: The New Debate. Washington: International
Center for Journalists, 1998.
Training Curriculum: IMPACS Media and Elections Program
Cambodia 2003. Phnom Penh : Institute for Media, Policy, and Civil Society,
2003.
The First Amendment Handbook. Arlington, VA : The Reporters
Committee for Freedom of the Press, 2003.
http://www.rcfp.org/handbook/index.html
MEDIA MONITORING PROJECT ZIMBABWE. Elections Reporting, a
practical guide. Harare: Media Monitoring Project, 1998. MEDIA MONITORING
PROJECT ZIMBABWE. Direct access to the media in election campaigns:
INSTITUTE FOR WAR AND PEACE REPORTING, Media Development and
Training Materials. Www.iwpr.net. Lange, Yasha and Palmer, Andrew, media and
Elections: a Handbook, European Institute for Media. Düsseldorf : 1995.
A review of International Practice and Some Recommendations
for Zimbabwe. Harare: Media Monitoring Project, 2001. SCHNELLINGER, LISA. Free
& Fair: A Journalist's Guide to Improved Election Reporting in Emerging
Democracies. Washington, DC : International Centre for Journalists, Washington,
2001.
Direct access to the media in election campaigns: A review of
International Practice and Some Recommendations for Zimbabwe. Harare: Media
Monitoring Project, 2001.
3. WEBSITES
International Journalists' Network: www.ijnet.org
Investigative Reporters and Editors: www.ire.org
Reporters' Committee for Freedom of the Press: www.rcfp.org
International Consortium of Investigative Journalists:
www.icij.org
International Freedom of Expression Exchange
http://www.ifex.org
Network for the Defense of Independent Media in Africa
(NDIMA) http://www.oneworld.org/ndima
http://tf1.lci.fr/infos/jt-tf1/ppda/
http://livres.20minutes-blogs.fr/
http://passouline.blog.lemonde.fr/
http://www.rtl.fr/radio/emission.asp?dicid=145661
Contents
Abstract.....................................................................................................1
Acknowledgements.......................................................................................2
Chapter
One..............................................................................................3
1.1
Introduction....................................................................................3
1.2
Background.....................................................................................3
1.3 Problem statement
...............................................................................4
1.4
Hypothesis.......................................................................................7
1.5
Justification.......................................................................................7
1.6 Aims and
objective..............................................................................8
1.7 Scope and
Limitation...........................................................................8
1.8 Significance of the
Study.....................................................................9
1.9 Research
Methodology.........................................................................9
1.10 Organization of the
study....................................................................9
Chapter Two: LITERATURE
REVIEW.........................................................10
2.1 MEDIA AND
ELECTIONS.....................................................................
10
2.2. THE MEDIA
BROADCAST...................................................................15
3. NO DEMOCRATIC ELECTIONS WITHOUT FREE AND PLURALISTIC
MEDI......................................................................................................18
4. JURISDICTION MEDIA
ANALYTICS.......................................................21
5. THE CONGOLESE MEDIA
LANDSCAPE...............................................23
Chapter Three: THE ROLE OF MEDIA DURING THE ELECTORAL
PERIOD.....35
1. ELECTIONS
.........................................................................................35
1.1 FREE ELECTION
........................................................................... 36
1.2 DEMOCRATIC
ELECTION...............................................................37
1.3 TRANSPARENT
ELECTIONS............................................................37
1.4 OTHER
DEFINITIONS.....................................................................38
II. ELECTORAL
SYSTEMS........................................................................39
III. MEDIA AND COVERAGE OF THE
ELECTIONS.................................41
IV. THE COVERAGE OF THE ELECTORAL
CAMPAIGN............................55
V. THE CITIZEN
JOURNALISM...........................................................59
VI. THE ELECTION
INTERVIEW...........................................................61
VII. THE OPINION
POLLS.....................................................................63
VIII. THE ELECTIONS IN THE ZONE OF CONFLICT
COVERAGE...............65
IX. THE ELECTION COVERAGE IN SENSITIVE
CONTEXTS......................66
Chapter Four: CONTENET ANALYSIS OF CONGOLESE
NATIONAL TV
COVERAGE...........................................................................................78
1. STUDY OF THE
POPULATION.........................................................78
2. STUDY SAMPLE
.............................................................................79
3. DATA COLLECTION AND
INVESTIGATION.......................................79
4. COUNTING OF THE
QUESTIONNAIRE...............................................80
5. ANALYSIS OF
DATA........................................................................80
Chapter Five: SUMMARY, CONCLUSIONS AND
RECOMMENDATION.............91
5.1. SUMMARY
.....................................................................................91
5.2. CONCLUSION
................................................................................92
5.3.
