Title: Analysis of predictors of consistent condom use
among adolescent girls in Ivory coast: implication for preventions
interventions
By TraoreMetahan, Demographer, MPH
September 2016
Key words
Africa, Adolescentgirls, HIV /AIDS, condomuse, behavioral model,
risky behavior, prevention
Abstract
Background
In sub-Saharan Africa, new infections among adults (15 and older)
touch 56% of women; and the proportion was higher among young women aged
15-24, who made up 66 per cent of new infections among young people.
Ivory Coast is the one of the most contaminated country of west
Africa with a rate of 3.7% in 2012 to 2.7% in 2014 (UNAIDS, 2015). HIV/AIDS
rates have fallen from 14 to 12, 4.7% in 2005 in 2014 is 3.2%. despite a slight
improvement of HIV rate, AIDS is still the main cause of death in West Africa.
In fact, the context in which young women live has a negative influence on
their behaviors.
Objective
This study objective is to examine relevant predictors associated
with condom use amongadolescent girls in Ivory Coast.
Results
The main predictors from the multiple regression, are place of
residence, matrimonial status, education level, the fact that the condom
reduces HIV risk and the multiple sexual behavior and the contraceptive
methodof condom use. The matrimonial status, the education level and the
household wealth are statistically significant. These variables show
significant differences for the condom use. Single young girls are 9.03 times
more likely to use condom (p=0.000). Adolescent girls witha primary education
level are 1.91 times more likely to use condom compared to those with no
education. those with secondary and plus education level are 3.54 times more
likely to use condom. For the factors of needs The fact that the condom can
reduce the HIV is statistically significant. Indeed, adolescent are 1.51
times more likely to use condom during sexual intercourses. Young girls
involved in multiple sexual behavior are 0.55 times less likely to use condom.
Also, adolescent girls using contraceptive method are 5.71 times more likely to
use condom than those who do not use condom.
Conclusions
The context in which young women live has a negative influence on
their behaviors. Awareness campaign must focusparticularly for their message in
condom use of adolescentgirls.
Background
Since the 20thcentury, of human immunodeficiency
virus/acquired immunedeficiency syndrome (HIV/AIDS) continues to be one of the
current challenges on the prevention and control faced worldwide is a category
of population face a lot of issues among youths of age 15 to 24 years.
According to UNAIDS in 2015, there is a total of 36.7 million of
people living with HIV and 1.1 million people died of HIV/AIDS. The number of
infected is 2.5 million every year during the last ten years (UNAIDS, 2015).
Since the discover of the AIDS, 30 million people are dead (UNAIDS, 2013). In
Africa there's a reduction of 32% during the last decade and the mortality rate
decrease to more than 32% since its pic of 2005. But the number of infected
people is still high comparing the population growth.More than35millionpeople
are infected in the world by HIV with 1.5 million of deathsand high proportions
of women and children.The official statistics reported that almost 60% of
adults living with HIV are women, and 75% of young people infected are girls
(UNAIDS, 2012). Young women and adolescent girls of 15-24 group age
aredrastically affected and infected. Globally, in 2015 there werean estimated
2.3 million adolescent girls and young women living with HIV, that constitute
60 per cent of all young people living with HIV (15-24).
In 2015, women represent 47 per cent of the 1.9 million new HIV
infections. It is noticed that young persons aged 15-24 there is 58% of new HIV
infections occurred among adolescent girls and young women in 2015(Unaids,
2015)
In sub-Saharan Africa, women comprised 56 per cent of
new infections among adults (15 and older); and the proportion was higher
among young women aged 15-24, who made up 66 per cent of new
infections among young people. Women are more vulnerable and more exposed to
HIV/AIDS than men (Rwenge, 2002). The biological make-up of the female
genitalia coupled with the gender/structural constraints within which sex takes
place thus exposes sexually active women to contracting the disease more than
their male counterparts. because of (WHO, 1999). In fact, some studies found
strong and consistent relationships between poverty economic insecurity and
multiple high risk sexual behaviors among women (Phaladze & Weiser,
2007).
Sexual activities during adolescence have been characterized as
dynamic and constantly changing, with potential impact on reproductive life and
a 5.8% increase in fertility rates in the 15-to-19-year age group observed in
Ivory Coast from 1994 to 2012. Another important health dimension relates to
the increased susceptibility to HIV transmission when such activities are
unprotected or performed under coercion.
Ivory Coast is the one of the most contaminated country of west
Africa. With a rate of 3.7% in 2012 to 2.7% in 2014 (UNAIDS, 2015). HIV rates
have fallen from 14 to 12, 4.7% in 2005 in 2014 is 3.2%. despite a slight
improvement of HIV rate, AIDS is still the main cause of death in west Africa.
The national report of Côte d'Ivoire aboutAIDS published in 2008 shows
that the prevalence of AIDS varies among age groups, gradually increasing by
about 1% in the 15 to 19 years to almost 14% in 30-34 years. There are
different reasons thathave been advanced to explain this meteoric rise of HIV /
AIDS within the Ivorian population in general and youth in particular. First
ofall, the socioeconomic, socio cultural andinstitutional contexthas influenced
young people live in a negative way on their attitudes about sexuality.
Although more than 93% of Ivorian's youths know that consistent
condom use could prevent HIV infection (DHS, 2012), only 47% female youths used
them at their previous high risk sexual encounters. This indicates a gap
between knowledge and behaviors. Many Ivorian youths engage in risky sexual
behaviors such as having unprotected sexual intercourse which may lead to
sexually transmissible infections (STIs), including HIV/AIDS (Arcand &
Wouabe, 2010; Kongnyuy et al., 2008; Mosoko et al., 2009). Despite the risks,
consistent condom use has remained fairly low (Van Rossem and Meekers,
2000).
The explanation of this situation is caused by the poverty and
misery whom face population in Côte d'Ivoire. As in most developing
countries, young people, especially girls, are forced to sell their charms to
survive. In Abidjan, prostitution is highly practiced so that it is become a
society issue. Since the 90 where governments seem unable to limit the spread
AIDS. Several studies showed argue that in the Ivorian capital, the rich and
the middle class men display marital infidelity. For young people, multiple
sexual partners andhaving multiple sexual partners is a phenomenon in
fashion.It is very important to understand why some people use condomduring
sexualintercourse and others not, request to take into consideration several
parameters. It must take into account individual susceptibility and
characteristics of the potential users, the context in which he lives, etc.
This study objective is to examine relevant factors associated
with condom use amongadolescent girls in Ivory Coast.
Two specific objectives are addressed in this paper.
· Identify the profile of adolescent girls using condom
· Determine thepredictors influencing the high risk
sexual behavior in Cote d'Ivoire
Synthetic literature review
This literature review presents the different explanatory
approaches in relation to condom use in order to identify determinants of
condom use. It is noticed that there is a deficiency in the explanatory
approaches sexual behavior of women in African context. To do so, we present
the differentapproaches to sexual behavior of young women and see their
relevance in men.
The Socio-Cultural Approach
The cultural approach plays a central role in the social
construction and cultural (Foucault, 1984, cited by Rwenge, 1991). Thus
according to these authors, the circumstances in which occurs the sexual
activity is a function of socio-cultural norms and values(ABEGA, 1999). Since
they are dynamic it is important to highlight how they influence the sexual
behavior of individuals in the traditional society.
According to the literature, the sociocultural approach about
women is based on the socio-cultural norms and values ??of the individual and
society in terms of sexuality. Sexual morals are not uniform in all the
societies. The sexual behavior of women depends on the degree of permissiveness
of social groups considered(Bah 1995). In permissive societies sexual mores and
sexual behavior are reflected in the low importance given to virginity,
encouragement of sexuality and adultery for men (Orubuloye et al., 1994,
Caldwell et al. 1994 quoted by Rwenge, 2002). In societies where sexual morals
are rigid women behave according to strict social control in sexual matters
(BONGAARTS, 2000).
In these societies there are the abandonment of traditional
values ??and conservative social standards, in favor of mores liberal
attitudes. These often include an increase in sexual promiscuity due to
decreased of social control. Urbanization appears as a cause of the reduction
of social control of women's sexuality and behavior.(Bajos,2001)
Standards and socio-cultural values ??of the sexuality of
men in traditional society. Traditionally, there exists a set of
standards and more or less binding legal obligations that regulate sexual
behavior(Caldwellet al. 1989). The sexual behavior of man depends on the
traditional context. The sociocultural system model representations and directs
individuals practices from the perspective of normative stability and
maintenance of cultural models (Songue, 1994). Traditional African society is
one where traditional norms and values ??have a strong influence on the
behavior of individuals, or social control is the most important. Unlike
women's sexuality, that of men is less controlled and less brigaded by the
communities which they serve. A man is often accused of adultery in case of
sexual intercourse with a married woman. (Tarkang, 2013). Furthermore, sexual
experiences before marriage are more valued among men and infidelity is better
tolerated. But the sexual mores are not uniform in all societies. In contrary,
according to social groups considered, there is more or less significant
differences, particularly in terms of their permissiveness (Rwenge, 2002).
Traditionally, there are societies with permissive sexual mores
and other are non-permissive. In societies or are permissive sexual mores, the
man has a great tolerance for premarital sexuality and fertility and tolerance
of adultery (Orubuloye et al, 1994; Caldwell et al, 1994 cited by Rwenge 2002).
By cons, in societies where sexual norms are not permissive, although
undergoing a low social control than women, the sexual behavior of men are
characterized by low promotion of premarital sex and adultery tolerance of
man(Uchudi et al, 2010).. These situations lead to differences in the use of
condoms. Traditionally, marriage and fertility have an important social value
(Muula 2011). These two phenomena are social norms. It also important to point
out that in traditional society, marriage main objective is a social obligation
which no man and women can escape. If not no man has no right to dispose of his
wife's body. The sexual act is considered in the African context, as a conjugal
duty that every woman should do. So to enable it to achieve its desired goal of
fertility, the company him, attaches great sexual freedom (Rwenge, 2002)
considering the fact that the goal of sex is fertility, so all decisions on
sexuality are held by men. In such circumstances all voluntary contraception
methods (condoms, for example) are banned. In these societies, we see more and
more to an upset conservative social norms, for more liberal attitudes (Uchudi,
2010). These often include increased individual liberty corollary of social
control reduction.