RECOMMENDATION.....................................................................94
References................................................................................................96
Contents................................................................................................100
Appendix................................................................................................102
Appendix
The survey questionnaire
It is noteworthy as the counting of our questionnaire took
account of the sex variable. Of this variable we generated variables such as
age bracket, level of education, occupational status, In addition, the survey
data that is to say the questionnaires responses were included in the tables,
these tables are developed using calculations of frequencies or percentages
expressed. This work will be based on a sample of 34 journalists who covered
the 2011 elections on national television in Kinshasa city.
1. CATEGORY A / questions for journalists
1. How old do you have?
A/
............................................................
2. What level of study do you have?
a) Secondary? b) Superior or University?
3. Did you have at your disposal adequate equipment for good
media coverage of the 2011 elections?
a) Yes b) No c) Other answer
..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
4. What attitude did you have adopted during this period as a
journalist of the national television?
a) man and woman press? b) politician? c)
politicized? d) any citizen? e) Undecided f) other answers
.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
5. How have you proceeded to cover the events of the various
candidates? and what are the techniques you applied?
A/..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
6. What professional qualities you put in works during this
period?
a) Honesty? b) Functionality? c) Appropriateness? d)
Liability? e) Truth? f) Sincerity? g) Credibility? h) Any? i)
Other answers
.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
7. Have you been under political pressure order or your employer
to support this or that candidate?
a) Yes b) No c) Other answers
.................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
8. How have you repartees your reportages for the 11 presidential
candidates?
A/..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
9. Were you satisfied with work you have realized as a
professional journalist and serving the general interest of the whole people?
a) Yes b) No c) Other answers
.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
10. Have you been physically threatened while on the go in places
reporting?
a) Yes b) No c) Other answers
.............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
2. CATEGORY B / Questions related to the time of repartee
antenna by candidates. Questions addressed to the general
direction of the national television.
11. How important do you have granted to the antenna for each
candidate during the 2011 elections?
A/..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
12. What has been the time given coverage on the air to each
candidate at for their election campaigns on national television?
A/..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
13. In order to explain to the people their country's development
plans how many hours have you given to each candidate?
A/..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
14. How long they realized each for disseminating their campaign
commercials on National TV?
A/..............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
15. How have you repartee the working time for different press
conferences of each candidate?
A/............................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
16. Do you have something else to say?
A/...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
Thank you for your cooperation
Contribution and Innovation
Through this research, we are happy to announce our innovation
and invention yet again in the field of journalism that "the theory
of three verbs" After the publication of my books in Germany and
France on Media here I present to you our new contribution and innovation that
will be if you let it be published in our research.
This what exactly the theory of three verbs?
This theory which is based on three most important verbs that
a professional media must take account in his daily work they are even nuclei
journalism and reporter. We believe that these three verbs are never escaped a
professional journalist. These three verbs allow a professional resume work by
the journalist. These are verbs:
ü interrest
ü Hang
ü inform
ü Interest: Done everything in
journalism is not information; the journalist must realize first that his
information should interest the target audience. In what journalist covering
events is the eye and ear of the public, he must make his work of university
professors, leading researchers, to farmers, presidents, writ has categories of
persons of every kind for do this the information must be always be interesting
and professional.
ü Hang: the question every professional
journalist arises is how to hang my audience. It is possible that the
information we have is interesting, or even very interesting question remains
as to how I can attract people's attention to what I say. This not easy to hung
a large number of people who have different interests on a fact why journalists
must be talented.
When I diffuse such or such information, people should stay in
their lounges to follow. For this talent and professionalism high ranking must
be practiced by the journalist. What is interesting at this point must also
attract attention and gave a desire follow.
ü Inform: it is useless to do
journalism, if at the end of his reportage one will not be given to measuring
essential information. The width of the work of reporter informed as drop
point. the information you have may be interesting, you may also be able to
hung a large number of audience, but in the end you must inform, the most
informative message must go, people who have found the interest and were to
hang on to your information should in the end have an essential message. They
must realize that the three verbs have been professionally respected by
journalist.