Standards and socio-cultural values ??of men's sexuality
in modern society. The reduction of social control would be caused in
part by urbanization and modernization. This is accompanied not only an ethnic,
cultural and social with the anonymity of individuals but also of family
control over the sexuality of young people (Mekers, 1991). Thus attitudes
toward sexuality are much more permissive in urban and semi-urban. The
degradation of morals values and mores consecutive to the abandonment of
traditional values ?? (due to modernism) would encourage and increase women
risk sexual behavior. To explain the evolution of sexuality, we focus to the
loosening of social control paradigm of "social disorganization".
The relaxation of social controls on sexuality, due to
urbanization, sex education and changes in modes of production in African
societies not only increased decision-making power of men to rigid sexual
morals but also young people have the capacityof decision-making power of men
to rigid sexual mores but also young people who have decision-making capacity
on when, with whom and why getting sex (Mekers 1991a).This social
disorganization of sociocultural mores on sexuality has led women to certain
Western practices, including sexual libertinism shown by multiple partners,
casual sex leading to the spread of STI/AIDS. They appear as the villages are
beginning to be affected by the change of lifestyle. The fact that people
living in cities come to visit the village playing an important role in the
rural spread of new practices (Balde, 2003). It isin the sense that Rwenge
(2002) attributes the change in the vision of the meaning of sex in modern
society where the main objective of this activity is reflected in modern
society by the unbridled pursuit of sexual pleasure. Much importance is given
here in the sexual performance of man passes. The gender issues are no longer
taboo and premarital sex becomes a common practice considered normal and sexual
inexperience show damaging failure (Ngondo, 1994; Njikam, 1998; Songue 1998;
Evina, 1998).
Christian religions have also contributed to the destabilization
of African traditions. (Gugler, 1981). The dynamics of sexual behavior is
explained by many researches as a consequence of the accession of individuals
in Western religion, modernization factors and the urban economy. Moreover, the
consideration of marriage and fertility has changed. Marriage is becoming less
and less a social control strategy in fertility (Kaplan, 2001). Theseresults
are expressed through divorces, separations between spouses. The fundamental
purpose of marriage is no longer so tied to fertility effect this marriage is
gradually losing its importance as a social institution. So, infidelity is
become a common practice even in societies with rigid sexual mores that
marriage devaluation is a manifestation of little interest that African
societies are paying increasingly high fertility (Ibara, 2008).Therefore,
sexuality objective is not more essentially fertility, but forsexual
satisfaction. Such consideration given to the sexuality of women determines
their attitude to modern contraceptive methods and sexual risk behaviors(Rwenge
2002). Therefore, the sexual risk behaviors are amplified. Despite the mostly
urban population experiencing STI / AIDS and it is the mode of transmission,
the rate of condom use is low (Caldwell, 2000). Thus, this approach argues that
modern values ??in marriage and fertility rates in Africa also contribute to
the attitudes and behavior of individuals on contraception and thus condom
(Carlos Mendes 2009).
The socio-cultural approach is based on the value placed on
sexuality to highlight the factors that explain the use of condoms as the
context of traditional society and the context of modern society in this case
traditional society where sexuality a reproductive purpose, it is considered as
ataboo (Caldwell, 1989). The condom is a contraceptive method goes against the
aspiration of many people. So, in such societies the sexual mores are in favor
of condom use. There is a change in sexual behavior of individuals due to an
erosion of standards and socio-cultural values ?? (Meekers, 1993; CERPOD, 1996;
Rwenge, 1999; Delauny et al. 2001) and causing social disorganization and a
crumbling sexual mores often unfavorable to prevention behaviors. However, the
socio-economic approach helps explain the sexual behavior of men and women
associated with condom use factors.
Socioeconomic Approach
This approach is based on the relationship between personality
and the adoption of healthy sexual behavior that approach considers individuals
as rational actors. This approach is thus based on the thesis of "wise
adaptation" that women would engage in sex to achieve well-defined goals,
specific economic or social difficulties.
As the study of the sexual behavior of men is recent, we will
present the content of the studies in women and then examine their relevance in
men. In women, sexual behavior depends on their socioeconomic status. Material
dependence of women to men because they have multiple sexual partners and lack
the power to control their sexual behavior(Kaltsam, 2008). Similarly, economic
constraints mean that girls have sex with older men and thus more likely to
have STIs / AIDS. Furthermore, an educated woman can challenge the internalized
representations of gender roles. That situation can have a great mastery over
his sex life and effectively negotiate the terms of the relationships in which
they engage (Rwenge, 2002).
The human level, socio-economic approaches is based on two
assumptions; the assumption of economic rationality and the economic
constraints. Two categories of men who get sex can be distinguished: (1) those
for whom sexual activity meets both an economic purpose and is a marriage
strategy (Cherlin &Riley 1986 quoted by Rwenge, 2002). In the first case,
found mostly young boys contracting the profit reports. This is the marketing
phenomenon by young girls who want to earn money necessary to meet their needs.
The economic conditions of women may also influence on their sexual behavior.
These young people are usually victims of sexual services of old men or engage
them in casual sex because of the poverty of their families(Dedy, 1995).
However, in case of favorable economic situation, some of them may engage in
multiple partnerships. In consequence, they enjoy the material difficulties of
some young girls to satisfy their sexual desires maximum. In the case of
economic difficult situation, many young women tend to engage intensively in
sexual relationships and even get into prostitution(Baral, 2012).
In the second case, the sexuality of women is an economic
objective than asocial purpose (Rwenge 1999). The purpose of sexual activity
can also be fertility. This being a necessary strategy is the culmination of
marriage. Studies have shown that this trend is much more pronounced among
young people in urban areas where the monetization of sex is amplified and
current (Calvès, 1996).
In addition, men who have a higher socioeconomic status and those
with a higher socioeconomic status allows these men to have multiple sexual
partners with old men. Thus,they take advantage of that status supplies to meet
their maximum sexual desire. In such a context. The man is needed in the way of
doing sex with these partners. Condom use often returns to man alone, since the
woman has a low condom negotiation power (Rwengé, 2002).
Institutional Approach.
As the institutional approach is characterized by a deficiency,
it will be presented the content of this approach in terms of sexual behavior
among women and then examine their relevance in men. The institutional approach
in women is one that gives great importance to policy, program and legislation
on sexuality and marriage in sexual behavior explaining of women.
In general, public policy, attitude and involvement of
authorities in the fight against STDs and AIDS can affect the spread of these
diseases in the population. These policies can allow the adoption of safer
sexual behavior prevention through condom availability and favorable preventive
information to improve sexual behavior of women (Rwenge 1999 b). Unfortunately,
in many African countries, few STI prevention programs for a change in sexual
behavior. Moreover, if prostitution is in many countries represent a phenomenon
reducing the efforts of the fight against STDs and AIDS, it should be noted the
strategies implemented by some governments for better control of this activity.
In Senegal, for example, prostitution islegalized for people over 20 years. One
advantage is related to the legalization of prostitutionactivities in Senegal
where condoms are freelydistributed to prostitutes in STI centers (United
Nations, 1992). Regarding the marriage, in many African countries, the marriage
of women is regulated by texts on the organization of civil status and various
provisions relating to the physical condition of those people remains the
"customary" (Rwenge 1999). In Cameroon the age of consent is 15 years for
girls, while in Togo, that age is 18 years.
The adoption of healthy sexual behavior is keen to legal and
political contexts, as well as the availability of condoms and prevention
information (Rwenge ,2002). For example, cooperation between government and
grassroots organizations, to that change some certain sexual standards, can
lead to the improvement of the sexual behavior of men and particularly of
women. It is the same for the implementation of information dissemination
systems, means of prevention of STI / AIDS among women and campaigns to
systematic use of condoms in risky sex.
Given that in modern societies the traditional considerations of
the child are not observed, people have a real desire to reduce their
fertility, among others by using condoms. In the same company's individuals
have a high level of knowledge of HIV / ADS, modes of transmission, etc. But
condom use rates are low. It's that there are institutional factors affecting
the accessibility, the quality of services of reproductive health. The real
problem is the psychosocial level regarding awareness of the risk association
with sexuality. The Information Education and Communication via the media does
not convey messages emphasizing the perceived risk of infection. And the level
of service quality of the RH, the level of information. It is not often adapted
and more women are often overlooked during awareness campaigns. (Dodo, 2003)
Governments are often helped in the fight against STI / AIDS by
religious institutions, especially in the moralization of manners, for example
by advocating monogamy (in the case of Christian institutions), fidelity or
abstinence. But the "dogmatic" position of religions is not without creating
difficulties for NAP (National Program for the Fight against AIDS) that being
engaged in the field of condoms, in open contradiction with religious messages,
sometimes causing confusion among the recipients (Beat S., 1993; Dozon
1994).
With the marriage rate among men in many African countries, new
legislation codifying the family organization were adopted in the years
following independence. Some like Guinea in 1962 and Ivory Coast in 1964,
forbade polygamy (Thirat,2000). On the other have chosen a compromise between
Western and African traditions legislation. Thus, the family codes of Cameroon
and Congo, for example, allow a choice in a marriage contract between a union
weakness to be only little apply, among other things because the marriages
registered with the civil state remains low numerous. In Côte d'Ivoire
and Guinea, the abolition of polygamy did not stop the practice: according to
the 1994 DHS and the first 1998 of the second 30% and 54% of married women
living in polygamous union (Ivory coast 1995, Guinea, 2000). Finally, the
marriage of adolescents is regulated in most countries by various text and law.
In Cameroon, as in the Ivory Coast official marriage is 18 years(Sylla,
2002).
In summary, the sociocultural, economical and institutional
approaches have influences on women sexuality in term of high sexual risk
behavior.
Method
The data for this study come from Demographic and Health Survey
(DHS)
conducted in 2012 in Ivory Coast. The access to these data has
been authorized by ORCMacro, an organization based in the United States.
The survey was conducted among 10060women (8,109 men and 1,577
women)
aged between 15 and 49 years. The ORC Macro uses stratified
sampling in order to provide adequate representation of environments urban and
rural.
In this study, we limited our sample to women whose age ranges
between 15 and 19 and who are mostat risk for infection with STIs HIV/AIDS
included. This gives us a sample of 2124 people. We will use the behavioral
model developed in 1968 by Ronald Andersen study the determinants of the use of
condoms among adolescent girls in Côte d'Ivoire (Figure 1).