LAMBE Author
* 1 CAYROL,
R., The media, print, radio and television, Paris, PUF, 1973, p 75
* 2 BALLE,
F, media corporations, radio and television,
telecommunications
* 3 BERTRAND, CJ.
Matias, introduction to the press, radio and television, 2nd
edition ellipse, 1999.
* 4 CAYROL,
R., the media, print, radio television, Paris, PUF, 1973
* 5 DERVILLE,
G., the power of media, Paris, PUF, 1997
* 6 NGOMA
BINDA, political participation , ethical, for a culture of peace,
democracy and good governance, Kinshasa, ITEP, 2005
* 7 POTER, IAN,
elections training curriculum, Impacts media, and election program,
Cambotra, 2003
* 8 CAMMACK,
DIANA, Election Reporting: a Practical Guide to media
monitoring, London: Article 19, 1988. CARVE, RICHARD. Media and Election Index,
Administration and Cost of Elections (ACE) Project. http://www.aceproject.org,
2001.
* 9 Chirambo,
Kondwani and Mccullum, Hugh, Reporting Elections in Southern
Africa: A Media Handbook. Windhoek, Namibie : le programme de démocratie
durable SARDC. Université de Namibie, Département d'études
d'information et de communication, 2000.
* 10 Clark, Roy
Peter and Cole C. Campbell. The Values and Craft of American
Journalism: Essays from the Poynter Institute. Gainesville, FL: University
Press of Florida, 2005.
* 11 MARTHOZ,
JEAN PAUL. Election Reporting, A Media for Democracy
Handbook. London: international Federation of Journalists, 2000. POTER, IAN.
Elections
* 12 POTER,
IAN. Elections Training Curriculum: IMPACS Media and
Elections Program Cambodia 2003. Phnom Penh : Institute for Media, Policy, and
Civil Society, 2003.
* 13 KABONGO
KALALA KANDA Isidore. Transforming the radio and state
television into of interest services public, Audit of the NTV, January 6,
2006
* 14 International
Journalists' Network: www.ijnet.org
* 15 Investigative
Reporters and Editors: www.ire.org
* 16 Hachten,
William A. Troubles of Journalism: A Critical Look at What's
Right and Wrong with the Press. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, 3ed
edition, 2004.
* 17 Hamilton,
James T. All the News That's Fit to Sell: How the Market
Transforms Information into News. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press,
2003.
* 18 BBC Producer's
Guidelines. http://www.bbc.co.uk/info/editorial/prodgl/contents.htm
Journalism Ethics: The New Debate. Washington: International
Center for Journalists, 1998.
* 19 Training
Curriculum: IMPACS Media and Elections Program Cambodia 2003. Phnom Penh :
Institute for Media, Policy, and Civil Society, 2003.
The First Amendment Handbook. Arlington, VA : Th e
Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press, 2003.
http://www.rcfp.org/handbook/index.html
* 20 Network for the
Defense of Independent Media in Africa (NDIMA) http://www.oneworld.org/ndima
http://tf1.lci.fr/infos/jt-tf1/ppda/
* 21
SCHNELLINGER, LISA. Free & Fair: A
Journalist's Guide to Improved Election Reporting in Emerging Democracies.
Washington, DC: International Centre for Journalists, Washington, 2001.
* 22 International
Consortium of Investigative Journalists: www.icij.org
International Freedom of Expression Exchange
http://www.ifex.org
* 23 Overholser,
Geneva and Kathleen Hall Jamieson. The Press. New York, NY:
Oxford University Press, 2005.
* 24 Sloan, W.
David et Lisa Mullikin Parcell . American Journalism:
History, Principles, Practices. Je? erson, NC : McFarland & Company,
2002.
* 25 INSTITUTE
FOR WAR AND PEACE REPORTING, Media Development and Training
Materials. www.iwpr.net. Lange, Yasha and Palmer, Andrew, (éditeurs).
Media and Elections : a Handbook, European Institute for Media. Düsseldorf
: 1995.
* 26 MEDIA
MONITORING PROJECT ZIMBABWE. Elections reporting, a practical
guide. Harare: Media Monitoring Project, 1998. MEDIA MONITORING PROJECT
ZIMBABWE. Direct access to the media in election campaigns:
|