Under this model, the use of condom takes place:
1. The individual must be predisposed to accept the
condom,
2. Certain conditions are necessary to facilitate its use and,
3. The individual must feel the need to use the condom.
In summary, facilitators factors, predisposing factors and
factors ofneed are used to achieve condom use.
Data analysis
Data Analysis Data were analyzed using the software SAS 9.2
Windows [16, 17]. Univariate descriptive were used to inspect the distribution
of frequencies.Par Thereafter, bivariate analyzesallow us to evaluate the
association betweenevery independentand condom use. The chi-square test with a
significance level of 5%, odds Ratio (OR) and a95% confidence interval were
used to examine the magnitude and degree of significance between the main
dependent value and each independent variable. For the final modeling,
multivariate logistic regression was used based on the behavioral model of
Andersen for the inclusion of explanatory variables. Three models were
estimated. First, we have introduced only the predisposing variables in the
second model, we added the facilitating variables. The latest model includes
all three groups of variables (predisposing, facilitative and needs).
Figure1: Conceptual Diagram of the analysis of
determinant
Predisposing factors
Multiple partnership
Condom prevent HIV
Risk perception
Having STI
Getting AIDS by Witchcraft
Facilitating factors
Religion
Matrimonial status
Education
Household wealth
Employment status
Predisposing factors
Age
Place of residency
Region
Cultural model of sexuality and fertility
Contraceptive method
Condom use
Principal dependent Variable
The dependent variable is condom use occurred during the last
sexual intercourse whatever casual or regular. The variable is dichotomous and
the responses are 1 for «yes» or 0 for «No» or
«don't know»
Independent variable
The independent variables are constituted of predisposing
factors, facilitating factors and the need factors
Results
Table 2:Sociodemographics Characteristics andbehavioral
of respondents
Variables
|
Frequency (n)
|
Proportion (%) of adolescent girls aged 15 to 19, who reported
using condom
|
Probability of CHI2
|
Predisposing factors
|
|
|
|
Region
Centre
North
West
South
Abidjan
|
105
87
59
50
56
|
34.88
31.64
27.83
24.39
42.75
|
0.004***
|
Facilitating factors
|
|
|
|
Religion
Muslim
Christian
Animist
Total
|
118
214
25
357
|
27.25
39.85
16.23
31.76
|
0.000***
|
Matrimonial status
Married
Single
|
21
336
|
5.50
45.28
|
0.000***
|
Place of residence
Urban
Rural
|
248
109
|
44.93
19.06
|
0.000***
|
Education level
No education
Primary
Secondary
Total
|
64
94
199
357
|
13.64
30.62
57.35
31.76
|
0.000***
|
Occupation
Working
No working
|
201
156
|
36.28
27.37
|
0.001***
|
Household Wealth
Poor
Middle
Rich
|
72
63
222
|
17.43
27.27
46.25
|
0.000***
|
Condom reduce risk of HIV
No
Yes
|
85
267
|
23.48
39.50
|
0.000***
|
Multiple partnership
No
Yes
|
328
29
|
31.66
32.95
|
0.000***
|
Had Sexually transmissible disease
No
Yes
|
707
60
|
31.23
37.50
|
0.207
|
Get HIV by Witchcraft
No
Yes
|
231
340
|
40.03
26.25
|
0.000***
|
Tested for HIV
No
Yes
|
578
189
|
29.68
37.42
|
0.014
|
Contraception use
No
Yes
|
95
201
|
12.39
56.30
|
0.000***
|
***: Significant to á=0.01
**: Significant to á=0.05
Almost all the variables have a strong relationship with the use
of condom. Except the variable of having STI, the fact that the respondent got
a Sexually Transmitted Disease (STD).
The Region is statistically significant linked with the condom
of girls at 1% with a p-value of 0.004 Centreregion have 34.88 respondent
reported to use condom with their partners. In the North, 31.64% of adolescent
girls use condom and 27.83% for the West region use condom. There is 24.39% of
the participants in the South Regionusing condom and participant living in
Abidjan (the capitol) are 42.75% to use condom.There is a strong significant
relationship between the religion and the condom use at 1% (p-value =0.000).
Adolescent girls who are Muslim constitute 27.25% using condom. 39.85% of
participants are Christians using condom. The animist is 31.76% using
condom.The matrimonial status is statistically significant with the condom use
(p=0.000) at 1%. The participant who are married represent 5.50% using condom
and those who are single are 45.28% using condom during sexual intercourse.The
place of residence is statically significant with the adolescent girls' condom
use (p=0.000) at 1%. Young girls with no education represent 13.64% who
reported using condom with their partner. For the primary education level,
30.62% use condom. The secondary and plus represent 57.35% of respondents using
condom.
Employment status is statistically significant with the condom
use at 1% (p=0.001). the participants who are working are 36.28% using condom
and those who are not working are 27.37% using condom.Household wealth is
statistically significant with the condom use of adolescent girls at 1%
(p=0.000). Poor women use less condom with 17.43% of respondents. In
contrary the percentage of condom use increases with the education level. In
fact, 27.27% of primary education use condom and 46.25% of secondary and plus
use condom.
Condom reduce risk of HIV is statically significant with the
condom use at 1% (p=0.000). In fact, 23.48% of participant reported that
condom does not reducesHIV and 39.50 % think that condom is do reduces the
riskof HIV. There is a strong relationship between the multiple sexual
partnership and the condom use at 1% (p=0.000). There is 31.66% of
participants in who are not involved in multiple sexual behaviors and those
involved in multiple sexual behaviors are 32.95% using condom during sexual
intercourses.The fact of having Sexually Transmitted Infection during the last
12 months is not significantly associated with the condom use of adolescent
girls (p value =0.207).
There is a strong association between the getting HIV
bywitchcraft at 1% (p=0.000). Infact,adolescent girls represent40.03%
whoreported HIVcannot be got through witchcraft use compared to 26.25% who
answered that HIV can be got by witchcraft use condom.There is an association
condomuse with HIV test is statically significant at 5% (0.014).
participants who had not ever been tested are 29.68% using condom while those
who had ever been tested represent 37.42% using condom.The contraceptive use is
statistically associated with condom use of adolescent girls at 1% (p=0.000).
For this variable 12.39% reporting not using contraceptive method use condom
and there is a proportion of 56.30% who use contraceptive method are currently
involved in use condom.
Bivariate association
Table 2: Bivariate analysis to assess the
association of the sociodemographic and behavioral and condom use
Variables
|
O.R
|
95% I.C.
|
P value
|
Predisposing factors
|
|
|
|
Place of residence
Urban
Rural
|
3.46
1.00
|
2.65-4.53
|
0.000***
|
Region
Centre
North
West
South
Abidjan
|
1.00
0.86
0.72
0.60
1.39
|
0.61-1.22
0.49-1.05
0.40-0.90
0.92-2.12
|
0.0043***
|
Facilitating factors
|
|
|
|
Religion
Muslim
Christian
Animist
Total
|
1.93
3.42
1.00
|
1.20-3.12
2.15-5.43
|
0.000***
|
Matrimonial status
Married
Single
|
1.00
14.22
|
8.95-22.60
|
0.000***
|
Education level
No education
Primary
Secondary
Total
|
1.00
2.80
8.53
|
1.96-4.01
6.08-11.97
|
0.000***
|
Occupation
No Working
Working
|
1.51
1.00
|
1.17-1.95
|
0.0013***
|
Household Wealth
Poor
Middle
Rich
|
1.00
1.77
4.08
|
1.21-2.61
2.99-5.56
|
0.000***
|
Factors of Needs
|
|
|
|
Condom reduce risk of HIV
No
Yes
|
1.00
2.13
|
1.60-1.84
|
0.000***
|
Multiple partnership
No
Yes
|
1.00
1.06
|
0.67-1.69
|
0.802
|
Risk perception
No
Yes
|
1.00
3.34
|
2.24-4.98
|
0.000
|
Had STI
No
Yes
|
1.00
1.32
|
|
0.2126
|
Get HIV by Witchcraft
No
Yes
|
1.00
0.53
|
0.41-0.70
|
0.000***
|
Tested for HIV
No
Yes
|
1.00
1.42
|
1.07-1.87
|
0.0144**
|
Contraception use
No
Yes
|
1.00
9.11
|
6.73-12.30
|
0.000***
|
The results show that allthe independent variables are associated
with the condom use except ever had STI variable.
Adolescent girls from the North region have 0.86 times less
likely to use condom compared to those from Centre. Those coming from West have
0.72 times less likely to use condom compare to those from Centre. Adolescent
from the South are 0.60 times less likely than those from the Centre. Girls
from Abidjan have 1.39 times more likely to use condom compared to those from
the Centre. Adolescent of urban zone are 3.46 times to use condom (p=0.000).
For the religion, Muslim are 1.93 times more likely and Christians have 3.452
timesmore likely to use condom compared to animist. For the marital status,
adolescent girls who are single have 14.22 times more likely to use condom
compared to singleadolescent girls during sexual intercourse with their
partners.
The odds ratio increases with the education level. In fact, girls
with and primary and those with second&plus and plus education level are
respectively 2.80 and 8.53 times more likely to use condom compared to those
with no education level.Employment status, is significantly associated with the
condom use. In fact, girls who don't work have 1.51 timeslikely to use condom
compared to those who don't work.The fact of using condom is function with the
wealth. Women in the middle are 1.77 times more likely using condom than those
who are poor and the rich are 4.08 times likely to use condom than the poor.
Girls who reported that condom can reduce HIV are 2.13 time
likely to use condom than those who reported the negative. But for the multiple
sexual behavior there is significant difference with the condom use. In fact,
adolescent girls who are involved in multiple sexual behavior are 1.06 times
more likely to use condom than those who are not. The risk perception showsa
significant difference for the condom use at 1%. Girls are 3.34 timemore
likely to use condom than those who don't have any risk perception.Girls
supposing the AIDS can bet got by witchcraft are 0.53 times less likely to use
condom than those stated the contrary.Adolescent girls using condom are 9.11
times more likely to use condom compared to those who do not use any
contraceptive method. But the variable of tested of HIV is not statistically
different.
Multivariate association
Table 3. Multiple regression logisticof adolescent use of
condom
|
|
|
Model1
|
Model2
|
Model3
|
Variables
|
Bivariate
|
|
OR
|
95% I.C.
|
OR
|
95% I.C.
|
OR
|
95% I.C.
|
Predisposing factors
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Place of residence
Urban
Rural
|
3.46
1.00
|
|
3.50***
1.00
|
2.63-4.65
|
1.10
1.00
|
0.68-1.80
|
1.03
1.00
|
0.63-1.71
|
Region
Centre
North
West
South
Abidjan
|
1.00
0.86
0.72
0.60
1.39
|
|
1.00
1.01
0.82
0.72
0.81
|
0.70-1.45
0.55-1.23
0.47-1.09
0.52-1.26
|
1.00
1.21
1.19
0.74
0.76
|
0.80-1.85
0.75-1.88
0.46-1.16
0.46-1.26
|
1.00
1.19
1.22
0.70
0.75
|
0.76-1.84
0.76-1.96
0.44-1.11
0.45-1.24
|
Facilitating factors
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Religion
Muslim
Christian
Animist
|
1.93
3.42
1.00
|
|
|
|
1.73
1.66
1.00
|
0.99-3.02
0.97-2.83
|
1.52
1.47
1.00
|
0.85-2.71
0.85-2.56
|
Matrimonial status
Married
Single
|
1.00
14.22
|
|
|
|
1.00
9.03***
|
5.50-14.8
|
1.00
9.16***
|
5.47-15.34
|
Education level
No education
Primary
Secondary
|
1.00
2.80
8.53
|
|
|
|
1.00
1.91***
3.54***
|
1.28-2.85
2.34-5.35
|
1.00
1.84***
3.16***
|
1.21-2.80
2.04-4.88
|
Occupation
No Working
Working
|
1.51
1.00
|
|
|
|
0.96
1.00
|
0.70-1.31
|
0.95
1.00
|
0.69-1.32
|
Household Wealth
Poor
Middle
Rich
|
1.00
1.77
4.08
|
|
|
|
1.00
1.31
2.61***
|
0.78-2.21
1.52-4.47
|
1.00
1.38
2.68
|
0.80-2.38
1.54-4.68
|
Factors of Needs
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Condom reduce risk of HIV
No
Yes
|
1.00
2.13
|
|
|
|
|
|
1.00
1.51**
|
1.08-2.12
|
Multiple partnership
No
Yes
|
1.00
1.06
|
|
|
|
|
|
1.00
0.55**
|
0.32-0.92
|
Risk perception
No
Yes
|
1.00
3.34
|
|
|
|
|
|
1.00
1.01
|
0.61-1.66
|
Had STI
No
Yes
|
1.00
1.32
|
|
|
|
|
|
1.00
0.94
|
0.57-1.58
|
Get HIV by Witchcraft
No
Yes
|
1.00
0.53
|
|
|
|
|
|
1.00
0.85
|
0.62-1.72
|
Tested for HIV
No
Yes
|
1.00
1.42
|
|
|
|
|
|
1.00
1.05
|
0.74-1.48
|
Contraception use
No
Yes
|
1.00
9.11
|
|
|
|
|
|
1.00
5.71***
|
3.98-8.20
|
The results of table 3 show the final model of the condom using
among the adolescent girls after adjusting for all the variables. The model 1
present the predisposing factors without the influences of the others types of
factors. The place of residence is statistically significant at 1%. In fact,
adolescent girls from urban zone are 3.50 times more likely to condom compared
to those from the rural zone.
In the model 2, the matrimonial status, the education level and
the household wealth are statistically significant. These variablesshow
significant differences for the condom use. Single young girls are9.16 times
more likely to use condom. Adolescent girls with primary education level are
1.84 times more likely to use condom compared to those with no education.
those with secondary and plus education level are 3.16 times more likely to use
condom.Even if the religion does not have influence but it is very important to
reveal its influence in African socio cultural context of HIV spread. The
Christian religion is spread everywhere almost in urban. This religion vehicles
eastern and modern values and education. Thus, in urban area, the traditional,
cultural values and values of sexuality are less severe and with a certain
degree of freedom contrary in rural area the traditional values and norms in
term of sexuality. That situation is an explanation of thefact that young girls
are more likely to use condom in opposition to the those of rural zones.
In the model 3, the matrimonial status, the education level and
the household wealth are statistically significant. These variables show
significant differences for the condom use. Single young girls are 9.03 times
more likely to use condom (p=0.000). Adolescent girls with primary education
level are 1.91 times more likely to use condom compared to those with no
education. those with secondary and plus education level are 3.54 times more
likely to use condom. For the factors of needs The fact that the condom can
reduce the HIV is statistically significant. Indeed, adolescent are 1.51
times more likely to use condom during sexual intercourses. Young girls
involved in multiple sexual behavior are 0.55 times less likely to use condom.
Also, adolescent girls using contraceptive method are 5.71 times more likely to
use condom than those who do not use condom.
Discussion
The main predictors from the multiple regression, are place of
residence, matrimonial status, education level, the fact that Condon reduce HIV
risk and the multiple sexual behavior and the contraceptive method condom
use.
The variable place of residence which is significant in the
model1 becomenon-significant in the model 2. The adjusting for the facilitating
variables make disappear the influence of the predisposing factors such as
place of residency. In the urban place of residence,adolescent girls are
exposed to the massmedia (TV, radio,etc.). The sensitive campaigns are more
frequent than in the rural zone. In fact, in urban zone the presence of health
facilities, reproductive health services and HIV/ AIDS care Programs, screening
test where counsels are given to people. Thus they have access more to the
family planning services. Thus girls of the urban area benefitsof important
sensitive and awareness campaign. This results showed there are gaps between
urban andrural zone in terms of HIV /AIDS intervention and programs.The place
of residence may discriminate through the employment status where people work
in intellectual area and women got an education level are able to negotiate the
condom use with their partner during the sexual intercourses.
In the model2, the facilitating factors such as matrimonial
status, education and household wealth are the main predictors. The propensity
increases with the education level. The girls with primary and secondary and
plus are more likely to use condom. Several studies have shown the same
results (Rwenge, 2002; Dodo, 2003). The same for the marital status. In fact,
single women are more likely to use condom than those who are married. Many
researchers found out the same outcomes.The fact that women living in cities
got good education level facilitate conduct to adopt preventive behavior. The
low condom for education is caused bythe factthat many of these women work in
rural area where there is not enough health infrastructures and family planning
program. Also women are nor exposed to media (Television, radio,
magazine,Newsweek).Household wealth represents a main predictor. Women oh rich
household are more likely to use condom.
The introduction of factors of needs maintain the action of
facilitating action from model 2 to the final model (model3).For the factors of
needs, multiple sexual behavior and the fact that condom prevent HIV are main
predictors. Many results are shown from many studies. In fact, condom is used a
double protection for a contraceptive and HIV/AIDS.The risk perception can be
explained by the spread of the disease in the communities. Almost people
gotfriends,relatives or colleagues suffering or dead of HIV/AIDS. The fact that
women using contraceptive have a high propensity to use condom is due to the
fact that condom is used for it double protection against unintended
pregnancies and HIV/AIDS at the same time.
These young women are student and the condom is a contraceptive
method to avoid unintended pregnancies. Women living in rural zone are often
excluded of awarenesscampaign about HIV/AIDS. Traditional sexual norms values
mores and fertility are highly and anchored in mentality and collective
unconscious and mores. The perception of traditional value of children is still
present in mentality and in mores. People are living in natality environment.
People want to get many children because children represent a wealth in term of
workforce to work in farms and contraceptive method to limit the number of
children is poorly perceived. The condom use in traditional area is poorly
viewed in conservative norms. In addition, those living in rural zone think
that they don't have high risk to be contaminated by HIV are not exposed enough
to the risk. This variable influence directly the condom use. The variable is a
pertinent predictor because manyfactors action for condom use pass through that
variable.
Study limitations
The study has taken place during post electoral crisis in Cote
d'Ivoire. Therefore, this situation can be factor of bias. For the case of
HIV/AIDS it is very important to set up a qualitative study in order to
understand the socio economic, psychological and anthropologic, culture
influence on HIV spread in Africa context. In addition, because most of the
items in the questionnaire elicit self-reported information on sensitive issues
such as condom use and HIV/AIDS, the respondent might have been bias in
responding to these items. However, assurance of confidentiality and anonymity
might have minimized this problem.
The lack of qualitative survey overshadows the research because,
the qualitative study gives a better understanding of and comprehension of the
high risk sexual behavior in terms of the non-use of condom and the multiple
sexual behavior and the relationship with the social norms, values and
stereotype. Many answers may be double with bias because of the factthat
sexuality is still taboo in many African society, so people don't give real
information concerning condom use.
Recommendations
· It will be high appreciated if awareness campaign be
focused on abstainingfrom sexualintercourse for young men and adolescent girls.
Adolescent shouldbe encouraged and counselled in order to prevent STDs,
including HIV infection, and pregnancy. Adolescents who have been sexually
active previously should also be counseled regarding the benefits of postponing
future sexual relationships.
· It must be encouraged the double protection of condom for
contraception and against HIV/AIDS are urged to actively support and encourage
the correct and consistent use of reliable contraception and condoms by
adolescents who are sexually active or contemplating sexual activity. The
responsibility of males as well as females in preventing unwanted pregnancies
and STDs should be emphasized.
· Decision makers must be actively involved all the
community leaders in all the HIV/AIDS mostly the religious leaders in order to
adapt their religious law for sexuality to the reality of the situation
· In the interest of public health, restrictions and
barriers to condom availability should be removed.
· It is very useful to activate the school committee to
fight HIV/AIDS in every Schools I order to decrease rates of unintended
pregnancy and acquisition of STDs and HIV infection.
· Should be considered appropriate sites for the
availability of condoms, because they contain large adolescent populations and
may potentially provide a comprehensive array of related educational and health
care resources.
· To be most effective, condom availability programs should
be developed through a collaborative community process and accompanied by
comprehensive sequential sexuality education, with parental involvement,
counseling, and positive peer support.
· It is urge to encourage research focus on qualitative
method in order to increase consistent condom use by sexually active
adolescents. These researchesmust evaluate andenhance effectiveness of
strategies to promote condom use, through condom education information and
communication of behavioral change.
|